Showing posts with label entitlement to relief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label entitlement to relief. Show all posts

Sunday, 26 January 2025

Supreme Court: Order II Rule 2 CPC Doesn't Mean Different Causes Of Action From Same Transaction Must Be Included In Single Suit

 In S. Nazeer Ahmed v. State Bank of Mysore and Ors. reported in   MANU/SC/7017/2007 : 2007:INSC:34 : (2007) 11 SCC 75, this Court categorically held that if the Defendant wishes to show that the causes of action were identical in both suits, it is necessary for him to have marked the earlier plaint in evidence and then make out that there was a relinquishment of a relief by the Plaintiff, without the leave of the Court. It was also stated that Order II Rule 2 is directed towards securing an exhaustion of the relief in respect of a cause of action and not to the inclusion in one and the same action of different causes of action, even though they may arise from the same transaction. In other words, a number of causes of action may arise out of the same transaction and it is not the mandate of Order II Rule 2 that they should all be included in one suit. On the other hand, what is required is that every suit shall include the "whole of the claim" arising out of "one and the same cause of action". {Para 46}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 372-373 of 2025.

Decided On: 15.01.2025

Cuddalore Powergen Corporation Ltd. Vs. Chemplast Cuddalore Vinyls Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 73,MANU/SC/0071/2025.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Defendant must file pleadings of previous suit to prove the identity of the cause of action in the two suits so as to bar second suit as per O 2 R 2 of CPC

In order that a plea of a Bar Under Order 2 Rule 2(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure should succeed the Defendant who raises the plea must make out; (i) that the second suit was in respect of the same cause of action as that on which the previous suit was based; (2) that in respect of that cause of action the Plaintiff was entitled to more than one relief; (3) that being thus entitled to more than one relief the Plaintiff, without leave obtained from the Court omitted to sue for the relief for which the second suit had been filed. From this analysis it would be seen that the Defendant would have to establish primarily and to start with, the precise cause of action upon which the previous suit was filed, for unless there is identity between the cause of action on which the earlier suit was filed and that on which the claim in the latter suit is based there would be no scope for the application of the bar. No doubt, a relief which is sought in a plaint could ordinarily be traceable to a particular cause of action but this might, by no means, be the universal rule. As the plea is a technical bar it has to be established satisfactorily and cannot be presumed merely on basis of inferential reasoning. It is for this reason that we consider that a plea of a bar Under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure can be established only if the Defendant files in evidence the pleadings in the previous suit and thereby proves to the Court the identity of the cause of action in the two suits. It is common ground that the pleadings in CS 28 of 1950 were not filed by the Appellant in the present suit as evidence in support of his plea Under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned Trial Judge, however, without these pleadings being on the record inferred what the cause of action should have been from the reference to the previous suit contained in the plaint as a matter of deduction. At the stage of the appeal the learned District Judge noticed this lacuna in the Appellant's case and pointed out, in our opinion, rightly that without the plaint in the previous suit being on the record, a plea of a bar Under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure was not maintainable.

 {Para 6}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 372-373 of 2025.

Decided On: 15.01.2025

Cuddalore Powergen Corporation Ltd. Vs. Chemplast Cuddalore Vinyls Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 73,MANU/SC/0071/2025.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Whether plaintiff will be barred to file second suit on the cause of action if he was not entitled to said relief at the time of filing of first suit?

V. The "entitlement to" along with the "availability of" the relief as a requisite in determining the applicability of Order II Rule 2.

72. The Privy Council in Mohammad Khalil Khan (supra) elaborated on the true import of Order II Rule 2 as follows:

Shortly stated Order 2, Rule 2, Code of Civil Procedure, enacts that if a Plaintiff fails to sue for the whole of the claim which he is entitled to make in respect of a cause of action in the first suit, then he is precluded from suing in a second suit in respect of the portion so omitted. To apply the Rule to the facts of the case their Lordships will have to consider what was the cause of action in Suit No. 8, on which the Plaintiffs founded their claims, and whether they included all the claims which they were entitled to make in respect of that cause of action in that suit. For, if they failed to include all the claims, then by force of Order 2, Rule 2, they are precluded from including the claim omitted in the present Suit No. 2.

