Showing posts with label breach of policy conditions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label breach of policy conditions. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 October 2025

Gujarat HC: Insurance Company can not prove breach of policy condition that private vehicle was taken on hire without examining material witnesses

Therefore, in such circumstances, it is a duty of the insurance company to prove by leading proper evidence on record that deceased and other persons those who were travelling in the jeep were travelling as a passenger on hire, but, no evidence was led by insurance company before the Tribunal. The driver was available. Notice, issued by the Claims Tribunal, was served on the driver, then, some efforts must have to be made by the insurance company to substantiate their contention before the Tribunal. Accordingly, raising the contention in written statement and to get some clue from the complaint is not enough for the insurance company to prove their contention before the Claims Tribunal. The driver and owner both are the persons who must have the knowledge as to whether jeep was hired or not, then, insurance company must have to make efforts by making an application before the Claims Tribunal to issue the summons as a witness to driver or owner for giving evidence before the Claims Tribunal in respect to the fact that whether jeep was hired or not. But, no such efforts have been made by insurance company.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

First Appeal No. 2030 of 2008 with Civil Application No. 5492 of 2008 in First Appeal No. 2030 of 2008

Decided On: 25.08.2008

National Insurance Company Vs. Shabbir Mohmad Kunjada and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

H.K. Rathod, J.

Citation:  MANU/GJ/0542/2008.

Print Page

Sikkim HC: Why an FIR Alone Can’t Prove Insurance Policy Breach in Motor Accident Claims?

The only evidence which the Appellants rely upon for the purpose of showing that there was a breach of a condition of the policy on the part of the insured of the vehicle having been given on hire to the deceased and her group, is the first information report lodged by Shrijana Pradhan, PW 2, who was also travelling in the same vehicle. No doubt, the statement recorded by the police of Manesar Police Station, Gurgaon, states that the vehicle was taken on hire, but this is in clear conflict with the statements made on oath before the Tribunal by the claimant No. 1 appearing as PW 1 and the maker of the F.I.R., the PW 2. It is a settled principle of law that an F.I.R. is not a substantive piece of evidence but only corroborative that can also be used for contradiction under Section 145 of the Evidence Act. The Appellants have not led any evidence at all, let alone produce evidence to prove that the vehicle was taken on hire by the deceased and her family. Therefore, the question of the F.I.R. corroborating the evidence of the insurers did not arise at all when they did not have any other evidence. The Appellant insurer also failed to confront the witness with the statement contained in the F.I.R. for the purpose of contradiction, an opportunity which was available to them under Section 145 of the Evidence Act. The Appellants could have easily produced the person who wrote down the F.I.R. as a witness to prove that the PW 2 had indeed made the statement before the police which had been denied by her in her deposition before the Tribunal. This having not been done, it is difficult for this Court to accept the contention of the insurer Appellant that the vehicle was given on hire. The sworn testimony of the witness made before the Tribunal, therefore, has to be given the necessary weight age over the one that is unsworn, and in this case unsigned statement, recorded by the police which in any case has only a corroborative value.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM AT GANGTOK

M.A.C. Appeal No. 3 of 2009

Decided On: 17.05.2010

Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors. Vs. M.K. Subba and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sonam Phintso Wangdi, Actg. C.J.

Citation: 2011AIR Sikkim 28,2011 ACJ 1482, MANU/SI/0040/2010.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Insurance company must examine witnesses to prove breach of policy conditions that passengers were travelling by paying fare

  In my view, it is the appellant’s stand that at the time of accident fare paying passengers were travelling in the offending Jeep and they were travelling on hire and reward basis. It was the burden on the appellant to prove this fact before the Tribunal as the F.I.R. was lodged on behalf of police constable. The persons, with whom the police constable enquired, were not examined before the Tribunal. The spot panchnama does not show that chili bags were found on the spot. The persons whose statements are recorded are not injured in the said accident nor filed any claim petition. {Para 6}

7. I have gone through the case laws cited by learned counsel for the appellant. The facts of the cited case and the facts in the case at hand are different. In the present case, the persons on whose statements the F.I.R. was lodged are not examined so also the persons whose statements are recorded by the police showing that they were fare paying passengers are not examined. In view of the above, I do not find any merit in the appeal.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

1005 FIRST APPEAL NO.1187 OF 2004

 The New India Assurance  Company Limited Vs  Motilal Ramdas Chaudhari

CORAM : S. G. DIGE, J.

DATED : 23rd SEPTEMBER, 2022

Print Page

Saturday, 16 August 2025

Karnataka HC: How Insurance Company should prove breach of policy conditions?

 In catena of cases, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has clearly held that the Insurance Company must not only take a defence that there was a violation of the condition of the policy, but must also prove the defence that there has been a substantive violation of the said policy condition. Moreover, the burden of proving a defence is always on the party which pleads it. In order to discharge this burden, the Insurance Company can either summon the driver as a witness, or adduce the documents from the Regional Transport Authority as documentary evidence to prove and establish its plea that the driver of the offending vehicle, indeed, did not have a valid driving licence. In the case of Rukmini (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has clearly opined that until and unless the Insurance Company were to be discharge its burden, it cannot be absolved of its liability to pay the compensation amount. {Para 12}


13. The issue whether the Insurance Company is liable to pay the compensation in the absence of a valid driving licence has been laid to rest in the case of Swaran Singh (supra). In paragraph No. 69 of the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:


"69. The proposition of law is no longer res integra that the person who alleges breach must prove the same. The insurance company is, thus, required to establish the said breach by cogent evidence. In the event the insurance company fails to prove that there has been breach of conditions of policy on the part of the insured, the insurance company cannot be absolved of its liability."

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

Miscellaneous First Appeal No. 6206 of 2009 (MV)

Decided On: 22.03.2016

C. Balakrishna Vs. C. Muniraju and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2016:KHC:10286,MANU/KA/0769/2016

Print Page