Showing posts with label defective title. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defective title. Show all posts

Saturday, 11 July 2020

Whether a person who acquires possession of the immovable property under a defective title becomes its owner by adverse possession after passing of twelve years?

It is well settled that a person who enters into possession of the property under an invalid transaction of transfer by way of sale etc. and if he has continued in possession for more than twelve years, then, even if the illegal transfer by itself may not convey the title, but, the adverse possession which commence from the date of entering into possession under the illegal transaction or the sale transaction, entered upon not in accordance with law, then the person acquires and perfects title to the property on completion of twelve years as owner. [see: Alla Baksh v. Mohd. Hussain 2 (1996) CLT 301 Karn; State of West Bengal v. The Dalhousie Institute Society MANU/SC/0447/1970 : AIR 1970 SC 1778 and Smt Chandrakantaben J. Modi and Narendra Jayantilal Modi v. Vadilal Bapalal Modi and Ors. MANU/SC/0506/1989 : AIR 1989 SC 1269].

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

Regular First Appeal No. 355 of 1992

Decided On: 25.02.1997

 Kimtu Vs.  Rama Dogra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.K. Palli and R.L. Khurana, JJ.

Citation: 1997 Shimla law Cases 409, MANU/HP/0106/1997
Print Page

Tuesday, 8 May 2018

Whether bonafide purchaser can be granted compensation for improvement made by her in absence of pleading and proof?

Under provisions of Section 51 of the said Act, a person making improvements in the property should have acted believing in good faith that he is absolutely entitled to the property. What actions are taken believing in good faith would depend on the facts of each case and hence, the importance of necessary pleadings in that regard. A general belief that the party was a bona fide purchaser for valuable consideration without any further details would not suffice the requirements of making out a case for grant of compensation under Section 51 of the said Act. Hence, the absence of pleadings that the defendant No. 3 believed in good faith that she was absolutely entitled to the property is a big handicap in her effort to seek compensation under Section 51 of the said Act.

9. The evidence on record led by the defendant No. 3 who was the purchaser of the suit property indicates that before executing the sale deed in favour of the defendant No. 3, no public notice came to be issued. It was also admitted that neither he nor the defendant No. 3 were present when the sale deed was executed. He further admitted that after receiving the telegram at Exhibit-52 from the plaintiff, no attempt was made to contact the plaintiff nor was any enquiry made in the office of the Sub Registrar with regard to the plaintiff's sale deed.

10. In Bajrang @ Hanumant Tatyaba Kakade (supra), the test that has to be applied to find out if the purchaser acted bona fide and took reasonable care and caution in making enquiry into the title of the property has been referred to. In paras 5 and 6 of said decision, it has been observed thus:

"5............................................................ The oft quoted and well known passage is reiterated in Bailey v. Barnes, (1984) 1 Ch. 25, 35 which aptly describes the obligation of the vendee before the purchase and that reads thus :

"A purchaser of property is under no legal obligation to investigate his vendor's title. But in dealing with real property, as in other matters of business, regard is had to the usual course of business; and a purchaser who wilfully departs from it in order to avoid acquiring a knowledge of his vendor's title is not allowed to derive any advantage from his wilful ignorance or defect which would have come to his knowledge if he had transacted his business in the ordinary way."
6. The aforesaid is the test which has to be applied to find out whether the purchaser acted bona fide and took reasonable care and caution in making usual enquiry into the title. If he succeeds in showing that even if he had transacted the business in ordinary way he was not in a position together that there was none other owner than the vendors, then, such vendee could be described as bona fide purchaser. On the other hand, if while transacting the business in the ordinary way the vendee would have come to know that there were owners other than the vendor, it cannot be said that such vendee has acted bona fide".

If the evidence led by the defendant No. 3 is tested on the aforesaid touchstone, the same falls short for holding that the defendant No. 3 had acted believing in good faith and had taken reasonable care and caution before purchasing the property.

11. The plea as raised by the defendant No. 3 with regard to absence of mutation entries in the name of the plaintiff cannot further her case inasmuch as the mutation entries are taken for fiscal purposes and cannot be treated as documents of title. Merely on the ground that the plaintiff had not got any mutation entry made in her favour pursuant to purchasing the suit property would not dispense with the necessary enquiries that are required to be made by a purchaser who believes in good faith that he is absolutely entitled to the same. The expressions "believing in good faith" and "absolutely" entitled indicate the nature of enquiries required to be undertaken by a purchaser who seeks to rely upon the provisions of Section 51 of the said Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 317 of 2014

Decided On: 31.07.2017

Maya Namdeorao Kharodkar Vs. Bhagyashree Pramod Dave and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.S. Chandurkar, J.

Citation: 2018(1) MHLJ 150
Print Page