Showing posts with label S 328 of IPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 328 of IPC. Show all posts

Friday, 26 June 2026

Bombay HC: Where a special statute like FSSA occupies the field with an overriding effect (Section 89 FSSA), the general law (IPC) cannot be invoked, and simultaneous prosecution under both is not permissible

 IPC sections 272, 273, and 328 cannot be invoked when the same subject matter is covered by FSSA, a special law - Section 59 of FSSA is broader than IPC Sections 272 and 273 - Where a special statute like FSSA occupies the field with an overriding effect (Section 89 FSSA), the general law (IPC) cannot be invoked, and simultaneous prosecution under both is not permissible - 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Criminal Application (Apl) No. 1776 of 2025

Decided On: 24.04.2026

Mohammad Bilal Moammad Yakub and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vrushali V. Joshi, J.

 Citation: 2026:BHC-NAG:6496-DB, MANU/MH/4024/2026

Print Page

Sunday, 3 August 2025

Bombay HC: Whether the court can reject anticipatory bail of accused based on Statement of co-accused?

 Thus, in this case except

for the alleged statement of the co-accused, which is

inadmissible in evidence, there is no evidence to

connect the Applicant with this crime. Though earlier

there was one similar offence was registered against

him, undeniably he is acquitted therefrom. Hence, the

liberty of the Applicant deserves to be protected.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO. 1675 OF 2024

Anil Vasant Kapse   Vs  The Superintendent Of Police And Another

CORAM : R.M. JOSHI, J

DATE : OCTOBER 15, 2024

Citation: 2024:BHC-AUG:25108
Print Page

Bombay HC: Under which circumstances the accused prosecuted for offence U/S 328 of IPC can be released on anticipatory bail?

 Learned APP opposed the application with the contention that co-accused are made statement about he being at the spot with the present applicant and also states about the applicant to be owner of the said article. Thus, according to him there is evidence to connect the applicant with the crime. He submitted that the Investigating Officer could not search the premises of the applicant as he has absconded. {Para 3}

4. Though perusal of the investigation papers show that co-accused claimed that applicant was there at the spot along with the applicant however, the first information report which is given by Senior Police Officer does no show his presence. The statement of the co-accused which is otherwise also not admissible in evidence becomes doubtful too. The submissions of the prosecution that the premises of the applicant could not be searched for want of his presence does not deserve acceptable as it was open for the investigation officer to take appropriate steps for obtaining warrant for search of the premises. In action on the part of the investigating officer to take steps in this regard speaks volumes.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.864 OF 2023

AJAY GOVIND BOMBATKAR Vs THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

CORAM : R. M. JOSHI, J.

DATE : 08th JUNE, 2023

Print Page

Bombay HC: Under which circumstances the court should release accused on anticipatory bail in offences relating to seizure of prohibited articles?

It appears from the investigation papers

that the present applicant used to give delivery of banned

tobacco articles to the other accused persons. There appears

substance in the learned advocate for the applicant that the

applicant has only delivered banned tobacco produces, apart

from that he has not played active any active role in the

alleged offence.

5. The applicant was granted interim protection and he

has co-operated in the investigation, and nothing is to be

recovered from the applicant. In the facts of the present case,

pre-tiral custodial detention of the applicant is not necessary.

6. In the result, the application is allowed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

 BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.140 OF 2023

Rupesh Vishnudas Malpani  Vs  The State of Maharashtra

and another 

 [CORAM : NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI, J.]

 DATE : 20th FEBRUARY, 2023

Print Page

Saturday, 12 July 2025

Bombay HC: Under which circumstances order passed by high court in bail application should not be treated as precedent?

  In so far as the judgment in the case of Manjubhai Rokde and Vinod Ramchandra Gupta (supra) are concerned, it needs to be noted that in both the orders no principle of law arose for consideration and no principle of law was laid down. It is well settled that an order of bail application is summary in nature based on summary facts which can never be relied as a precedent or can be cited as an authority laying down proposition of law by this Court unless and until principle of law arise for consideration and the order lays down principle of law. A decision is an authority for what it actually decides. The essence of a decision is its ratio and not every observation found therein nor what legally follows from the observations made in the order. A case cannot be an authority on the point of a fact. Each case has to be decided in the light of circumstances existing in it. A precedent is a judicial decision which lays down a principle of law. Generally bail orders in their operative part proceed on peculiar facts of each case. Sometimes facts are not stated in the order considering complexity of facts and circumstances of the case. Therefore, generally bail orders without laying down principle of law cannot be regarded as an authority on a point of fact. Therefore, in my opinion, both the judgments cited by the advocate for the applicant in the absence of proposition of law being decided cannot be treated as a precedent laying down principle of law. The orders relied upon by the applicant, therefore, are of no help to the applicant. {Para 9}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Anticipatory Bail Application Nos. 189 of 2023 and 616 of 2023

Decided On: 16.06.2023

Eknath Bhalchandra Patil Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Amit B. Borkar, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/5594/2023.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Whether the court should allow anticipatory bail application in case of seizure of Gutka or Pan Masala?

