Showing posts with label departmental enqiry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label departmental enqiry. Show all posts

Monday, 10 October 2022

How to appreciate evidence if state is taking different stand while filing written statement in Motor accident proceeding and while taking departmental proceeding against concerned driver?

 12.11 The Road Transport Corporation, in order to

escape its liability in the M.A.C.T. matter, has

taken up the contention that the driver was

driving in a proper manner and rider of the two

wheeler was driving in a rash and negligent but

on the other hand in the disciplinary

proceedings it is contended that its own driver

was rash and negligent. It is required for any

litigant more so an instrumentality of the state

to adhere to one set of facts and not change

the set of facts depending on its convenience

and/or requirements.

12.12 Despite the existence of the fax dated

26.07.2015, of the Divisional Cum Controller to

the Managing Director, and the report of the

Deputy Chief Security and Vigilance Officer

dated 05.08.2016, a written statement had

been filed absolving the respondent-driver of

any liability. Once the driver stood absolved by

the said written statement, it is impermissible

for the Road Transport Corporation to initiate

the disciplinary enquiry.

12.13 It was for the respondent, Road Transport

Corporation to have come clean and clearly and

categorically stated in M.V.C.Nos.3282 &

3283/2015 that it was the driver's fault for

driving the vehicle in a rash and negligent

manner and offered to make payment of the

compensation due in the said proceedings. It is

only in order to try and escape the payment of

compensation that a false stand has been taken

by the Road Transport Corporation, which is

established to be false by the contents of the

present writ petition as also by the M.A.C.T. in

its order dated 08.09.2016 in the aforesaid

M.V.Cs.

12.14 It is also relevant to take note that not only was

the precious time of the M.A.C.T. wasted by

taking the said false defence offered by the

Road Transport Corporation, but more

importantly, the victim of the road accident was

denied, immediate relief, and succour by way of

payment of compensation. The said payment

being delayed until the finding being rendered

by the M.A.C.T. after evidence being led. These

kind of actions on part of the Road Transport

Corporation are required to be deprecated and

are deprecated.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

WRIT PETITION NO. 24370 OF 2019 (L-KSRTC)

BETWEEN:

THE KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT

CORPORATION  Vs SRI GANGANNA

BEFORE

 MR JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2022

Print Page

Saturday, 12 December 2020

Whether the employer will be liable for defamation of employee if he conducts departmental enquiry against him?

 In the present case, the defendant has taken the defence of privilege. The question is whether the charge-sheet issued against the plaintiff, the enquiry report and the letter of dismissal of the plaintiff can be said to be protected by absolute privilege or qualified privilege?


37. The enquiry proceeding was initiated by the defendant by issuing the charge-sheet on the basis of information received that the matriculation certificate and mark-sheet submitted by the plaintiff at the time of his appointment were not genuine. The information was received from a reliable source and in my opinion could not be brushed aside as frivolous. If it was finally established that the information was true, that would have amounted to a criminal offence on the part of the plaintiff. Having got such information, it was incumbent upon the management of the defendant to hold an enquiry into the matter. Such enquiry was held as part of the management's duty and in larger public interest. As such, in my considered opinion, the enquiry proceedings and all publications made in connection therewith were privileged. As Lord Finlay L.C. observed in Adam vs. Ward, (1917) Appeal Cases 309, if a communication is made in pursuance of a duty, the same would be privileged. His Lordship was of the view that this privilege is qualified and may be rebutted by proof of express malice. In the present case, no case of malice has been established by the plaintiff. Hence, at least, the defence of qualified privilege would be available to the defendant.


38. The law is fairly clear that any step which is essentially a step in a judicial or quasi-judicial proceeding would be immune from liability for defamation as it gives rise to an occasion for privilege.  In O'Conor vs. Waldron, MANU/PR/0085/1934 : AIR 1935 PC 3, Lord Atkin observed that proceedings before an executive or administrative authority or a step to initiate such proceedings can only give rise to an occasion for qualified privilege. Gatley on Libel and Slander (5th Ed., page 181) states that no action will lie for defamatory statements contained in any document which is incidental to the proper initiation of judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings, information, complaint, writ or petition by which the quasi-judicial Tribunal is set in motion.


39. I have no doubt in my mind that the protection of privilege should extend to enquiry proceedings conducted by an employer against an employee. It would definitely not be desirable if an employer in spite of receiving information that an employee is allegedly committing a crime or other wrongful act detrimental to the public interest, refrains from holding an enquiry into the matter for the fear of being exposed to a defamation suit. Such a position would be extremely harmful to the interest of the public at large.


40. The question is whether such privilege should be absolute or qualified. I am of the view that the privilege should be qualified. This means that if the plaintiff is able to establish malice on the part of the defendant in conducting an enquiry proceeding against him by issuing charge-sheet, the defence of privilege will not be available to the defendant. However, in the present case, the plaintiff has been unable to establish malice on the part of the defendant in conducting the enquiry proceeding against him by issuing charge-sheet which culminated in his dismissal order. I am of the considered view that the materials complained of by the plaintiff and forming the basis of the present defamation suit are protected by qualified privilege. The fact that at a subsequent point of time due to intervention of the Hon'ble President of India, the order of dismissal was withdrawn and the plaintiff was reinstated in service, does not change the situation.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

CS 11 of 2006

Decided On: 17.02.2017

 Manik Lal Bhowmik  Vs.  Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Arijit Banerjee, J.

Citation: MANU/WB/0098/2017

Print Page