Showing posts with label B Summary report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label B Summary report. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 June 2024

Whether Magistrate can grant B Summary report without giving notice and hearing informant?

The impugned order does not show that, any notice was given to the informant before accepting the proposal by the investigating officer. It has been held in Bhagwant Singh's case (Supra) as under;

"In a case where the Magistrate to whom a report is forwarded under sub-sec. (2) of S. 173 decides not to take cognizance of the offence and to drop the proceeding or takes the view that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding against some of the persons mentioned in the First Information Report, the Magistrate must give notice to the information and provide him an opportunity to be heard at the time of consideration of the report. However, either from the provisions of the Criminal P.C. Or from the principles of natural justice, no obligation on the Magistrate to issue notice to the injured person or to a relative of the deceased for providing such person an opportunity to be heard at the time of consideration of the report can be spelt out, unless such person is the informant who has lodged the F.I.R. But, even if such person is not entitled to notice from the Magistrate, he can appear before the Magistrate and make his submissions when the report is considered by the Magistrate for the purpose of deciding what action he should take on the report."

"If the magistrate decides that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding further and drops the proceeding or takes the view that though there is sufficient ground for proceeding against some, there is no sufficient ground for proceeding against others mentioned in the First Information Report, the informant would certainly be prejudiced because the First Information Report lodged by him would have failed of its purpose, wholly or in part. Moreover, when the interest of the informant in prompt and effective action being taken on the First Information Report lodged by him is clearly recognized by the provisions contained in sub-sec. (2) of S. 154, sub-sec. (2) of S. 157 and sub-sec. (2) (ii) of S. 173 in that the officer of the police station has under S. 157 (2) to notify the fact to the first informant that he is not going to investigate the case or cause it to be investigated and under S. 173 (2) (ii), the said officer is obligated to communicate to the informant the action taken by him and the report forwarded by him to the Magistrate, it must be presumed that the informant would equally be interested in seeing that the Magistrate takes cognizance of the offence and issues process, because that would be culmination of the First Information Report lodged by him. There can, therefore, be no doubt that when, on a consideration of the report made by the officer in charge of a police station under sub-section (2)(i) of S. 173, the Magistrate is not inclined to take cognizance of the offence and issue process, the informant must be given an opportunity of being heard so that he can make his submissions to persuade the Magistrate to take cognizance of the offence and issue process."

{Para 8}

9. Further this Court had set aside the order of discharging accused without giving notice and hearing informant. Thus the legal position as has been enumerated in Bhagwant Sing, Gangadhar Mhatre and Abhinandan Zha ought to have been followed by the learned Magistrate. Therefore, the said order is required to be set aside and the matter is required to be relegated to the Judicial Magistrate First Class to be dealt with according to the above said authorities.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Application No. 1264 of 2018

Decided On: 06.08.2018

Saleha Kausar Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/2377/2018.

Print Page

Thursday, 8 February 2024

Provisions of Criminal Manual regarding issuance of Summary A,B, C by Magistrate

 Summaries of Final Orders

24. All the Courts of Session and the Magistrates are directed to specifically note for guidance ,the following instructions for issue of summaries of final orders. In all cases disposed of by them, they should comply with these instructions without prejudice to their statutory powers and judicial discretion :----

(1) Each Magistrate shall,immediately after disposing of a cognizable case , forward through the police Station from which the case came, to the Superintendent or Sub-Divisional Police Officer concerned ,a summary of a final order in Form E. It should be sent in all cases,whether disposed of by trial or otherwise brought to an end by the death,lunacy or escape of the accused or in any other way what-soever. When a case has been tried by a Magistrate, he will issue the summary. In cases tried by the Court of Session, the Magistrate concerned will forward the required summary after the disposal of the case by that Court or by the High Court. When the order of decision of the Magistrate is modified on appeal or revision ,the Magistrate who sent the original summary will sent again a fresh summary of such modified order or decision in Form F.

Print Page

Saturday, 20 June 2020

Whether Magistrate accepting Summary in a Criminal case under the Prevention of Corruption act is said to have taken Cognizance of Offence?

The Criminal Procedure Code has not defined the expression "take cognizance". But it appears clear on decided cases that taking of cognizance is a different thing from initiation of proceedings. The Magistrate may apply his mind and consider a report submitted to him by the police officer under Section 173, Criminal Procedure Code; but, before it could be said that he has taken cognizance under Section 190 of the Criminal Procedure Code, it is not sufficient that he should have applied his mind to the report, but he must do something for proceeding under the subsequent provisions of the Code, for example, under Section 200, under which the Magistrate has to examine the complainant on taking cognizance of an offence. In Superintendent and Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal v. Abani Kumar, MANU/WB/0167/1950 : AIR1950Cal437 , it was held that