 I have considered the submissions on behalf of both the sides. I have carefully scrutinized the case diary. Prima facie, the statement of the person from whom prohibited substance was seized named the applicant in ABA/139/2023 as supplier. The applicant in ABA/616/2023 is a seller. Considering the nature of allegations against the applicant, it is necessary that detail investigation as regards existence of any racket operating in prohibited substance need to be investigated. It is also necessary to investigate source of such supply and acquisition. It is also necessary to investigate into the names and identity of purchasers of the prohibited substance from the applicants. {Para 6}

10. Therefore, in my opinion, considering the allegations against the applicant, no case for grant of pre-arrest protection is made out.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Anticipatory Bail Application Nos. 189 of 2023 and 616 of 2023

Decided On: 16.06.2023

Eknath Bhalchandra Patil Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Amit B. Borkar, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/5594/2023.

Print Page

Sunday, 9 October 2022

Can a person selling Gutka or Pan masala prosecuted for an offence U/S 328 of IPC be released on anticipatory bail?

 Section 328 of

IPC is attracted where the substance in question is poison or

any stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug or other thing

is administered or caused to be taken by any person with an

intent to cause hurt or with an intent to commit or to facilitate

the commission of an offence or intent it to be likely that he will

thereby cause hurt, becomes punishable under the provision.

The first part of Section 328 contemplates a direct involvement

of person and second part suggest any indirect method for

causing one of the substances to be taken by any person.

Expression “causing” involves some action. “Causation” means

the action of causing something. “Intervening causation” means

an event that comes between the initial event in sequence and

the end result. Manufacturing “unsafe food” is initial event.

Causing its movement by transporting or storing it with an

intent to reach to end user are the events in sequence caused

by active participation of intermediate agencies or persons.

Thus, all such events involving active participation of persons

at each stage, is relevant. A person at end is a ‘consumer’ to

whom “unsafe food” is sold, knowing well that its consummation

would cause hurt to him. Persons involved in manufacturing

“unsafe food”, causing its movement to market or storing it with

intent to sell it, either himself or through other persons, while

prohibitory ‘order’ promulgated under Section 30 of the Food

and Safety Act is in force and such all persons, under express

or implied authority either individually or otherwise, “causes

person to take” unsafe food with intent to cause hurt. It is

indirect causation. It was further observed that the

manufacturing unsafe food articles, moving these goods from

manufacturing unit to market for its sale is an event and that

any action in chain of circumstances which foreseeably leads to

and facilitates the sale of food articles is further event may be

said to be a cause of that event to bring the action within the

expression’ “causes to be taken by a person”, any poison with

intent to cause hurt to such person, in Section 328 of the IPC.

The offence under Section 328 of IPC, essentially is not causing

someone else to do prohibited act but ‘causing’ a person to

consume food articles knowing well that its consumption would

hurt such person. Even otherwise, where the investigation is at

initial stage, and the relevant material is yet to be collected; it

may not be appropriate to hold that FIR does not make out an

offence under Section 328 of IPC. The said application was

rejected.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.483 OF 2021

Mohammed Ali Raheman @ MohammedAli Abdul Raheman Shaikh  Vs. The State Of Maharashtra 

CORAM : PRAKASH D. NAIK, J.

DATE : 24th MARCH, 2021

Print Page

Sunday, 22 May 2022

Can a person selling Gutka or Pan masala prosecuted for an offence U/S 328 of IPC be released on anticipatory bail?

Having been found with the contraband articles, such as, Jarda, Pan Masala, Flavoured Supari, Scented Tobacco and Mava in contravention of the notification No. FSSA/Notification/901/7 dated 19.7.1919 and Notification No. FSSA/Notification/901/7 dated 15.7.2020 issued under Section 30(2)(a) of the Food Safety Standard Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as "FSS Act" for sake of brevity) by the Commissioner of Food Safety Maharashtra State, various FIRs under Sections 188, 269, 271, 272, 273, 307, 328, 353 of IPC and Section 59 of the FSS Act, came to be registered.

