LLM Notes: Subordinate Legislation in India

 Subordinate legislation, also known as delegated or secondary legislation, refers to laws or regulations made by an authority other than the sovereign legislative body (Parliament or State Legislature), but with its authorization. This authority is conferred through an enabling or parent Act, which sets out the broad framework and principles, while the subordinate authority (usually the executive, but sometimes judiciary, municipal bodies, or autonomous institutions) fills in the details necessary for implementation and administration.

Article 13(3) of the Indian Constitution explicitly includes orders, rules, regulations, and notifications within the definition of “law,” thereby recognizing various forms of subordinate legislation.

Purpose and Necessity

Subordinate legislation is necessary because:

• The legislature cannot anticipate every detail or future contingency when framing laws, especially given the increasing complexity of modern governance.

• It allows for flexibility, expertise, and speed in responding to technical or rapidly changing situations.

• It helps manage the legislative workload, as Parliament may not have time to address all specifics.

Types of Subordinate Legislation

Subordinate legislation in India can take several forms, including:

• Rules: Detailed provisions made by the executive to implement statutes.

• Regulations: Issued by regulatory authorities or statutory bodies.

• Bye-laws: Made by municipal or local authorities for local governance.

• Notifications and Orders: Issued by government departments for specific administrative purposes.

Other types include judicial rules (made by courts for their procedures) and regulations by autonomous bodies (like the University Grants Commission).

Mechanisms for Scrutiny and Control

Given that subordinate legislation involves law-making by unelected authorities, several checks and balances exist:

• Parliamentary Scrutiny: Both houses have Committees on Subordinate Legislation to examine whether the delegated powers are being properly exercised. Rules and regulations are usually required to be laid before Parliament, which can annul or modify them.

• Judicial Review: Courts can strike down subordinate legislation if it exceeds the authority granted by the parent Act or violates constitutional provisions.

• Public Consultation: Some Acts require prior publication and public feedback on draft rules.

Criticisms and Concerns

• Subordinate legislation can blur the separation of powers, as law-making is done by the executive or other bodies rather than the legislature.

• There is a risk of insufficient oversight, lack of transparency, and potential for misuse of delegated powers.

Conclusion

Subordinate legislation is a crucial element of the Indian legal system, enabling the efficient and flexible implementation of laws. However, it must operate within the boundaries set by the parent Act and is subject to parliamentary and judicial oversight to ensure accountability and adherence to the rule of law.

• Definition

  • Subordinate legislation refers to laws, rules, regulations, orders, schemes, and bye-laws made by authorities other than the legislature, under powers delegated by the legislature to implement and administer primary statutes.

• Purpose

  • It provides detailed guidelines and procedures necessary for effective enforcement of primary laws, allowing experts and administrators to address technical and evolving issues.

• Legal Basis

  • The authority to make subordinate legislation is derived from the parent Act or the Constitution, and must operate strictly within the framework and limits set by the delegating statute.

• Types

  • Common forms include rules, regulations, orders, notifications, schemes, and bye-laws, which must be published in the official Gazette and laid before Parliament or State Legislature.

• Necessity

  • Subordinate legislation is essential due to legislative time constraints and the need for flexibility, specialization, and rapid response to changing circumstances

• Parliamentary Oversight

  • Committees on Subordinate Legislation in both Lok Sabha and State Assemblies scrutinize whether the delegated powers are being properly and lawfully exercised.

• Judicial Control

  • Courts can review subordinate legislation and declare it invalid if it exceeds the powers granted by the parent Act (ultra vires) or violates constitutional provisions.

• Procedural Safeguards

  • Subordinate legislation must be consistent with the objectives of the parent Act, should not impose taxes or bar court jurisdiction unless expressly authorized, and must avoid unjustifiable delays in publication or laying before the legislature.

• Concerns

  • Issues include delays in framing rules, lack of transparency, risk of executive overreach, and insufficient parliamentary scrutiny in some cases.

• Significance

  • Subordinate legislation is a vital tool for effective governance, but requires robust checks to ensure accountability, legality, and alignment with legislative intent.

Mind Map Explanation
Subordinate Legislation (Central Node)
Meaning: Laws made by authorities other than the legislature, under powers given by the legislature.

Purpose: To provide details, procedures, and technical rules for implementing main laws.

Types: Includes rules, regulations, bye-laws, orders, and notifications.

Legal Basis: Authority comes from the parent Act or Constitution

Necessity: Needed because the legislature cannot handle all technicalities and details.

Control: Checked by Parliamentary Committees and courts (judicial review).

Significance: Ensures laws can be implemented efficiently, flexibly, and with expert input.

Print Page