"before it can be said that any Magistrate has taken cognizance of any offence under Section 190(1)(a), he must not only have applied his mind to the contents of the petition, but he must have done so for the purpose of proceeding in a particular way as indicated in the subsequent provisions of the Chapter. When the Magistrate applies his mind not for the purpose of proceeding under the subsequent sections of the Chapter, but for taking action of some other kind, e.g., ordering investigation under Section 156(3), or issuing a search warrant for the purpose of the investigation, he cannot be said to have taken cognizance of the offence."
Now this view of the Calcutta High Court has been approved by the Supreme Court in R.R. Chari v. State of Uttar Pradesh MANU/SC/0025/1951 : 1951CriLJ775 where their Lordships of the Supreme Court were concerned with a case where the police had applied for a warrant of arrest of the accused for an offence punishable under Section 161 or 165 I.P.C. Under Section 3 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, such an offence is a cognizable offence for the purpose of the Criminal Procedure Code, subject to the condition that the police officers below the rank of officers mentioned in Section 5A cannot investigate without an order of the Magistrate of the First Class, or make an arrest without a warrant, and, it was held by the Supreme Court that, when the police applied for a warrant of arrest during investigation under Section 3, and the Magistrate issued a warrant, he could not be deemed to have taken cognizance of the case under Section 190 of the Criminal Procedure Code and, therefore, the fact that sanction of Government under Section 197 of the Code had not been obtained before the warrant was issued would not vitiate the trial. That case, therefore, clearly shows that, where a Magistrate applies his mind only for ordering investigating under Section 5A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, or issue a warrant on the application by the police for the purpose of investigation, the Magistrate is not taking cognizance of the offence. In our opinion, the present case would fall within the principle laid down in this case. All that was done by the police officer here was to submit a report under Section 173 of the Criminal Procedure Code, and the police wanted the Magistrate to issue a "B" summary, classifying the complaint as maliciously false. In fact, the officer did not want the Magistrate to take any further action on the report. It was open to the Magistrate to grant that type of summary. It was also open to the Magistrate to differ from the view of the police, and, in fact, in this case, the trial Magistrate chose to classify the case as fit for the issue of "A" summary. But, since no further proceedings were intended to betaken, it cannot be said that the learned trial Magistrate, in issuing "A" summary had taken cognizance of the offence. In these circumstances, the order of the trial Magistrate cannot be challenged on the ground that it was bad, as he took cognizance of an offence without any previous sanction as contemplated under section 6 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Ref. No. 119 of 1958

Decided On: 30.10.1958

State  Vs.  Shankar Bhaurao Khirode

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.N. Gokhale and N.M. Miabhoy, JJ.

Citations: AIR 1959 Bom 437, (1959) 61 BOMLR 591, 1959 CriLJ 1153, ILR 1959 Bom 1088
Print Page

Monday, 6 October 2014

Whether the court must hear the accused in hearing for the issue of B summary report by investigating officer?



In my opinion, the Respondent No.2 had no  locus­ standi  to 
participate in the proceedings that would take place before the Magistrate 
for deciding whether or not to accept ‘B’ summary report.   The reason is 
obvious.  It is well settled that until a formal accusation is levelled against 
an accused, or until a decision to proceed against the him is taken, the 
accused would not have any say in the matter.   It would not be for the 
accused   to   appear   before   the   Court   and   contend   that   the   proceedings 
against him should not be initiated, when the Court is yet undecided, as to 

whether such proceedings should be initiated or not.  The reason why the 
first informant needs to be heard when a ‘B’ summary report is filed, is 
obvious.  It is because the the report of the investigating agency is adverse 
to the claims and contentions of the first informant.   Fairness, therefore, 
requires that he should be given an opportunity of being heard and to point 
out  how  the conclusion arrived at by the investigating agency is wrong. 

The   case  of   the   accused  at   that  stage,   would  be   totally  different.     The 
investigating agency having already come to a conclusion, which is in his 
favour, the contest would be between the investigating agency and the first 
informant.  It is the first informant who is aggrieved by the decision of the 
investigating   agency   and   it   is   therefore   that   he   is   required   to   be   heard 
before the conclusion arrived at by the investigating agency, is accepted. 
The accused is not at all aggrieved by the filing of a ‘B’ summary report. 
Therefore, there would be no parity between him and the first informant. 
Merely because the first informant is required to be heard, at that stage, 
the accused cannot claim that he also should be heard.  The position of the 
accused   in   such   a   case   would   be   totally   different   from   that   of   the   first 
informant and therefore, on the view that since the first informant is to be  

heard, principles of natural justice require that the accused should also be  
heard, cannot be accepted.
In my opinion, the order passed by the Magistrate, which was 
based only on the decision as aforesaid of the Rajasthan High Court in the 
case of  Hardev Singh Sandhu (supra), which decision was not followed, 

