Showing posts with label agriculturist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label agriculturist. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 January 2017

When businessman or housewife can become agriculturist?

Original plaintiff, who had obtained permission has died.
The present petitioners are her heirs and they seek to execute the decree. Shri Bhangade, learned senior counsel, submits that it should be shown by these heirs also that they are agriculturist in their own right. According to him, simply because of succession they will not become agriculturist. The submission is fallacious and is to be rejected to be stated. When an agricultural land devolves upon heirs, every heir gets share in it. As soon as share devolves upon him, he becomes an agriculturist whether or not he holds other agricultural land. If such a course is not to be followed, then no heir would be able to succeed to the self-acquired agricultural land of his father upon his dying intestate. All such lands in such case would always revert to the government. It must be said that a person upon whom such agricultural land devolves automatically becomes an agriculturist whether or not he cultivates the land personally thereafter. He can always cultivate a land through agricultural labourer.
Bombay High Court
Amarjyot Singh Jaswant Singh vs State Of Maharashtra on 18 July, 2009
Bench: C. L. Pangarkar
Citation: 2009(5) ALLMR 791 Bom, 2009(6) MHLJ 115
Print Page

Tuesday, 3 May 2016

When jurisdiction of civil court is barred for deciding issue of being agriculturist for purchase of land?

Thus, both on principle and on authority there is no escape from the conclusion that where in a suit properly constituted and cognizable by the Civil Court upon a contest an issue arises which is required to be settled, decided or dealt with by a competent authority under the Tenancy Act, the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to settle, decide or deal with the same is not only ousted but the civil Court is under a statutory obligation to refer the issue to the competent authority under the Tenancy Act to decide the same and upon the reference being answered back, to dispose of the suit in accordance with the decision of the competent authority under the Tenancy Act.
If plaintiff sued for specific performance of a contract for sale of agricultural land governed by the provisions of the Tenancy Act in the Civil Court and the defendant appeared and raised a contention that in view of the provisions contained in s. 63 of the Tenancy Act the plaintiff being not an agriculturist he is barred from purchasing the land, the issue would arise whether the plaintiff is an agriculturist. Such an issue being within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Mamlatdar, it is incumbent upon the Civil Court to refer the issue to the competent authority under the Tenancy Act and the civil Court has no jurisdiction to decide or deal with the same. That issue arises in the suit from which the present appeal arises and both the trial Court and the High Court were in error in clutching at a jurisdiction which did not vest in them and, therefore, on this ground alone this appeal will succeed.
Supreme Court of India

Gundaji Satwaji Shinde vs Ramchandra Bhikaji Joshi on 5 December, 1978
Equivalent citations: 1979 AIR 653, 1979 SCR (2) 586
Bench: Desai, D.A.
           
Print Page

Whether Civil court can decide Issue as to whether plaintiff is an agriculturist?

It clearly appears from the observations in paragraph 14 of the trial Court's judgment and paragraph 13 of the first appellate
Court's judgment that both the Courts indeed held that the defendant
had failed to prove that the plaintiff was not an agriculturist, though
the Courts had not framed an issue in that regard. It appears from
the evidence of the parties that in the absence of framing of the issue,
the parties were not aware that they were required to prove that the
plaintiff was an agriculturist or not. In fact, the first appellate Court
considered some documents which were not permitted to be produced
on record under the provisions of order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, while holding that the defendant had failed to prove that
the plaintiff was not an agriculturist. In view of the provisions of
Section 89 of the Act of 1958, the transfer of agricultural lands to non
agriculturist is barred, provided that the Collector or Officer
authorized by the State Government grants permission for such a
transfer. Since, the suit was filed by the plaintiff for specific
performance of contract and since the transfer of agricultural lands to
a non agriculturist was barred under Section 89 of the Act of 1958, it
was necessary for the trial court to have framed the issue as to
whether the plaintiff was an agriculturist and to have further remitted
the issue to the authority under the Act of 1958 for a decision on the
same. It is held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Gundaji
Satwaji Shinde ..vs. Ramchandra Bhikaji Joshi reported in 1979 Mh
L J. 283 that if an issue arises in a civil court as to whether a person is
an agriculturist within the meaning of Tenancy Act, the Mamlatdar
alone would have exclusive jurisdiction under the Tenancy Act to
decide the same and the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is ousted. The
Court further added that if the Mamlatdar were to hold that the
plaintiff was not an agriculturist, obviously his suit for specific
performance in the civil court would fail because he is ineligible to
purchase the agricultural land. The Hon'ble Supreme Court had
considered the provisions of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Act
(67 of 1948), while deciding the issue. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
then added that it could be incumbent on the civil Court in such a case
to refer the issue to the competent authority under the Tenancy Act.
However, in the instant case, the civil Court took upon itself
the task of deciding the issue as to whether the plaintiff was an
agriculturist, without specifically framing the issue. Both the Courts
were, therefore, not justified in observing that the defendant had
failed to prove that the plaintiff was an agriculturist, without framing
the issue and without referring the same to the tenancy authority, for
a decision on the same. The second substantial question of law framed
in this second appeal is answered in the affirmative and in favour of
the appellant.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
SECOND APPEAL NO. 289 OF 1996.


 Ashok s/o Kisan Muneshwar,Vs Janardhan s/o Parashram Bhagat,


CORAM : Smt. Vasanti A. Naik, J.
DATED : 09th September, 2008.

Print Page