Showing posts with label eclipse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label eclipse. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 April 2016

When Civil court has jurisdiction to entertain suit in respect of Trust property?

In the instant case, as indicated above, the Suit has inter alia been
filed for cancellation of the Sale Deed dated 2/7/2012 executed in favour of
the Defendant No.7 by the Defendant Nos. 2 to 6.  In pursuit of the said reliefs,
the Plaintiffs have made averments in the plaint as to how a fraud has been
practiced upon them by the Defendant No.7 by getting the Sale Deed executed
in his sole name when there was a Memorandum of Understanding entered
into between the Trustees and the Plaintiffs and the Defendant No.7 in respect
of the suit property. No doubt the Sale Deed has been executed after the
sanction order was granted by the Charity Commissioner, however, what is
required to be borne in mind is the fact that after the Sale Deed is executed,
the property no more remains the property of the Trust, and in fact has become
the property of the Defendant No.7.  Since the Plaintiffs have a grievance in
respect of the Sale Deed which has been executed solely in favour of the
Defendant No.7, the Plaintiffs in seeking the relief of cancellation of the Sale
Deed can be said to be agitating their civil rights.  Though the Sale Deed is
executed   pursuant   to   the   order   passed  under   Section   36   of   the   said   Act,
however the fact of execution of the Sale Deed,  has over taken the order of the
Charity Commissioner granting sanction  under Section  36 of the said Act.
Hence there is no merit in the contention of the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Applicant that the Plaintiffs in challenging the Sale Deed are in

fact challenging the order passed by the Joint Charity Commissioner under
Section 36 of the said Act. Considering the reliefs which are sought in the
Plaint, it may be that some of the reliefs cannot be granted by the Civil Court,
however, as rightly held by the Trial Court in the impugned order, the Suit is
maintainable before it in respect of some of the reliefs. Hence pre­requisites for
attracting the bar under Section 80 of the said Act are non­existent. It is
required to be noted that the challenge to the Sale Deed inter­alia on the
ground of fraud cannot be raised before the Charity Commissioner and the
same can only be raised by way of a Civil Suit. The Trial Court therefore can be
said to have correctly held that the Suit in respect of some of the reliefs was
maintainable before it.  Hence though some of reliefs cannot be granted by the
Civil Court in view of the bar under Section 80 of the said Act, at the same
time the Authorities under the said Act, cannot grant the relief by way of
prayer clause (a) and the said prayer can only be granted by a Civil Court. The
Trial Court has also taken into consideration the fact that for setting aside the
order passed under Section 36 of the said Act, the Plaintiffs have filed an
application under Section 36(2) of the said Act as the same obviously cannot
be challenged by way of a Suit.   As regards the contention of the learned
counsel for the Applicant that the Trial Court has erroneously proceeded on the
basis of the maintainability of the Suit whereas the question was about its
jurisdiction. In my view,  in some cases the issue of maintainability of Suit and
the issue of jurisdiction of Court eclipse each other, one such case can be said

to be the present one. Therefore, the order passed by the Trial Court ruling that
it has jurisdiction is well founded. It cannot be said that the Trial Court has
acted with material irregularity or in excess of its jurisdiction whilst holding
that it has jurisdiction to try and entertain the Suit.  In that view of the matter,
no case for exercise of the revisionary jurisdiction is made out.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO.785 OF 2013
Pratap Shivaji Chumbale 
Versus
 Deepak Vishanath Pingale,

CORAM      : R. M. SAVANT, J.

Pronounced on : 13th December 2013
Citation; 2015 (7) ALLMR349
Print Page