Showing posts with label death claim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label death claim. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 February 2025

Whether legal heirs have right to file fresh motor accident claim petition after death of injured even though petition filed by him for injury claim is pending?

Here in this case, the claimants, as legal heirs and representatives, have filed a subsequent claim petition while the original was still pending, the right to sue arose on the death of the original claimant and survived on the date when subsequent claim petition was filed. As was held in the case of Surpal Singh (supra), maxim action personalis mortiur cum persona cannot be imported to defeat the purpose and the object of a social welfare legislation of the M.V. Act to give advantage to the wrong doer. Once the status of the claimants as legal heirs or legal representatives are conceded and acknowledged, to deny benefit of compensation, on the ground that injury was personal to the claimant, will be giving a premium to the wrong committed, which would itself defeat the very purpose and object of the legislation. The subsequent petition was filed at the time when the original petition was yet pending. It is not the case that the original petition filed by the original injured came to be dismissed as abated. The cause of action still survived on the day when MACP no.292/17 was filed. The only diversion made by the petitioners is filing of MACP no.292/17 by paying extra Court fees. Thus, the registration number of the petition stood to be different than that of the original and subsequently, the original petition was withdrawn. So filing of another petition on the cause of action, which arose on the death of the injured would be maintainable under Section 166(1). {Para 23}

(c) of the M.V. Act.

 GUJARAT HIGH COURT

Jiteshkumar Rajubhai Parmar vs Bhavnaben Dilipbhai Vyas on 6 April, 2023

C/SCA/6993/2019

Author: Gita Gopi

Print Page