Showing posts with label conciliation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conciliation. Show all posts

Tuesday, 25 May 2021

Whether court can refer the dispute to arbitration if there is a settlement before the conciliator?

That, in turn, brings the IGRC order entirely within the meanings of Sections 73 and 74 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996. Those Section read thus:

“73.Settlement agreement.― (1) When it appears to the conciliator that there exist elements of a settlement which may be acceptable to the parties, he shall formulate the terms of a possible settlement and submit them to the parties for their observations. After receiving the observations of the parties, the conciliator may reformulate the terms of a possible settlement in the light of such observations.

(2)If the parties reach agreement on a settlement of the dispute, they may draw up and sign a written settlement. If requested by the parties, the conciliator may draw up, or assist the parties in drawing up, the settlement agreement.

(3)When the parties sign the settlement agreement, it shall be final and binding on the parties and persons claiming under them respectively.

(4)The conciliator shall authenticate the settlement agreement and furnish a copy thereof to each of the parties.

74.Status and effect of settlement agreement. The― settlement agreement shall have the same status and effect as if it is an arbitral award on agreed terms on the substance of the dispute rendered by an arbitral tribunal under section 30.”

(Emphasis added) {Para 17}

18.The IGRC order must, therefore, be construed as a settlement agreement within the meaning of Sections 73 and 74 of the Arbitration Act. No other view is possible, because if this is not to be seen as a settlement agreement that can be enforced, then any IGRC order in favour of the investor would remained on paper only. It would be entirely toothless. It would entirely defeat the purpose of having an IGRC at all. In fact, this is the reason why, if the Trading Member does not find the IGRC order palatable, a recourse is made available to him in the bye-laws itself to adopt what the bye-law call ‘the second level of dispute resolution, i.e. arbitration’. The tiered dispute resolution contemplated is, thus: (a) conciliation (and, as noted above, the bye-laws refer to the first step precisely as that); and (b) if conciliation fails, then arbitration (with its later in-house appeal provision).

19.The IGRC order can be said to have attained finality. The question is how is it to be made enforceable against the party that admitted liability? As I noted there is now no question of an arbitration. There is nothing to arbitrate. Karvy, which could have invoked arbitration, has not done so. On the contrary, it has accepted the claim. Titan does not need to go to arbitration or to have its claim adjudicated: it has got an admission of its claim before the IGRC. 

20.The upshot of this is that Titan now holds in its hands an order of the IGRC that is perfectly enforceable and has the same status and efect as an arbitral Award within the meaning of Sections 30 and 36 of the Arbitration Act. Section 74 puts a settlement agreement in conciliation on par with a settlement award under Section 30. Sub-section (4) of Section 30 makes any such settlement award on agreed terms enforceable as any other Award. Therefore, it logically follows that the IGRC order is fully enforceable under Section 36 of the Arbitration Act, as if it were a decree of the Court.

REPORTABLE

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

IN ITS COMMERCIAL DIVISION

COMM ARBITRATION PETITION (L) NO. 10013 OF 2020

Titan Co Ltd Vs  Karvy Comtrade Ltd & Ors

CORAM:

G.S. PATEL, J

DATED: 19th March 2021

Print Page