Showing posts with label majority award. Show all posts
Showing posts with label majority award. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 August 2023

Whether Dissenting Opinion Of An Arbitrator Can Be Treated As An Award If The Majority Award Is Set Aside?

In Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd, the court recollected the

previous holding in Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI (hereafter, “Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd.”) 2019 [7] SCR 522, wherein the court had set aside the majority award, but issued consequential directions in the peculiar facts of the case:

“In Ssangyong [Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co.

Ltd. v. NHAI, (2019) 7 SCR 522], this Court upheld the view taken by the dissenting arbitrator in exercise of its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, in order to do complete justice between the parties. The reason for doing so is mentioned in para 77 i.e. the considerable delay which would be caused if another arbitrationwas to be held. This Court exercised its extraordinary power in Ssangyong [Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI,] keeping in mind the facts of the case, and the object of expeditious resolution of disputes under the Arbitration Act.”

However, the court did not, in Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd (supra) direct the dissenting opinion to be treated as an award. In the opinion of this court, that approach is correct, because there appears to be a slight divergence in thinking between Russel and Gary Born. The former, Russel is careful to point out that a dissenting opinion is not per se an award, but “is for the parties' information only and does not form part of the award, but it may be admissible as evidence in relation to the procedural matters in the event of a challenge.” However, Gary Born does not expressly say that the opinion is not a part of the award. That author yet clarifies that “This is an essential aspect of the process by which the parties have an opportunity to both, present their case, and hear the reasons for the Tribunal's decision; not hearing the dissent deprives the parties of an important aspect of this process.” {Para 26}

27. It is, therefore, evident that a dissenting opinion cannot be treated as an award if the majority award is set aside. It might provide useful clues in case there is a procedural issue which becomes critical during the challenge hearings. This court is of the opinion that there is another dimension to the matter. When a majority award is challenged by the aggrieved party, the focus of the court and the aggrieved party is to point out the errors or illegalities in the majority award. The minority award (or dissenting opinion, as the learned authors point out) only embodies the views of the arbitrator disagreeing with the majority. There is no occasion for anyone- such as the party aggrieved by the majority award, or, more crucially, the party who succeeds in the majority award, to challenge the soundness, plausibility, illegality or perversity in the approach or conclusions in the dissenting opinion. That dissenting opinion would not receive the level and standard of scrutiny which the majority award (which is under challenge) is subjected to. Therefore, the so-called conversion of the dissenting opinion, into a tribunal’s findings, [in the event a majority award is set aside] and elevation of that opinion as an award, would, with respect, be inappropriate and improper.

 2023INSC768

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 4658 OF 2023

M/S HINDUSTAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED 

Vs M/S NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA

Author: S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.

Dated: AUGUST 24, 2023.

Print Page