Kerala HC: BNSS Gives Wider Protection To Accused Of Unsound Mind Or Intellectual Disability, Will Apply Retrospectively

 Following the principles enunciated above, all applications filed and steps taken in a pending proceeding prior to 1.7.2024 shall be under the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. As I discussed above, Chapter XXVII of the Sanhita has given wider protection to a person of unsound mind or a person suffering from intellectual disability. Where two persons suffering from a mental disability or intellectual disability are dealt with differently, one under the Code, and the other under the Sanhita, it amounts to a violation of Article 14 of the Constitution. Among equals, the law should be equal and equally administered and should be treated alike. The guarantee of 'equal protection' under Article 14 is a guarantee of equal treatment of persons in 'equal circumstances'. To preserve the fundamental right of an individual, the provisions of the Sanhita can be extended retrospectively to any proceedings initiated prior to 1.7.2024. The saving provision under Section 531 of the Sanhita shall not deter the enforcement of the fundamental right of an accused. Issue No.2 is answered as above. {Para 29}

The present case

30. Annexure A3 report reveals that the petitioner is suffering from severe dementia, and the chances of recovery are less. The petitioner is aged 74 years. The report states that the petitioner's soundness of mind is to be assessed in detail by a psychiatrist. The learned Special Judge has taken the stand that if the party requires it, he should be subjected to an examination by a psychiatrist. The learned Special Judge lost sight of the principle that he has an onerous responsibility to try the issue as to whether the petitioner has any mental disability. The order impugned is patently illegal and irregular. The impugned order, therefore, stands set aside. The learned Special Judge shall reconsider the application and proceed under Chapter XXVII of the Sanhita.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

Crl. MC No. 6370 of 2023

Decided On: 05.09.2024

V.I. Thankappan Vs. State of Kerala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K. Babu, J.

Citation: MANU/KE/3656/2024,2024:KER:67342

Print Page

Shifting the Paradigm: How BNSS 2023 Transforms Criminal Procedure for Accused Persons of Unsound Mind

 The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 replaces select portions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) 1973 and, in doing so, rewrites India’s response to accused persons whose mental condition prevents them from mounting a defence. The reform moves beyond outdated language and narrow categories, extends wider substantive protection, and tightens procedural safeguards.

1. Structural Re-location of the Law

CrPC housed the rules in Chapter XXV, Sections 328 – 339. BNSS mirrors this structure in Chapter XXVII, Sections 367 – 378, ensuring continuity for practitioners while signalling a fresh policy outlook.

Print Page