 In the matter of State of Maharashtra vs. Syed Hasan Syed Subhan MANU/SC/1021/2018 : 2018 AIR (SC) 5348 the Honourable Apex Court has clearly held that the non-compliance of the prohibitory order which prohibits transportation and sale of Ghutka and Pan Masala, would entail a prosecution under Section 55 of the FSS Act, but it has been held that the provisions of the Indian Penal Code can also be invoked and applied. The Apex Court did not find favour with the findings of the High Court, which had held that the non-compliance of the notification issued by the Food Safety Commissioner can be penalized only by imposing fine mentioned under Section 55 of FSS Act and no complaint under the Indian Penal Code could have been preferred by the Food Security Officer for violation of the prohibitory order. While setting aside the said finding, Their Lordships of the Apex Court held that the High Court was wrong in holding that the action can be initiated against the defaulters only under Section 55 or under Section 68 of the FSS Act, for adjudication.

21. This brings me back to the requisites of Section 328 of IPC. On closer scrutiny of Section 328, it is obvious for the prosecution to prove that the accused was directly responsible for administering poison etc. or causing it to be taken by any person, through another. Simply stating, the accused may achieve and complete the act by himself or by means of another. It is nowhere alleged that the applicants were primarily responsible for administering poison. It is also not the case that applicants had helped by aid of third person or by involving third person, who had authority to do so, caused it (poisonous substance) to be used by others. It would be premature to say that act of storage or transporting, as is alleged against the applicants, should be construed as fulfilling the requisites of Section 328 of IPC. There is need to guard against this hard-headed view, which is canvassed by the learned APP, on a sheer contemplation that the act of applicants would tantamount to an act of "administering" or "causing to be taken". The ratio laid down in the case of Joseph Kurian (supra) is all pervasive qua the cases in hand and applies with full rigour.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Anticipatory Bail Application Nos. 944, 1168, 1183,  of 2021

Decided On: 30.09.2021

 Munjabhau Manchakrao Rokde and Ors. Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.G. Bisht, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/4640/2021

Print Page

Thursday, 9 December 2021

Whether court should release accused on anticipatory bail if he is found in possession of Gutka?

  In case of applicants Wahid Khan and Amit Agrawal are concerned, First Information Report itself indicates that the applicant Wahid Khan has stored huge quantity of contraband articles namely 'Gutka' in the Godown of Amit Agrawal. The secret information itself spells out that applicant Wahid Khan was running Welcome Pan Shop, who has stored goods in the Godown of Amit Agrawal. Though it is argued that case of Amit Agrawal lies on the distant footing, however the investigation paper reveals that the Godown was taken on rent by Amit Agrawal from one Shri Khetanmal. Therefore, it cannot be said that Amit Agrawal who was in the actual possession of Godown, was totally noway concern with the storage of goods. Prima facie, it is evident that both of them co-jointly stored huge quantity of 'Gutka' and sainted tobacco articles which requires thorough investigation. {Para 15}


16. It is very unfortunate to note that despite prevailing ban from a decade, still the large number of cases are emerging in the State about seizure of 'Gutka' products. Sizable number of youths are mostly affected by free sale of 'Gutka'. It is noticed that there was fearless smuggling of 'Gutka' products from the neighboring States. Though the punishment for the offence was made more stringent, still in the quest of making quick money, 'Gutka' is freely made available at the cost of Society. Emphasis is on the point that it ruins the new generation which is a matter of great concern.

17. The seizure of 'Gutka' in large quantity itself postulates that they were not for personal consumption but for sale. In order to reach to the genesis, thorough investigation is necessary. Grant of pre-arrest protection would cut down the further process of investigation. The offence is having larger impact on the health of Society. Considering all these circumstances, I do not find that these are fit cases where judicial discretion can be exercised.

18. In view of the above, all bail applications stand rejected and disposed of.

Bombay High Court
Gajanan S/O Ashok Agrawal vs State Of Mah. Thr. Pso Ps ... on 7 December, 2021
Print Page

Saturday, 14 September 2019

Whether accused can be prosecuted under S 328 and S 188 of IPC for storage of tobacco products?

