Showing posts with label time of death. Show all posts
Showing posts with label time of death. Show all posts

Monday, 21 October 2019

Whether time of occurrence can be doubted on ground that digested food has been found in stomach of deceased?

The appellant has sought to prove that the time of death was also
not proved as evidence from P.W.1 and P.W.3 came that they had gone
to the said chawk after meal. From this part of their deposition, the
appellant wants to establish that if that was the case, the stomach of
the deceased could have residue of undigested food. But this part of

the argument has been elaborately dealt with by the High Court and in
Para 13 of its Judgment the High Court observed and held:“
13. In this regard following opinion of Modi’s Medical
Jurisprudence and Toxicology, 23rd Edition at page 450 is
very relevant:‘
It must also be remembered that the process of
digestion in normal, healthy persons may
continue for a long time after death.’
It has come in evidence that at the time of death, the deceased
was aged about 28 years. Thus it is apparent that at that time
deceased was a young man. It has also come in evidence that
the postmortem
was held on 23.1.1993 at 11 a.m. Under the
aforesaid circumstance, because the deceased was a normal
young man of 28 years of age, digestion process might have
been continuing after the death of the deceased till the period
of postmortem
and in that view of the matter only because
digested food has been found in the stomach of deceased it
cannot be held that the prosecution had failed to prove the
time of occurrence that too in view of the cogent, clear and
acceptable evidence of P.W. 1 and 3.”

NON REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 935 OF 2011

PRABHASH KUMAR SINGH  Vs  THE STATE OF BIHAR (NOW JHARKHAND) 

Aniruddha Bose, J.
Dated:September 12, 2019.
Print Page

Thursday, 28 December 2017

Whether time of death can be ascertained by presence or absence of food in stomach of deceased?

 Now, we shall deal with the other aspect of the argument advanced on behalf of the Appellants i.e. in relation to uncertainty in the time of occurrence as well as death of the deceased, with reference to expert evidence. The contention is that as per the statement of PW-8, they had 'Bhel' just before the incident. However, according to the medical evidence, there were no food particles in the stomach of the deceased. Therefore, the version of PW-8 is falsified by the evidence of PW-10, more particularly, wherein she has stated that she did not find any food particles in the intestine of the deceased. According to the learned Counsel for the Appellants, this causes a serious doubt on the very basis of the prosecution story. This argument appears to be of some significance at the first brush, but when examined in depth in light of the entire evidence, it clearly lacks merit.



9. The presence or absence of food at the time of post-mortem in relation to the time of death is based on various factors and circumstances such as the type and nature of the food consumed, the time of taking the meal, the age of the person concerned and power and capacity of the person to digest the food. In the present case, though PW-8 has stated that he had 'Bhel' with the deceased just before the incident, there is no evidence about the exact time when the meals were taken or the quantity of 'Bhel' consumed by the deceased. Judging the time of death from the contents of the stomach, may not always be the determinative test. It will require due corroboration from other evidence. If the prosecution is able to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and cumulatively, the evidence of the prosecution, including the time of death, is proved beyond reasonable doubt and the same points towards the guilt of the accused, then it may not be appropriate for the court to wholly reject the case of the prosecution and to determine the time of death with reference to the stomach contents of the deceased. Even in Modi's Jurisprudence, it has been recorded as under:




... The state of the contents of the stomach found at the time of medical examination is not a safe guide for determining the time of the occurrence because that would be a matter of speculation, in the absence of reliable evidence on the question as to when the deceased had his last meal and what that meal consisted of.




Where there is positive direct evidence about the time of occurrence, it is not open to the court to speculate about the time of occurrence by the presence of faecal matter in the intestine. The question of time of death of the victim should not be decided only by taking into consideration the state of food in the stomach. That may be a factor which should be considered along with other evidence, but that fact alone cannot be decisive.




10. This Court in a catena of cases has stated the dictum that medical opinion is admissible in evidence like all other types of evidence and there is no hard-and-fast Rule with regard to appreciation of medical evidence. It is not to be treated as sacrosanct in its absolute terms. Agreeing with the view expressed in Modi's book on Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology, this Court recorded that so far as the food contents are concerned, they remain for long hours in the stomach and the duration thereof depends upon various other factors.




11. Further, in Malay Kumar Ganguly v. Sukumar Mukherjee MANU/SC/1416/2009 : AIR 2010 SC 1162, it has been held by this Court that the opinion could be admitted or denied. Whether such evidence could be admitted or how much weight should be given thereto, lies within the domain of the court.




12. It is clear from the depositions of the prosecution witnesses, viz., PW-5 and PW-8 which corroborates with the deposition of PW-10 that the injuries were sustained by a sharp cutting object and not by hard and blunt object. Further, the plea raised by learned Counsel for the Appellants with regard to non-founding of food particles in the intestine of the deceased is of no basis as the digestion varies with different person even with same material, and sometimes even with the same person at different times. With incomplete digestion, no reliable opinion can be given on a medical basis. In fact, there is no positive evidence that the deceased had 'Bhel' along with others. If the period of digestion is six hours, the food will be in semi-digested stage upto 2 to 2½ hours and if someone takes food then it remains in stomach for half an hour and then it goes to the intestine. Even if it be taken that the deceased had 'Bhel' along with others and five minutes thereafter the incident started in which he succumbed to his injuries, the food will not be converted into semi-digested state and the doctor will not find any food particles in the intestine. The digestion of food is one of the important data which guide the medical officer in arriving at an opinion as to the time of death. This is possible on internal examination.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA



Criminal Appeal Nos. 1962 of 2011 and 604 of 2012




Decided On: 03.08.2017




Sanjay Khanderao Wadane Vs. State of Maharashtra




Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.K. Sikri and R.K. Agrawal, JJ.

Citation:(2017) 11 SCC 842.
Print Page