Showing posts with label cross-examine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cross-examine. Show all posts

Friday, 18 December 2020

Whether prosecution can cross-examine hostile witness with his statement recorded by investigating officer who was not authorized to investigate the case?

 Section 162, Criminal P.C., has been enacted for the protection of an accused person. To hold that a statement, made during the course of an investigation started and carried on without proper authority, would not be excluded from the prohibition contained in Section 162, would be to deprive an accused person, for no fault of his, of the protection afforded to him by the Legislature. It would put a premium on illegality and would be opposed to the intention of the Legislature and the policy underlying Section 162, Criminal P. C,


33. In my opinion, therefore, if an investigation is in all other respects an investigation under chap. 14, it would not cease to be an investigation under that Chapter within the meaning of Section 162, Criminal P.C., if it has been undertaken without necessary permission or on the strength of an invalid permission; and that the statements, recorded during the course of such investigation, would be as much hit by the provisions of Section 162, Criminal P.C., as the statements, recorded during the course of an investigation under chap. 14, properly undertaken. If, therefore, I had come to the conclusion that Ex. P-10 Is a statement made by Mr. Ibrahim to Ahibaran Singh during the course of an investigation, I would have had no hesitation in holding that the investigation was under chap. 14, and that Section 162, Criminal P.C., was applicable to the statement.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD

FULL BENCH

Decided On: 29.04.1949

 Shyamlal Sharma  Vs.   King-Emperor

Authored By : Seth, Raghubar Dayal, Wanchoo

Author: Seth, J.

Citation: MANU/UP/0019/1949,AIR 1949 All 483

Print Page