We accordingly answer the reference as under:
It is essentially within the judicious discretion of the Court,
depending on the individual facts and circumstances of the case
before it, to seek or not to seek expert opinion as to the comparison of
the disputed handwriting/signature with the admitted handwriting/
signature under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The
Court is however not barred from sending the disputed handwriting/
signature for comparison to an expert merely because the time gap
between the admitted handwriting/signature and the disputed
handwriting/signature is long. The Court must however endeavour
to impress upon the petitioning party that comparison of disputed
handwritings/signatures with admitted handwritings/signatures,
separated by a time lag of 2 to 3 years, would be desirable so as to
facilitate expert comparison in accordance with satisfactory
standards. That being said, there can be no hard and fast rule about
this aspect and it would ultimately be for the expert concerned to
voice his conclusion as to whether the disputed handwriting/
signature and the admitted handwriting/signature are capable of
comparison for a viable expert opinion. The view expressed by the
Division Bench in JANACHAITANYA HOUSING LIMITED V/s. DIVYA
FINANCIERS1, as to the stage of the proceedings when an application
can be moved by a party under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872, continues to hold the field and there is no necessity for this
Full Bench to address that issue.
HYDERABAD HIGH COURT
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NOS.1500 of 2010
Dated:18-12-2015
Bande Siva Shankara Srinivasa Prasad .. Petitioner
Ravi Surya Prakash Babu and others Respondents
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE R. SUBHASH REDDY
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE RAMESH RANGANATHAN
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR
Citation:AIR 2016 HYD 118(FB)
Print Page
It is essentially within the judicious discretion of the Court,
depending on the individual facts and circumstances of the case
before it, to seek or not to seek expert opinion as to the comparison of
the disputed handwriting/signature with the admitted handwriting/
signature under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The
Court is however not barred from sending the disputed handwriting/
signature for comparison to an expert merely because the time gap
between the admitted handwriting/signature and the disputed
handwriting/signature is long. The Court must however endeavour
to impress upon the petitioning party that comparison of disputed
handwritings/signatures with admitted handwritings/signatures,
separated by a time lag of 2 to 3 years, would be desirable so as to
facilitate expert comparison in accordance with satisfactory
standards. That being said, there can be no hard and fast rule about
this aspect and it would ultimately be for the expert concerned to
voice his conclusion as to whether the disputed handwriting/
signature and the admitted handwriting/signature are capable of
comparison for a viable expert opinion. The view expressed by the
Division Bench in JANACHAITANYA HOUSING LIMITED V/s. DIVYA
FINANCIERS1, as to the stage of the proceedings when an application
can be moved by a party under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872, continues to hold the field and there is no necessity for this
Full Bench to address that issue.
HYDERABAD HIGH COURT
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NOS.1500 of 2010
Dated:18-12-2015
Bande Siva Shankara Srinivasa Prasad .. Petitioner
Ravi Surya Prakash Babu and others Respondents
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE R. SUBHASH REDDY
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE RAMESH RANGANATHAN
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR
Citation:AIR 2016 HYD 118(FB)
