Checklist Toolkit for Session Judges for deciding remand and Bail Applications of accused Under Prevention of Corruption Act

 General Principles for Bail Under PC Act

Fundamental Considerations:

• Bail is the rule and judicial custody is the exception in criminal cases

• Both Sessions Court and High Court have concurrent jurisdiction to grant bail under Section 439 CrPC

• Allegations of corruption must be dealt with zero tolerance

Pre-Hearing Checklist

Documentary Requirements:

• Verify FIR copy and charges framed

• Ensure accused is in custody or has surrendered before court

• Check if chargesheet has been filed

• Review case diary entries as mandated

• Examine any remand orders and their validity

Jurisdictional Verification:

• Confirm court's jurisdiction under Section 439 CrPC

• Verify if application filed simultaneously in multiple courts (not permissible)

• Check if Section 17A sanction obtained (except in trap cases)

Trap Cases: Special Considerations

Evidence Assessment Checklist

Demand and Acceptance Proof:

• Verify if demand for illegal gratification is established beyond reasonable doubt

• Check evidence of acceptance/obtaining of undue advantage

• Review phenolphthalein-sodium carbonate test results

• Examine electronic transfer of money evidence

• Assess quality of prosecution witnesses (complainant, panch witnesses, investigating officers)

Section 20 Presumption Analysis:

• Determine if gratification payment and acceptance is proved

• Check if presumption under Section 20 can be invoked

• Assess accused's ability to rebut the presumption

Investigation Integrity:

• Verify if trap was conducted properly without prior sanction requirements under Section 17A

• Check for any evidence tampering or witness intimidation

• Review intercepted calls or surveillance evidence

Risk Assessment for Trap Cases

Flight Risk Indicators:

• Attempts to evade investigation

• Instructions to family members to obstruct raids

• Operation of bank lockers immediately after raid

• Non-cooperation with investigating agencies

Evidence Tampering Concerns:

• Access to documents or digital evidence

• Influence over witnesses or co-accused

• Ability to destroy physical evidence

Disproportionate Assets Cases: Special Considerations

Assets Calculation Verification

Essential Data Points:

• Check period determination

• Income during check period

• Expenditure during check period

• Likely savings calculation

• Assets acquired during check period

• Disproportionate percentage calculation [G/F x 100]

Legal Standards for Known Sources:

• Income must be from lawful sources

• Intimation of receipt of income to prosecution

• Burden on accused to provide satisfactory explanation

Evidence Complexity Assessment

Documentary Evidence Volume:

• Bank statements and financial records

• Property documents and registrations

• Income tax returns and declarations

• Investment portfolios and transactions

Investigation Requirements:

• Need for forensic accounting

• Requirement for custodial interrogation

• International transactions or properties

Bail Decision Matrix

Factors Favoring Bail

Legal Grounds:

• Default bail eligibility under Section 167(2) CrPC

• Completion of investigation

• No evidence tampering concerns

• Strong defense on merits

Practical Considerations:

• Cooperation with investigation

• No influence over witnesses

• Stable residential address

• Medical or humanitarian grounds

Factors Against Bail

Legal Impediments:

• Strong prima facie case with Section 20 presumption

• Evidence of demand and acceptance established

• Possibility of evidence destruction

• Influence over prosecution witnesses

Behavioral Concerns:

• Attempts to obstruct investigation

• Non-cooperation with agencies

• Flight risk indicators

• Previous bail violations

Conditions for Bail Grant

Standard Conditions

Appearance and Cooperation:

• Regular appearance before investigating officer

• Surrender passport (if applicable)

• Furnish local address and contact details

• Not to leave jurisdiction without permission

Evidence Protection:

• Not to tamper with evidence or influence witnesses

• Not to contact prosecution witnesses directly

• Surrender access to official records or documents

• Cooperation with ongoing investigation

Special Conditions for Trap Cases

Financial Monitoring:

• Disclosure of all bank accounts and lockers

• Prohibition on operating bank lockers without court permission

• Regular financial disclosures

• Restriction on large financial transactions

Investigation Compliance:

• Available for custodial interrogation when required

• Cooperation in recovery of tainted money or articles

• Assistance in identification of co-conspirators

Special Conditions for Disproportionate Assets Cases

Asset Preservation:

• Prohibition on disposal of immovable properties

• Attachment of disproportionate assets

• Regular submission of asset statements

• Cooperation in asset valuation process

Financial Transparency:

• Complete disclosure of income sources

• Cooperation in forensic accounting

• Submission of all financial documents

• Regular reporting of financial activities

Remand Considerations

Police Custody Remand Checklist

Legal Requirements:

• Verify grounds for police custody are specific, not general

• Record reasons for granting police remand

• Compute remand period correctly including both start and end dates

Necessity Assessment:

• Recovery of articles or evidence

• Identification of co-conspirators

• Confrontation with co-accused

• Investigation of larger conspiracy

Judicial Custody Considerations

Default Bail Timeline:

• Monitor 60/90 day limits under Section 167(2) CrPC

• Prevent misuse of remand provisions

• Ensure investigation completion within statutory period

Post-Bail Monitoring

Compliance Verification

Regular Review:

• Monitor compliance with bail conditions

• Review investigation progress

• Assess any violation reports

• Consider bail cancellation if warranted

Modification Powers:

• Impose additional conditions if required

• Relax conditions based on circumstances

• Cancel bail for violations or on merits

Documentation Requirements

Order Format

Essential Elements:

• Clear reasoning for bail grant/rejection

• Specific conditions imposed with rationale

• Reference to relevant legal provisions

• Consideration of Section 20 presumption (if applicable)

Case-Specific Additions:

• Asset preservation orders (DA cases)

• Financial monitoring directions

• Investigation cooperation requirements

• Evidence protection measures

This comprehensive checklist ensures systematic evaluation of bail applications under the Prevention of Corruption Act while balancing the accused's liberty rights with the investigation's integrity and society's interest in combating corruption.

Note: This checklist is based on constitutional mandates and Supreme Court judgments. It must be used in conjunction with current legal provisions and recent judicial pronouncements. When in doubt, err on the side of protecting constitutional rights.

Last Updated: Based on judgments up to 2025

Print Page