Therefore, in such circumstances, it is a duty of the insurance company to prove by leading proper evidence on record that deceased and other persons those who were travelling in the jeep were travelling as a passenger on hire, but, no evidence was led by insurance company before the Tribunal. The driver was available. Notice, issued by the Claims Tribunal, was served on the driver, then, some efforts must have to be made by the insurance company to substantiate their contention before the Tribunal. Accordingly, raising the contention in written statement and to get some clue from the complaint is not enough for the insurance company to prove their contention before the Claims Tribunal. The driver and owner both are the persons who must have the knowledge as to whether jeep was hired or not, then, insurance company must have to make efforts by making an application before the Claims Tribunal to issue the summons as a witness to driver or owner for giving evidence before the Claims Tribunal in respect to the fact that whether jeep was hired or not. But, no such efforts have been made by insurance company.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
First Appeal No. 2030 of 2008 with Civil Application No. 5492 of 2008 in First Appeal No. 2030 of 2008
Decided On: 25.08.2008
National Insurance Company Vs. Shabbir Mohmad Kunjada and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
H.K. Rathod, J.
Citation: MANU/GJ/0542/2008.
Print Page