Abatement of proceedings in Indian law refers to the automatic termination or suspension of a legal proceeding due to specific events affecting the parties involved. It is governed primarily by Order XXII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
Definition and Scope
Abatement refers to the cessation or termination of a legal proceeding without a final determination on the merits, primarily due to specific events affecting the parties involved. It can also mean the suspension or termination of proceedings either of the main action, or the proceedings ancillary or collateral to it.
Legal Framework
The provisions governing abatement are found in Order XXII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which applies to:
-
Both plaintiffs and defendants
-
Appeals as well as original suits
-
Various rules covering different scenarios
Situations Leading to Abatement
Death of a Party
The most common cause of abatement occurs when a plaintiff or defendant dies during the pendency of a suit. However, abatement only occurs if:
-
The right to sue does not survive the deceased party
-
The legal representative is not substituted within the prescribed time
Other Circumstances
-
Marriage of a Female Party: The marriage of a female plaintiff or defendant does not cause the suit to abate
-
Insolvency of a Party: The insolvency of a plaintiff does not automatically lead to abatement, and the assignee or receiver may continue the suit
Time Limits for Substitution
The Limitation Act, 1963 prescribes specific periods for substitution applications:
-
90 days: To file an application for substitution from the date of death of the party
-
60 days: To set aside the abatement from the date of abatement
If the legal heir or representative is not substituted within 90 days, the suit abates automatically by operation of law.
Consequences of Abatement
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Against deceased plaintiff | The entire suit may abate if right to sue does not survive |
| Against one of multiple plaintiffs | Suit may proceed with others if right survives |
| Against one of multiple defendants | Suit continues against others unless defense is joint |
| In appeal | Appeal abates if appellant or respondent dies without substitution |
An abated suit can be revived under Order XXII Rule 9 by demonstrating:
-
Sufficient cause for not substituting legal representatives in time
-
The application must be filed with a delay condonation petition under Section 5 of the Limitation Act
If granted, the court revives the suit from where it abated.
Important Exceptions
Abatement does not occur in certain situations:
-
When the right to sue survives against or in favor of other plaintiffs or defendants
-
If death happens after hearing is complete but before judgment
-
In representative suits, the court must give notice to interested parties before declaring abatement
Key Case Law
Several landmark judgments have clarified the principles of abatement:
-
Union of India v. Ram Charan (1964): Held that abatement occurs automatically after expiry of the limitation period if substitution is not made
-
Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom v. Bhargavi Amma (2008): Emphasized that procedural laws like abatement must be used to aid justice, not defeat it, and that ignorance of death does not automatically constitute sufficient cause for setting aside abatement
Distinction from Dismissal
| Basis | Abatement | Dismissal |
|---|---|---|
| Reason | Procedural lapse (death, non-substitution) | Judicial decision on merits or default |
| Effect | Suit ends without decision on merits | Suit ends with a legal or factual finding |
| Revival | Can be revived with sufficient cause | May require appeal or new filing |
No comments:
Post a Comment