Showing posts with label discrepancy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label discrepancy. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 March 2026

Supreme court: What will be impact of Material vs. Normal Discrepancies on credibility of prosecution witnesses?

 In State of Rajasthan v. Smt. Kalki and Anr.   MANU/SC/0254/1981 : AIR 1981 SC 1390, while dealing with this issue, this Court observed as under:


In the depositions of witnesses there are always normal discrepancies, however honest and truthful they may be. These discrepancies are due to normal errors of observation, normal errors of memory due to lapse of time, due to mental disposition such as shock and horror at the time of the occurrence, and the like. Material discrepancies are those which are not normal, and not expected of a normal person. {Para 18}

19. The courts have to label the category to which a discrepancy belongs. While normal discrepancies do not corrode the credibility of a party's case, material discrepancies do so. (see: Syed Ibrahim v. State of A.P.   MANU/SC/8237/2006 : AIR 2006 SC 2908; and Arumugam v. State   MANU/SC/8108/2008 : AIR 2009 SC 331).


20. In Bihari Nath Goswami v. Shiv Kumar Singh and Ors.   MANU/SC/0158/2004 : (2004) 9 SCC 186, this Court examined the issue and held:


Exaggerations per se do not render the evidence brittle. But it can be one of the factors to test credibility of the prosecution version, when the entire evidence is put in a crucible for being tested on the touchstone of credibility.

21. While deciding such a case, the Court has to apply the aforesaid tests. Mere marginal variations in the statements cannot be dubbed as improvements as the same may be elaborations of the statement made by the witness earlier. The omissions which amount to contradictions in material particulars i.e. go to the root of the case/materially affect the trial or core of the prosecution's case, render the testimony of the witness liable to be discredited.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 891 of 2004

Decided On: 11.11.2010

Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P. Sathasivam and B.S. Chauhan, JJ.

Author: B.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 770,2011 ALLMR 288 (SC),MANU/SC/0947/2010.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Saturday, 28 October 2017

How to appreciate evidence if there is discrepancy in pleading and evidence due to passing of time?

The only other point which requires consideration in this appeal is whether the decision of the lower appellate court remanding the suit to the trial court for a determination of the question of partial ejectment can be upheld or not. On this question the decision of the lower appellate court proceeds on the basis that since there is some discrepancy on the question of requirement of the plaintiffs, in the evidence of the plaintiff No. 1 and the statements made in paragraph 9 of the plaint, the plaintiffs' case that they require the entire disputed premises for their own use and occupation cannot be accepted. The discrepancy noticed by the lower appellate court is that in paragraph 9 of the plaint it has been stated that the plaintiff No. 1 requires at least 4 rooms for his chamber and nursing home, but in evidence the plaintiff No. 1 has stated that he requires 9 or 10 rooms for his nursing home. It is true that this discrepancy is there regarding the number of rooms required by the plaintiff. But it must not be lost sight of that the suit was filed in January 1965 and the plaintiff No. 1 was deposing in court in May. 1972. In our view, the plaintiff No. 1 was not required to nor could be expected to mention exactly the same number of rooms which he requires because of the intervening period of about 71/2 years. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

A.F.A.D. Nos. 989 and 1084 of 1973

Decided On: 23.03.1978

Dr. Gurokesh Debangshi and Anr. Vs. Bimalendra Nath Banerjee

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Janah and D.C. Chakraverty, JJ.
Citation: AIR 1978 Calcutta 332
Print Page

Sunday, 15 October 2017

How to appreciate evidence of witness if there is minor discrepancy on trivial matters in his statement?

It is a settled legal proposition that while appreciating the evidence of a witness, minor discrepancies on trivial matters, which do not affect the core of the prosecution's case, may not prompt the court to reject the evidence in its entirety. "Irrelevant details which do not in any way corrode the credibility of a witness cannot be labelled as omissions or contradictions." Difference in some minor details, which does not otherwise affect the core of the prosecution case, even if present, would not itself prompt the court to reject the evidence on minor variations and discrepancies. After exercising care and caution and sifting through the evidence to separate truth from untruth, exaggeration and improvements, the court comes to a conclusion as to whether the residuary evidence is sufficient to convict the accused. Thus, an undue importance should not be attached to omissions, contradictions and discrepancies which do not go to the heart of the matter and shake the basic version of the prosecution witness. As the mental capabilities of a human being cannot be expected to be attuned to absorb all the details, minor discrepancies are bound to occur in the statements of witnesses. 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1584 of 2010

Decided On: 20.07.2017

 State of U.P. Vs.Ram Kumar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Sikri and Ashok Bhushan, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017SC 3878
Print Page

Friday, 5 May 2017

How to appreciate evidence if there is discrepancy in injury certificate and post mortem report?

