A Division
Bench of this Court in the aforesaid judgment in PIL No.173 of 2013
and other connected matters had an occasion to consider all the
relevant laws regarding regulation of water supply in the State. In the
said judgment, in Paragraph 188, the Division Bench has referred to
Clause 4.0 of the Maharashtra State Water Policy, 2003. Clause 4.0 of
the Maharashtra State Water Policy, 2003 reads thus:
“4.0 Priority of Water UsageWater
resources shall be allocated in accordance with
the following general principles:
(a) Domestic use for drinking, cooling, hygiene and
sanitation needs including livestock;
(b) Industrial, commercial use and agrobased
industrial use;
(c) Agriculture and hydropower;
(d) Environment and recreation uses;
(e) All other uses.”
9. In Paragraphs 190 and 191, the Division Bench proceeded
to observe thus:
“190. At highest, the use of water for Kumbhmela
and for other religious purposes will be
covered by the last category “e”. Therefore,
according to the Water Policy of the State
Government, if sufficient water cannot be
allocated for usages in categories (a) to (d)
in that order of preference, there cannot be
any allocation of water for Kumbhmela and
other religious purposes. In the National
Water Policy of 2012, in Paragraph 1.2, it is
noted that large parts of India have already
become water stressed as the issues related to
water governance have not been addressed
adequately. It is noted in the said policy that the
mismanagement of water resources has led to a
critical situation in many parts of the country.
191. Needless to add that in case of scarcity or
hydrological drought, in view of Clause (c) of
Section 11 of the said Act of 2005, the water
cannot be released from the reservoirs by the
State for religious ceremonies or religious
objects without the Regulatory Authority
deciding the issue of priority of equitable
distribution of water. Therefore, in case of
scarcity or hydrological drought, the State is
not entitled to release water from the
reservoirs for such purposes without
adjudication being made by the Regulatory
Authority under Clause (c) of Section 11 of
the said Act of 2005.”
(emphasis added)
10. The Division Bench has categorically held that if sufficient
water cannot be allocated for usages in Categories (a) to (d) in that
order of preference, there cannot be any allocation in those categories
of water for Kumbhmela or for other religious purposes. Further, it is
held that in case of scarcity or hydrological drought, the State is not
entitled to release water from the reservoirs in the State for such
religious purposes without an adjudication being made by the
Regulatory Authority under Clause (c) of Section 11 of the said Act of
2005.
11. We have carefully perused the findings recorded by the
Chief Secretary. In Paragraph 15 of the impugned order, the Chief
Secretary has referred to the categories (a) to (e) which are quoted
above. In Paragraph 16, he observed that 60 to 70 lakhs pilgrims were
likely to participate in Shahi snan in the Kumbhmela on 29th August
2015, 13th September 2015 and 18th September 2015. Therefore, 4.50
TMC water was proposed to be released from Gangapur Dam. He
observed that if the water was not released, there might have been a
possibility of epidemic and serious hygiene problems. He has,
therefore, come to a conclusion that the case was governed by category
(a). In our view, even assuming that there was a possibility of law and
order problem being created if sufficient water was not released for the
Kumbhmela, by no stretch of imagination, the release of water to
prevent such law and order situation was covered by any of the
categories (a) to (d) of clause 4.0 of the State Water Policy. Though it is
claimed that the water actually released for Kumbhmela for Shahi snan
(holy bath) was less than what was planned, the fact remains that in
the year 2015-2016 when there was a hydrological drought, the water
was released by the State Government for the benefit of Shahi snan in
breach of its own water policy. We are not on the issue of release of
water for drinking purposes for the benefit of pilgrims as it covered by
category (a). By no stretch of imagination, the release of water for
Shahi snan will be covered by Category (a). Therefore, release of water
for Shahi snan was completely illegal. The State was bound by its own
water policy and the State could not have acted contrary to its own
binding policy. We are not able to accept the strong justification tried
to be offered by the learned Government Pleader for supporting the
impugned order.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE SIDE JURISDICTION
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO.154 OF 2015
Hiralal Motilal Desarda.
