In the case of Vasudev Daulatram Sadarangani Vs. Sajni Prem Lalwani AIR 1983 Bombay 268 this Court through the judgment of Justice Lentin, as he then was, held that a petition of probate can be filed when the need arises as it only seeks recognition from the Court to perform a duty-the duty of an executor. The right to file an application for grant of probate or letters of administration is a continuing right which can be exercised at any time after the death of the testator. There is no specific provision in the Limitation Act for filing a petition for probate. The petition for probate shows no lis between the parties and hence is not required to be filed as a suit. Consequently, a testamentary petition could not be covered by the Limitation Act. Indeed through the years petitions have been filed in this Court for probate many years after the death of the deceased and as and when the need for the grant of a probate arises.
125. The Supreme Court whilst considering this issue in the case of Kunvarjeet Singh Khandpur Vs. Kirandeep Kaur MANU/SC/7451/2008 : (2008) 8 SCC 463 set out the summarised decision in Vasudev Sadarangani's case in para 15 of the judgment. The fact that the application for permission to perform the legal duty created by will by filing a probate or letters of administration as a continuous right has been upheld. Once that is done, no question of any bar of limitation would arise. Hence it has been held that there is advisedly no prescribed period of limitation for a grant of probate, or letters of administration. The right to apply is whenever it is necessary which may not be within 3 years from the date of the death of the deceased. However the assumption that under Article 137 the right to apply necessarily accrues on the death of the deceased being unwarranted is observed to be incorrect, as in some cases that would not be so if, as in this case, where it is shown that there was no need to apply for probate at the time of the death of the deceased. If parties were at dispute since that time and if applying for probate or letters of administration was shown to be necessitated by intrinsic evidence, unlike in this case, the assumption may be warranted. This is so held only upon accepting the analogy in the case of Kerala SEB Vs. T.P. Kunhaliumma MANU/SC/0323/1976 : (1976) 4 SCC 634 which held that Article 137 would apply as much to a Probate Petition as to all other applications because in the Limitation Act, 1963, unlike the Limitation Act 1908 the applications under Article 137 included applications under all Acts and not only applications under the CPC. Hence a Probate Petition is held otherwise to fall under Art. 137 of the Limitation Act 1963. But it being a continuous right and being required to be filed only if the situation so entailed, the period of limitation would begin to run only from when the situation warranted a petition.
126. It is contended on behalf of the defendants that Article 137 would apply from the date of the death of the deceased. The contention is absurd. When the Supreme Court accepts, as held by this Court, that the right to sue for probate etc., is a continuous right and can accrue whenever it becomes necessary, the cause of action cannot accrue on the date of the death of the deceased, even if the assumption is not unwarranted. The right to sue would accrue when the need is felt whatever be the assumption as the conclusions in Vasudev Sadarangani's (supra) case which has been upheld as the correct position in law is consistent with all the conclusions except 'b'. Hence the argument that Article 137 would apply from the date of the death of the deceased in all cases cannot be accepted.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Testamentary Suit No. 7 of 2007 in Testamentary Petition No. 964 of 2006
Decided On: 07.03.2013
Appellants: Manilal Sunderji Doshi
Vs.
Respondent: Kamal Manilal Doshi & Ors.
Vs.
Respondent: Kamal Manilal Doshi & Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:R.S. Dalvi, J.