even by the same High Court subsequently, needs to be interfered with. 
The learned Additional Sessions Judge has also placed reliance only on 
the said decision of the Rajasthan High Court, without noticing the decision 
of   the   Supreme   Court   in  Chandra   Deo   Singh   Vs.   Prakash   Chandra  
Bose alias Chabi Bose and another, AIR 1963 Supreme Court 1430. 
From   the   observations   made   by   their   Lordships   in   the   said   reported 
judgment, the principle that an accused cannot have any right to participate  
in any proceedings, which are taking place before it is decided that the  
accused should be proceeded against,  can be deduced.   The position of 
law   that  till   a   Magistrate   decides   to   proceed   against   an   accused,   the  
accused should have no say in the proceedings which take place before  
such a decision by a Magistrate is arrived at, seems to be well settled.  In 
the light of this position, simply on the ground that the first informant is 

being given a hearing in the matter, it would not be proper to give hearing 
to an accused. 

THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
BENCH AT AURANGABAD.
APPELLATE SIDE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.  732  OF  2011

Gopal Bhagwan Sonar, V  The State of Maharashtra,

­­­­­
CORAM  : ABHAY M. THIPSAY, J.
DATE      : 26th  September, 2013. 
Citation;2014 CRLJ(NOC)453 Bom
Print Page

Tuesday, 29 July 2014

Procedure to be followed by Magistrate after receipt of B Summary Report




The above stated two judgments of 
the   Hon'ble   Supreme   Court   are   based   on   the   judgment   of   the   Hon’ble 
Supreme   Court   in   the   matter   of  M/s.   India   Carat   Pvt.   Ltd.   Vs.   State   of  
Karnataka, reported at AIR 1989 SC 885.  The observations made in the said 
judgment of  India Carat  can be found at paragraph No.16, which read as 
under :
“16.   The   position   is,   therefore,   now   well   settled   that  
upon receipt of a police report under Section 173(2) a 
Magistrate  is entitled  to take cognisance of an offence  
under Section 190(1)(b) of the Code even if the police 
report is to the effect that no case is made out against  
the accused.   The Magistrate can take into account the  
statements   of   the   witnesses   examined   by   the   police  
during   the   investigation   and   take   cognisance   of   the  
offence complained of and order the issue of process to 
the accused.  Section 190(1) (b) does not lay down that  
a Magistrate can take cognisance of an offence only if  
the   investigating   officer   gives   an   opinion   that   the  
investigation has made out a case against the accused.  
The Magistrate can ignore the conclusion arrived at by  

the   investigating   officer   and   independently   apply   his  
mind to the facts emerging from the investigation and  
take cognizance of the case, if he thinks fit, in exercise of 
his powers under Section 190(1)(b) and direct the issue  
of process to the accused.   The Magistrate is not bound  
in such a situation to follow the procedure laid down in 
Sections 200 and 202 of the Code for taking cognizance  
of a case under Section 190(1)(a) though it is open to  
him to act under Section 200 or Section 202 also. ...”

(Emphasis supplied)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
  
               
CRIMINAL APPLICATION (APL) NO. 761 OF 2012

Prakash Banduji Mundale, Vs State of Maharashtra, 

                             CORAM : M.L. TAHALIYANI, J.
    Dated; 29th april 2014.
Citation; 2014 AllMR(cri) 2414
Print Page

Saturday, 6 April 2013

Whether only Magistrate can grant B Summary in criminal case?


 Now, it has been established by several decisions of our High Court, notably those mentioned inState v. Murlidhar Goverdhan (1960 Cri LJ 800) and Krishna Gundu Potjale v. State, ,
that even granting of B Summary is a judicial order and not an administrative order. This view has now been given a finality even by the Supreme Court in its decision in Abhinandan Jha v. Dinesh Mishra, . It is, thus, clear that grant of
summaries is a judicial function left to the exclusive province of the Magistrate and a Police Officer, or for that matter a Commissioner of Police, or an officer duly appointed by the him, has no role to play.
19. In this view of the matter, we are clearly of the view that the Commissioner or an officer duly nominated by the Commissioner has no jurisdiction to grant summaries, as has been done in the instant cases. The order granting summaries being a judicial function, the same can be impugned by an aggrieved party by filing either a revision application under the Code of Criminal Procedure or Writ Petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India. Order granting summaries may lead the complainant to the consequences of facing a prosecution for lodging false or frivolous complaints. The same, if left to be performed by the Commissioner, will leave the party without a remedy, even though he may be faced with the prospect of being prosecuted in view of the finding in respect of the summaries issued. This has, therefore, advisedly not been left within the province of the Commissioner or his delegate and has been left to the discretion of a Magistrate whose orders can be tested in superior Courts before the parties are faced with the consequences of filing false prosecutions.

Bombay High Court
Sharavan Baburao Dinkar And Etc. vs N.B. Hirve, Additional Inspector ... on 25 September, 1996
Equivalent citations: 1997 (2) BomCR 51, (1996) 98 BOMLR 824, 1997 CriLJ 617

Bench: A Agarwal, R Khandeparkar

Print Page