In an attempt to upset the concurrent findings by the courts below, Shri. K.T. Sankaran, the learned counsel for the appellant, submitted that the opinion of the expert without corroboration is not conclusive of the genuineness of the thumb impression by the 1st defendant. He also argued that the court has to examine the report with the help of the photographs of the thumb impression and find out whether the report is acceptable or not.
In this connection, it is to be remembered that there is a difference between the opinion of the expert with regard to the handwriting and the Opinion of the expert with regard to the thumb impression. There is no forgery possible with regard to the thumb impression whereas an expert in forgery can write exactly like the original handwriting of another person. This distinction is well recognised by the decision of the Supreme Court. In Jaspal Singh v. State of Punjab (MANU/SC/0129/1979 : AIR 1979 SC 1708), the Supreme Court has stated that the science of identifying thumb impression is an exact science and does not admit of any mistake or doubt. This decision was followed by this Court in various decisions including the one by a Division Bench in James @ Chacko v. State (MANU/KE/0238/1994 : 1994) 1 KLJ 871) even in a case where the impression was smudged but not to the extent of impossibility of comparison.
Equivalent Citation: 2004(1)KLJ705, 2004(1)KLT991,(2004)2 crimes214
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
S.A. No. 932 of 1994 (C)
Decided On: 05.02.2004
Parukutty Amma & Another Vs. Thankam Amma & others
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:R. Bhaskaran, J.
