Pages
(Move to ...)
Home
Law Web Search Engine
Privacy Policy - Law Web
Disclaimer
Terms of Use
▼
Showing posts with label
O 41 R 22 of CPC
.
Show all posts
Showing posts with label
O 41 R 22 of CPC
.
Show all posts
Friday, 2 August 2024
Whether plaintiff should value his appeal on the basis of combined valuation of the plaint and counterclaim where both suit and counter-claim are dismissed?
›
Where both suit and counter-claim are dismissed, the subject-matter of the appeal would be the plaint. Hence valuation would be as per the...
Whether the District Court (Appellate Court) lacks jurisdiction to entertain appeal when valuation of cross-objection exceeds pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Court?
›
Having noticed the change in old Code and new unamended Code of Civil Procedure, let me now turn to the further legislative change brought ...
Wednesday, 4 October 2023
What is the basic concept of legal right and how this concept is relevant to decide who is “person aggrieved” ?
›
In this context, we may refer to a recent pronouncement in Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan v. The State of Maharashtra & ors. 2012 (11) SCAL...
Monday, 2 October 2023
Whether Cross Objections Have All Trappings Of Regular Appeal and it Must Be Considered In Full?
›
In the present case at hand, the Appellants herein, in the court of first appeal filed a cross objection. It is the claim of the Appellant...
Whether Second appellate court should remand the case if first appellate court has failed to give it findings on cross objection?
›
In the present case at hand, the Appellants herein, in the court of first appeal filed a cross objection. It is the claim of the Appellants...
Tuesday, 31 August 2021
Supreme Court: A party can challenge adverse findings without filing cross objection
›
The effect of the amendment was considered in Banarsi & Ors. v. Ram Phal (2003) 9 SCC 606. , where this Court held that after the 1976...
Sunday, 2 August 2020
Supreme Court judgment on cross-objection in appeals under the Motor Vehicles Act
›
A conjoint reading of the provisions of Section 173 of the M.V. Act; Rule 249 of the Bihar Motor Vehicle Rules, 1992; and Order XLI Rule 2...
Sunday, 7 June 2020
Whether cross objection is maintainable in a civil revision application?
›
The crossobjections contemplated under O.41 R.22 are in the nature of substantive right available to the person interested in opposing th...
Tuesday, 21 April 2020
Whether cross-objection will fail if civil appeal is rejected for non payment of court fees?
›
The next question which arises is with regard to cross-objections. In my opinion, it is quite clear that if an appeal is rejected for non-...
Leading Supreme Court judgment Banarsi Vs. Ram Phal on Cross-objection
›
A right to file cross objection is the exercise of right to appeal though in a different form. It was observed in Sahadu Gangaram Bhagade...
Sunday, 15 September 2019
Whether defendant can file cross objection if suit against it is dismissed in default?
›
We find that the High Court has failed to draw the distinction between the decree and a finding on an issue. It is the decree against...
Sunday, 25 August 2019
Whether cross objection filed by one respondent against other respondent is maintainable?
›
The Apex Court observed in Panna Lal Vs. State of Bombay MANU/SC/0240/1963 : AIR 1963 SC 1516 (C) In our opinion, the view that has...
Saturday, 27 July 2019
Whether first appellate court can examine legality of finding recorded in favour of plaintiff in absence of cross objection of defendant?
›
Mere perusal of the judgment of the Trial Court would go to show that while answering the issues, the Trial Court had divided issue No. 4 ...
Thursday, 18 July 2019
Whether it is mandatory for court to decide cross objection on merit independently if it has disposed off appeal on merit?
›
The High Court having dismissed the appeals filed by the State/NTPC was, therefore, required to examine as to whether any case was made o...
Tuesday, 25 December 2018
Whether appellate court can examine legality of finding recorded against a party in absence of cross objection?
›
This question, i.e., first part of issue No. 4 was decided by the Trial Court in Plaintiff's favour wherein it was held that Defendan...
Sunday, 16 December 2018
Whether appellate court can give relief to respondent?
›
Even a bare reading of Order 41, rule 33 is a sufficient to convince any one that the wide wording was intended to empower the appellate c...
What are advantages of filing cross objection?
›
In the case of Banarasi vs. Ram Phal (supra) , the Hon'ble Supreme Court has taken into consideration the amendment of the aforesaid ...
Sunday, 19 August 2018
Whether decree can be re-opened by appellate court in absence of cross objection by affected party?
›
In so far as the first substantial question of law is concerned, it can be seen that the trial Court while answering Issue No. 1 held tha...
Saturday, 12 May 2018
Notes on Civil appeal
›
APPEALS FROM ORIGINAL DECREE: S 96-99A .Order 41 of CPC. The word appeal has not been defined in the code. The term refers to the...
Sunday, 11 March 2018
Whether respondent in writ petition while supporting order passed in his favour can challenge findings recorded against him?
›
So far as the first point is concerned, Order 41, rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure confers two distinct rights on the respondent in ...
›
Home
View web version