 A close analysis of the said section would reveal that
whoever disobeys an order promulgated by a public servant

directing to abstain from certain acts, or to take certain orders
with certain property in his possession, disobeys such direction,
would attract Section 188 of the IPC if such disobedience causes
or tends to cause obstruction, annoyance or injury, or risk of it, to
any person lawfully employed and if such disobedience causes or
tends to cause danger to human life, health or safety shall be
punished under the said section. The keywords being ‘causes or
tends to cause danger to human life, health or safety ’. The
disobedience of the public order apart from attracting a penalty
under Section 55 of the FSS Act would, in view of the decision of
the Apex Court in Sayyed Hussain (supra), attract Section 188 of
the IPC but it would have to be examined whether it falls within
the mischief sought to be penalised by the said section. The FIR
lodged against the Petitioners alleges only storage. Undisputedly,
there is a disobedience of an order which prohibits storage of
tobacco, Pan Masala and Gutka. Far away Nothing in the FIR
attribute any other act to the Petitioners viz. manufacture,
distribution or sale. Disobedience of the promulgated order
under Section 188 of the IPC is punishable if it causes or tends to
cause danger to human life. The section do not use the term
‘likely to cause’, conveying that there has to be a positive evidence
of causing or tends to cause danger to human life and in absence,
Section 188 is not attracted. It is not in doubt that the tobacco
and its products are dangerous to human life and safety.
However, mere possession or storage cannot fall within the

purview of ‘Danger’ contemplated under the said section. The
goods, as long as they remain stored, do not pose any danger. The
goods will have to be moved beyond the store to be sold - ‘to be
purchased for consumption’ and mere storing a food item would
not pose the intended danger to human life. The gap between
the storage and the consumption by a consumer will have to be
bridged before the danger or the hurt contemplated under
Sections 328 and Section 188 of the IPC get attracted and it is
only when the prosecution proves that it is the Petitioners who are
the one who did it, their prosecution would be a success. The
Apex Court in Joseph Kurian Philip Jose (supra), has succinctly
drawn a distinction in the two terminologies applied by Section
328 of the IPC in the form of direct and indirect methods and the
said judgment continues to be an authoritative and binding
precedent till date. In the light of the aforesaid position emerging
from the submissions advanced before us, we do not intend to
continue the prosecution against the Petitioners as it would
merely amount to an abuse of process of law and the prosecution
of the Petitioners under Sections 328 and 188 of the IPC,
therefore, cannot continue. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.3607 OF 2019

 Anand Ramdhani Chaurasia Vs  The State of Maharashtra,

CORAM : SHRI RANJIT MORE &
SMT. BHARATI DANGRE, JJ.

PRONOUNCED ON: 13th SEPTEMBER, 2019.
JUDGMENT:- [Per: Smt. Bharati Dangre, J.]
Print Page

Wednesday, 9 March 2016

Whether possessing or transporting Gutka or Pan Masala amounts to offence U/S 328 of IPC?


The entire gamut of this provision is quite peculiar. It says that the culprit
should administer to the victim. A substance which would be stupefied or
poisonous with an intention to cause hurt to him. Possessing Gutka or Pan Masala or transporting Gutka or Pan Masala does not amount to administering it to any victim. As said above, Gutka or Pan Masala were
not subjected to food analysis so far. On the other hand, the
Commissioner simply opined that it could be injurious to health. He
placed reliance on various reports which he received from time to time.
He did not placed reliance on report of food analysis appointed under the
provisions of FSS Act, 2006. It could therefore be said that Gutka or Pan
Masala could be poisonous. So, possessing or transporting Gutka or Pan
Masala did not amount to offence under Section 328 of the Indian Penal
code. In our view, this provision will not apply to the present cases.

 
 The next question is, whether manufacturing, possession,
selling of Gutka and Pan Masala would amount to offence punishable under Section 328 of the Indian Penal Code. Section 328 of the Indian Penal Code reads as under :-
“328. Causing hurt by means of poison, etc., with intent to commit an offence. - Whoever administers to or causes to be taken by any person
any poison or any stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug, or other
thing with intent to cause hurt to such person, or with intent to commit or
to facilitate the commission of an offence or knowing it to be likely that he
will thereby cause hurt, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be
liable to fine.”
By no stretch of imagination, manufacturing, possessing Gutka and Pan

Masala would amount to administering poison. As said above, Gutka or
Pan Masala are not subjected to food analysis. The commissioner opined
that in its sale etc. ia not in public interest. This opinion is based on
various reports but not report of Food Analyst appointed under the
provisions of the FSS Act. Therefore, it cannot be said that Gutka and Pan
Masala are stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug. Besides offering
these items of Food would not amount to intention to cause hurt. The
provisions of Section 328 of the Indian Penal Code to the present cases is
therefore impermissible.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 1027 OF 2015

 Ganesh Pandurang Jadhao,  Vs The State of Maharashtra, 


 CORAM : A.V. NIRGUDE &
INDIRA K. JAIN, JJ.
 DATE : 4th March, 2016

Print Page