Now coming to the judgment of the Apex Court in Narhari and others' case (supra), the Apex Court in paragraph 5 has observed that It is now well settled that where there has been one trial, one finding and one decision, there need not be two Appeals even though two decrees may have been drawn up. The observation of the Apex Court in Narahari's case therefore applies in all fours to the facts of the instant case wherein there was one trial, one finding and one decision as regards the property and therefore the Appellants were not required to file separate Appeals. In so far as the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in Pampara Philip's case is concerned, though the said judgment is not directly on the point as to whether one Appeal is maintainable, the Appellants can draw support from the said judgment in the light of the fact that the learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court has held that if the claim in the counter claim is dismissed and the suit claim is allowed, then there is no warrant to file two Appeals but what is required to be done is that the valuation has to be composite i.e. the valuation of the suit and counter claim, and court fees have to be paid accordingly. In my view, the judgment lends support to the case of the Appellants inasmuch as in the instant case also the suit claim has been allowed and the counter claims have been dismissed.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 4658 of 2013
Decided On: 10.12.2014
Shankar Masu Dokare Vs. Shobha Subhash Dokare
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Savant, J.