Showing posts with label essence of contract. Show all posts
Showing posts with label essence of contract. Show all posts

Wednesday, 15 April 2020

How to appreciate evidence when the defendant pleads that time was the essence of the contract for the sale of immovable property?

From a perusal of the papers, it is seen that though the defendants had stated that the sale deed had to be executed within a period of three months from the date of the agreement, they have not taken any steps to terminate the agreement on the expiry of the period given under the agreement. The defendant have also accepted the execution of the agreement of sale and their only grievances is that the plaintiff had not come forward to complete the sale within the agreed time. Therefore according to the plaintiff time was never contemplated as essence of the contract, further, it is the admitted fact that the defendants had not obtained the sale deed from the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board on the date of the agreement which once again was a requirement for having the sale deed executed in favour of the plaintiff even if there is no stipulation to this effect. The right to convey the property would accrue to the defendants only upon receiving the sale deed from the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board and therefore it can be safely concluded that time was never contemplated as a stipulation for the contract.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

A.S. No. 915 of 2009 and M.P. No. 1 of 2012

Decided On: 13.03.2019

S. Devi  Vs. V. Anburaj and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.T. Asha, J.

Citation: AIR 2020(NOC) 30 Mad
Print Page

Sunday, 26 May 2019

Whether time will be essence of contract in suit for specific performance of contract?

Though it was sought to be urged on behalf of the plaintiffs that the agreement being one for sale of immovable property, the time was not the essence of the contract and therefore the plaintiffs waited till 25.09.2006 for filing the suit for specific performance, that contention cannot be accepted. Once it is found that in view of a specific date being mentioned in the agreement for execution of the sale-deed, the limitation would be governed by the First Part of Article 54 of the Act of 1963, the question as to whether time was the essence of the contract is irrelevant and the same is not required to be considered. Reference in that regard can be usefully made to the decision in Sumerchand Hukumchand & Others Versus Hukumchand Mathurdas & Others [MANU/MP/0049/1965 : 1965 MP.L.J. 829] wherein it has been held that the question as to whether time is the essence of the contract is not at all relevant for determining whether the First or the Second Part of Article 113 of Limitation Act, 1908 would apply to a particular case. The only material consideration is that when the parties have agreed to complete the transaction on a particular date specified, the limitation would be governed by the First Part of Article 54 of the Act of 1963.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal Nos. 457 and 458/2015

Decided On: 03.09.2018

 Arvind  Vs. Baba Jasbirsing Kalsi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.S. Chandurkar, J.

Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 601
Print Page

Thursday, 1 December 2016

When time is not essence of contract?

Learned counsel
for the appellant further argued that in the case of sale of
immovable property there is no presumption as to time being the
essence of the contract. Even if it is not the essence of the
contract, the court may infer that it is to be performed in a
reasonable time if the conditions are: (i) from the express terms
of the contract; (ii) from the nature of the property; and (iii) from
the surrounding circumstances, for example: the object of
making the contract and for that reliance has been placed upon
(1993) 1 Supreme Court Cases 519 Chand Rani (Smt.)
Dead) by Lrs… Appellants versus Kamal Rani (Smt.) (Dead)
by Lrs… Respondents. 
The agreement to sale (Ext. 3)
contains the terms which have been agreed upon that the
transaction of sale should be completed within six months from
the date of execution of the agreement i.e. from 28.10.1988 till
27.04.1989. In last paragraph there is term that if the vendee
fails to get the sale deed registered within the time then, amount
of only Rs. 25,000/- will be forfeited and that cannot be realized
from executant. Further it is mentioned that the land to be sold
would be measured and the payment of the price would be finally
calculated accordingly. In the case of Smt. Indira Kaur and
others (supra) and also in the case of Chand Rani (Supra) it
has been held that the law is well settled that in transaction of
sale of immovable properties time is not the essence of the
contract. The Apex Court in the case of Balasaheb Dayandeo
Naik (dead) through LRS & Ors. vs. Appasaheb Dattatraya
Pawar reported in (2008) 4 SCC Page 464 in paragraph 10,
11, 12 and 14 held that the time was not the essence of the
contract. Here also the land going to be sold is immovable
property and agricultural land and as such time was not the
essence of the contract. There is nothing on the record on behalf
of defendants to show that the defendants got measured the land
rather the plaintiff after sending the Ext. 1/A (legal notice)
requested the defendants to get the land measured and
demarcated and to get the sale deed executed. From the oral 
evidences adduced on behalf of the parties also it reveals that the
time was not the essence of the contract and it was never agreed
that the entire earnest money will be forfeited rather by way of
cost only Rs. 25,000/- was to be forfeited. No party can be
allowed to go beyond the express term contained in the
agreement to sale. Accordingly, it is held that the time was not
the essence of the contract.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
First Appeal No.42 of 2006

Most.Sita Devi V Mahal Sahkari Grih Nirman Samiti Ltd. Patna, 
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JITENDRA MOHAN
SHARMA
Citation:AIR 2016 Patna 191
Date: 06-09-2016
Print Page

Saturday, 28 February 2015

When time is essence of contract in suit for specific performance of contract?

This is an illustrious case of dilatory tactics by the petitioner who entered into the contract to purchase the land of 500 sq. yds. in the heart of the city of Delhi by agreement dated February 27,1975. The hard fact is that the defendant was in dire need of money to celebrate his daughter's marriage on may 16, 1975. The agreement was that the draft sale deed should be finalized with in seven days and sale deed registered. Time is, therefore, the essence of the contract in this case. The defendant insisted upon payment of consideration in cash. The respondent sent the approved draft sale deed immediately but the petitioner did not give final draft as contemplated by the agreement since he had to obtain the income tax clearance certificate which he did not obtain. Ext. 5 and 9, the letters written by the respondent was always willing to have the sale deed executed but the petitioner delayed the execution of the sale deed on one pretext or the other petitioner did not give any reply to any of the tow letters. The learned single Judge as also the Division Bench of the High Court have in extenso one into the evidence and found that the petitioner was not ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. He did not have necessary cash for payment of the amount. The petitioner has produced before the Division Bench by way of additional evidence, his account to show that he has got one lakh and odd. Even that fell short of the required amount. What is material in this case is that the respondent was in dire need of cash to calebrate the marriage of his daughter. The petitioner did not offer ash to the respondent. Under those circumstances, the High Court was clearly right in saying that the petitioner was not ready and willing to perform his part of the contract under clause (c) of Section 16 of the Specific Relief Act.

Supreme Court of India

His Holiness Acharya Swamiganesh ... vs Shri Sita Ram Thapar on 30 April, 1996
Equivalent citations: 1996 AIR 2095, 1996 SCC (4) 526

Bench: Ramaswamy, K.
      
Print Page