Vs
The State of Maharashtra and Others
CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.A.SAYED, JJ
DATED : 22ND DECEMBER 2016
Print Page
Bench of this Court in the aforesaid judgment in PIL No.173 of 2013
and other connected matters had an occasion to consider all the
relevant laws regarding regulation of water supply in the State. In the
said judgment, in Paragraph 188, the Division Bench has referred to
Clause 4.0 of the Maharashtra State Water Policy, 2003. Clause 4.0 of
the Maharashtra State Water Policy, 2003 reads thus:
“4.0 Priority of Water UsageWater
resources shall be allocated in accordance with
the following general principles:
(a) Domestic use for drinking, cooling, hygiene and
sanitation needs including livestock;
(b) Industrial, commercial use and agrobased
industrial use;
(c) Agriculture and hydropower;
(d) Environment and recreation uses;
(e) All other uses.”
9. In Paragraphs 190 and 191, the Division Bench proceeded
to observe thus:
“190. At highest, the use of water for Kumbhmela
and for other religious purposes will be
covered by the last category “e”. Therefore,
according to the Water Policy of the State
Government, if sufficient water cannot be
allocated for usages in categories (a) to (d)
in that order of preference, there cannot be
any allocation of water for Kumbhmela and
other religious purposes. In the National
Water Policy of 2012, in Paragraph 1.2, it is
noted that large parts of India have already
become water stressed as the issues related to
water governance have not been addressed
adequately. It is noted in the said policy that the
mismanagement of water resources has led to a
critical situation in many parts of the country.
191. Needless to add that in case of scarcity or
hydrological drought, in view of Clause (c) of
Section 11 of the said Act of 2005, the water
cannot be released from the reservoirs by the
State for religious ceremonies or religious
objects without the Regulatory Authority
deciding the issue of priority of equitable
distribution of water. Therefore, in case of
scarcity or hydrological drought, the State is
not entitled to release water from the
reservoirs for such purposes without
adjudication being made by the Regulatory
Authority under Clause (c) of Section 11 of
the said Act of 2005.”
(emphasis added)
10. The Division Bench has categorically held that if sufficient
water cannot be allocated for usages in Categories (a) to (d) in that
order of preference, there cannot be any allocation in those categories
of water for Kumbhmela or for other religious purposes. Further, it is
held that in case of scarcity or hydrological drought, the State is not
entitled to release water from the reservoirs in the State for such
religious purposes without an adjudication being made by the
Regulatory Authority under Clause (c) of Section 11 of the said Act of
2005.
11. We have carefully perused the findings recorded by the
Chief Secretary. In Paragraph 15 of the impugned order, the Chief
Secretary has referred to the categories (a) to (e) which are quoted
above. In Paragraph 16, he observed that 60 to 70 lakhs pilgrims were
likely to participate in Shahi snan in the Kumbhmela on 29th August
2015, 13th September 2015 and 18th September 2015. Therefore, 4.50
TMC water was proposed to be released from Gangapur Dam. He
observed that if the water was not released, there might have been a
possibility of epidemic and serious hygiene problems. He has,
therefore, come to a conclusion that the case was governed by category
(a). In our view, even assuming that there was a possibility of law and
order problem being created if sufficient water was not released for the
Kumbhmela, by no stretch of imagination, the release of water to
prevent such law and order situation was covered by any of the
categories (a) to (d) of clause 4.0 of the State Water Policy. Though it is
claimed that the water actually released for Kumbhmela for Shahi snan
(holy bath) was less than what was planned, the fact remains that in
the year 2015-2016 when there was a hydrological drought, the water
was released by the State Government for the benefit of Shahi snan in
breach of its own water policy. We are not on the issue of release of
water for drinking purposes for the benefit of pilgrims as it covered by
category (a). By no stretch of imagination, the release of water for
Shahi snan will be covered by Category (a). Therefore, release of water
for Shahi snan was completely illegal. The State was bound by its own
water policy and the State could not have acted contrary to its own
binding policy. We are not able to accept the strong justification tried
to be offered by the learned Government Pleader for supporting the
impugned order.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE SIDE JURISDICTION
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO.154 OF 2015
Hiralal Motilal Desarda.
Vs
The State of Maharashtra and Others
CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.A.SAYED, JJ
DATED : 22ND DECEMBER 2016
