Before parting with this case, however, we must strike a
note of caution, as has been done by the Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court. It could not be gainsaid that the employers
have a right to take disciplinary actions and to hold domestic
enquiries against their erring employees. But for doing so, the
standing orders governing the field have to be followed by such
employers. These standing orders give sufficient protection to
the concerned employees against whom such departmental
enquiries are proceeded with. If such departmental proceedings
initiated by serving of chargesheets are brought in challenge at
different stages of such proceedings by the concerned
employees invoking the relevant clauses of Item 1 of Schedule IV
before the final orders of discharge or dismissal are passed, the
Labour Court dealing with such complaint should not lightly
interfere with such pending domestic enquiries against the
concerned complainants. The Labour Court concerned should
meticulously scan the allegations in the complaint and if
necessary, get the necessary investigation made in the light of
such complaint and only when a very strong prime facie case is
made out by the complainant appropriate interim orders
intercepting such domestic enquiries in exercise of powers under
Section 30(2) can be passed by the Labour Courts. Such orders
should not be passed for mere askance by the Labour Courts.
Otherwise, the very purpose of holding domestic enquiries as
per the standing orders would get frustrated.”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.4086 OF 2016
Ashok Rambhaji Tupe,
V
The Maharashtra State Road Transport
( CORAM : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.)
DATE : 07/04/2016
Citation: 2016(6) ALLMR 630
Print Page
note of caution, as has been done by the Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court. It could not be gainsaid that the employers
have a right to take disciplinary actions and to hold domestic
enquiries against their erring employees. But for doing so, the
standing orders governing the field have to be followed by such
employers. These standing orders give sufficient protection to
the concerned employees against whom such departmental
enquiries are proceeded with. If such departmental proceedings
initiated by serving of chargesheets are brought in challenge at
different stages of such proceedings by the concerned
employees invoking the relevant clauses of Item 1 of Schedule IV
before the final orders of discharge or dismissal are passed, the
Labour Court dealing with such complaint should not lightly
interfere with such pending domestic enquiries against the
concerned complainants. The Labour Court concerned should
meticulously scan the allegations in the complaint and if
necessary, get the necessary investigation made in the light of
such complaint and only when a very strong prime facie case is
made out by the complainant appropriate interim orders
intercepting such domestic enquiries in exercise of powers under
Section 30(2) can be passed by the Labour Courts. Such orders
should not be passed for mere askance by the Labour Courts.
Otherwise, the very purpose of holding domestic enquiries as
per the standing orders would get frustrated.”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.4086 OF 2016
Ashok Rambhaji Tupe,
V
The Maharashtra State Road Transport
( CORAM : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.)
DATE : 07/04/2016
Citation: 2016(6) ALLMR 630