In the present case on 7th January 2021 the petitioner had filed its Return of Income for AY 2020 -21 and the email id mentioned therein was loktax2016@rediffmail.com therefore the AO ought to have considered this email as provided u/r 127(1)(b)(i) email address available in the income tax return furnished by the addressee to which the communication relates which would be the primary email id or (ii) i.e. email address available in the last income tax return furnished by the addressee. In our view the AO clearly erred in issuing a notice on the secondary email address when there was a primary email address given by the petitioner. It is common knowledge that a secondary email address has to be used as an alternative or in such circumstances when the authority is unable to effect service of any communication on the primary address. There is no prudence in issuing an email on the secondary email address. In our view the AO ought to have sent the notice u/s. 148 to both the primary address and the email address mentioned in the last Return of Income filed to preempt a jurisdictional error on account of valid service; there was neither any cost to it or any prejudice to any party for sending it on more than one email in a given circumstance as in the present case. We see no wrong with the petitioner's refusal to participate in a proceeding vitiated by valid service of notice. This Court in the case of Mrs. Chitra Supekar vs. ITO in Writ Petition No. 15580 of 2022 has held that it was imperative for the AO to have checked if there was a change of address before initiating a proceeding; and that a valid service of notice under section 148 is a condition precedent lest it would be a jurisdictional error.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition Nos. 1983 of 2022, 3037 of 2022 and 3042 of 2022
Assessment Year: 2015-2016;2016-2017;2017-2018
Lok Developers Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income tax Circle 24(1) and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dhiraj Singh Thakur and Kamal Khata, JJ.
Author: Kamal Khata, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/0524/2023.
Decided On: 15.02.2023.
Citation: 2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 18.
Print Page