The learned counsel for the Petitioner Shri Jamdar submitted that
there is no requirement to value the suit as per Section 6(iv)(ha) of the
Bombay Court Fees Act, 1959 as the main substantive relief sought is by way of
prayer clause (A) to the effect that a declaration is sought that the sale deed
dated 31/10/2008 has been got executed from the Plaintiff by fraud, misrepresentation
and by breach of trust taking disadvantage of the old age and
illness of the Plaintiff and without consideration, and for a declaration that the
said so called sale deed is illegal and suffers from fraud is abinitio illegal and
not binding on the Plaintiff. The learned counsel would contend that the 2nd
prayer introduced by way of amendment is a consequential as if the 1st prayer
is granted, the said 2nd prayer has to necessarily follow. The learned counsel
would contend that the Bombay Court Fees Act is a fiscal statute and would
have to be strictly construed, and unless requisites for the application of
Section 6(iv)(ha) are available, the said provision would not apply.
It would also apposite to reproduce the relevant statutory
provisions of Section 6(iv)(ha) and Section 6(iv)(j) reproduced thus :
“(ha) for avoidance of sale, contract for sale, etc.
In suits for declaration that any sale, or contract for sale
or termination of contract for sale, of any moveable or
immoveable property is void one half of advalorem fee
leviable on the value of the property”
(j) for other declarations
In suits where declaration is sought, with or without
injunction or other consequential relief and the subject
matter in dispute is not susceptible of monetary
evaluation and which are not otherwise provided for by
this Act ad valorem fee payable, as if the amount or
value of the subject matter was one thousand rupees.
In all suits under clauses (a) to (j) the Plaintiff shall
state the amount at which the values the relief sought,
with the reasons for the valuation.”
As can be seen, Section 6(iv)(ha) reveals that in suits for
declaration that any sale, or contract for sale or termination of contract for
sale, of any moveable or immoveable property is void and stipulates the court
fees payable under the said provision.
Section 6(iv)(j) covers the suits where declaration is sought, with
or without injunction or other consequential relief and the subject matter in
dispute is not susceptible of monetary evaluation and which are not otherwise
provided for by the said Act.
The submission of the learned counsel for the Petitioner that in the
said suit what was sought was the declaration of the agreement in question as
void which relief is covered by Section 6(iv)(ha) of the said Act. However, in
the instant case, the Petitioner is not seeking any such relief in the suit but only
claiming a declaration that the sale deed dated 15/12/2008 is not binding
upon him. In my view, the same would not make any difference as what in
effect the Plaintiff is seeking by way of prayer clause A(1) is the avoidance of
the said agreement dated 15/12/2008, and therefore, Section 6(iv)(ha) would
be attracted. As observed herein above, even if prayer clause A were to be
granted to the Plaintiff, nevertheless the agreement in question in favour of the
Defendant Nos.3 to 5 would have to be set aside, and therefore, the relief
sought by way of prayer clause A(1) would have to be valued in terms of
Section 6(iv)(ha).
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.401 OF 2011
Shri Abdulsattar Gulabbhai Bagwan Vs Shri Vaibhav Lxmangiri Gosawi,
CORAM : R M SAVANT, J.
Pronounced on : 01st December 2011
Citation: 2012 (1) Bom C R 1
Print Page