concerned, there is no room to draw any other inference that the
petitioner did threaten the Chief Officer by showing him a chappal
on 20.02.2014. A reference is made to the CCTV footage in the
report of the Collector as well as in the impugned order. The CCTV
footage was made available for perusal of the Court and we have
seen the CCTV footage in the presence of learned Counsel for both
the parties. On viewing the CCTV footage, it is abundantly clear
that the petitioner did threaten the Chief Officer by showing a
footwear (chappal). He was standing in a threatening posture. The
conduct of the petitioner in threatening the Chief Officer, by
showing him footwear and adapting a threatening posture, shall
have to be branded as disgraceful. We are satisfied in respect of
occurrence of incident upon viewing the CCTV footage. It
has neither been contended in the petition nor has been argued
that the CCTV footage is manipulated or morphed.
So far as expression “disgraceful” is concerned, the
New Oxford American Dictionary explains it to mean shockingly
unacceptable. In the New International Webster's Comprehensive
Dictionary, 'disgraceful' is set out as characterized by or causing
disgrace, shameful. In P. Ramanatha Aiyar's Law Lexicon,
'disgraceful conduct' is described as shameful behaviour. It
further sets out that it need not be circumscribed to something
done in the course of one's duty as member or office bearer. The
term “disgraceful conduct” would mean any allegation which,
because it is done by an elected member or office bearer, is
sufficiently reprehensible to be classified as disgraceful.
17 Considering the meaning attached to the term
'disgraceful', we are of the considered view that the alleged
misconduct of the petitioner shall have to be branded as shameful
behaviour and is shockingly unacceptable.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.1430 OF 2016
Nandkumar alias Laxman Sahadu V The State of Maharashtra,
CORAM : R.M.BORDE &
K.L.WADANE, JJ.
DATE : 07th June, 2016