73. Order II Rule 2(1) reads that - "every suit shall include the whole of the claim which the Plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action...". Similarly, Order II Rule 2(3) reads that - "A person entitled to more than one relief in respect of the same cause of action may sue for all or any of such reliefs...". It is necessary that the same intention also be read into Order II Rule 2(2) which reads that - "where a Plaintiff omits to sue in respect of, or intentionally relinquishes, any portion of his claim, he shall not afterwards sue in respect of the portion so omitted or relinquished". The phrase "any portion of his claim" must essentially be understood to mean any portion of his claim which he is entitled to make for the simple reason that there cannot be a deliberate or intentional relinquishment of any portion of a claim, if the Plaintiff was not entitled to it. Therefore, the true import of the bar Under Order II Rule 2 must be that it operates to preclude a Plaintiff from instituting a second suit, on the same cause of action, for a claim, any portion of a claim, or reliefs, which the Plaintiff was entitled to avail at the time of filing of the first suit.

74. There may arise a situation where the Plaintiff may be entitled to a relief but such a relief was not available at a certain point in time. In other words, that obtaining such a relief was impossible due to the circumstances which existed during the institution of the first suit. It is our opinion that, in such scenarios, Courts must give such an interpretation to the principles Under Order II Rule 2 that is not bogged down by mere technicalities.

75. We are in agreement with the view taken by the Rajasthan High Court in Ramjilal v. Board of Revenue, Rajasthan reported in   MANU/RH/0033/1964 : AIR 1964 Raj 114 wherein the High Court had opined that Order II Rule 2 does not require that a person must seek all the remedies to which he may be entitled to even though it would be impossible for him to obtain the remedy from the opposite party. Herein, it was not possible for the Plaintiff to obtain the relief of possession from the Respondent No. 2 in his initial suit since the Respondent No. 2 himself was put in actual possession of the property much after the institution of the first suit. In such circumstances, it could not be said that the Plaintiff had intentionally relinquished any portion of his claim or that he omitted to ask for a relief which he could otherwise obtain. The relevant observations are reproduced hereinbelow:

8. Now, in the present case, when the Petitioner filed the first suit on 14th August, 1946, his claim was only for a declaration to the effect that the adoption of Respondent No. 2 by Pusharam was invalid in law and for the relief that the adoption-deed should be cancelled. According to the admission of Respondent No. 2 himself he was not in possession of the property in respect of which the second suit was filed on 1st July, 1954. It cannot therefore, be said that the Plaintiff had intentionally relinquished any portion of his claim or that he omitted to ask for a relief which he could get from Respondent No. 2. Even if he had sued for possession against Respondent No. 2, he could not obtain a decree for possession against a person who was admittedly not in occupation of the same. It would, therefore, have been futile on the part of the Petitioner to sue for possession against Respondent No. 2 at that time. Order 2, Rule 2 Code of Civil Procedure does not require that a person must seek all the remedies to which he may be entitled even though it be impossible for him to obtain them from the opposite party. It is true that Respondent No. 2 had obtained a decree for possession against the landlords on 18th February, 1946, i.e., about six months prior to the institution of the Petitioner's suit, but the Petitioner was not a party to that suit. It had nowhere been mentioned in the judgment of the learned Members of the Board of Revenue if the Petitioner was even aware of the decree which Respondent No. 2 had obtained against the landlords Moreover, even if it be assumed for the sake of argument that the said decree was in the knowledge of the Petitioner, then too, he could not sue for possession, because Respondent No. 2 was not put in actual possession of the property in execution of the decree. It was about three years after, i.e., on 11th March, 1949 that Respondent No. 2 got possession of the property. In our opinion, the learned Members committed an error, which is patent on the face of the record, in holding that the Petitioner ought to have sued for possession at the time when he filed the first suit on 14th August, 1946.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 372-373 of 2025.

Decided On: 15.01.2025

Cuddalore Powergen Corporation Ltd. Vs. Chemplast Cuddalore Vinyls Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 73,MANU/SC/0071/2025.

Print Page