The third point raised before us is that in the wound
certificate (Ext. P-4) there are only two injuries, i.e. bone
fracture of right leg and puncture wound below left angle of
mandible covered with blood are mentioned, while in the post
mortem report there are nine ante mortem injuries. As such
there is apparent discrepancy between the two documents.
On deeper scrutiny, we find that there is no material
contradiction for the reason that PW-3 Dr. Nanda Koti has
proved Ext. P-4(b) wherein it has been mentioned that the
patient needed immediate treatment, as such, only gross
injuries were entered in the register (not the minor injuries)
and the patient was shifted to emergency ward. In the
cross-examination he has clearly stated that Basavaraj
(deceased) was unconscious. In the circumstances, addition of
stitched wounds in post mortem report (Ext. P-2) does not
create doubt regarding the incident in question.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 435 OF 2006
M. G. Eshwarappa and others 
V
State of Karnataka.
Citation:AIR 2017 SC1197
Print Page

Monday, 1 May 2017

How to appreciate evidence if there is discrepancy in evidence of witness?

 Thus, in criminal trial a prosecutor is faced with so many odds. The Court while appreciating the evidence should not lose sight of these realities of life and cannot affored to take an unrealistic approach by sitting in ivory tower. I find that in recent times the tendency to acquit an accused easily is galloping fast. It is very easy to pass an order of acquittal on the basis of minor points raised in the case b a short judgment so as to achieve the yardstick of disposal. Some discrepancy is bound to be there in each and every case which should not weigh with the Court so long it does not materially affect the prosecution case. In case discrepancies pointed out are in the realm of pebbled court should tread upon, it, but if the same are boulders, court should not make an attempt to jump over the same. 
Citation : 2002 CriLJ 2645
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal No. 761 of 2001 and Death Reference No. 1 of 2001
Decided On: 15.04.2002
Krishna Mochi and Ors.
Vs.
State of Bihar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.B. Shah, B.N. Agrawal and Dr. Arijit Pasayat, JJ.

Print Page

Tuesday, 22 November 2016

What is distinction between discrepancy and contradiction for appreciation of evidence?

 In the case of State of Himachal Pradesh Vs. Lekh Raj MANU/SC/0714/1999 : (2003)1 SCC 247 the apex court had held that:
Discrepancy has to be distinguished from contradiction whereas contradiction in the statement of the witness is fatal for the case, minor discrepancy or variance in evidence will not make the prosecution's case doubtful. The normal course of the human conduct would be that while narrating a particular incident there may occur minor discrepancies, such discrepancies in law may render credential to the depositions. Parrot-like statements are disfavored by the courts, In order to ascertain as to whether the discrepancy pointed out was minor or not or the same amounted to contradiction, regard is required to be had to the circumstances of the case by keeping in view the social status of the witnesses and environment in which such witness was making the statement.
5.7 In the case of Krishna Pillai Sree Kumar Vs. State of Kerala reported in MANU/SC/0166/1981 : 1981 Supp. SCC 31: 1981 CriLJ 743, the apex Court has held that it is no doubt true that the prosecution evidence does suffer from consistencies here and discrepancies there but that is a shortcoming from which no criminal case is free. The main thing to be seen is whether those inconsistencies, etc., go to the root of the matter or pertain to insignificant aspects thereof. In the former case, the defence may be justified in seeking advantage of the incongruities obtaining in the evidence. In the latter, however, no such benefit may be available to it. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI (AGARTALA BENCH)
Crl. Appeal No. 115 (J) of 2008
Decided On: 19.10.2012

 Ranjit Sarkar Vs. State of Tripura

Coram:Brojendra Prasad Katakey and S.C. Das, JJ.

Citation:2013 (1) GLT709
Print Page