Showing posts with label examination of narrator. Show all posts
Showing posts with label examination of narrator. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 September 2026

Bombay HC: Hearsay evidence of a witness is not admissible unless the narrator is examined and states that he had narrated that fact to the witness

 Now let us examine whether what was heard by prosecution witnesses viz., PW2 Nandkumar Pol, PW3 Sunita Pol and PW4 Duryodhan Kadam allegedly from the victim minor child aged about 3 1/2 years constitutes piece of admissible evidence. Section 59 of the Evidence Act provides that all facts except contents of documents or electronic record could be proved by oral evidence. As per mandate of Section 60, oral evidence must, in all cases be direct. When such evidence refers to a fact which could be perceived by any sense other than hearing or witnessing, the evidence must be of a witness who says he perceives it. It is well settled that the best available evidence should be brought before the court. This provision aims at rejection of evidence which is not direct i.e. rejection of hearsay evidence. Whatever a person is heard to say disclosed by another person is not admissible. Something which a witness before the court says that he heard from a third party who is not called as a witness, then the statement of that witness is inadmissible to prove the truth of the fact stated. In other words, secondary evidence of any oral statement is not admissible. Thus, evidence not based on personal knowledge but what has been heard from others being hearsay evidence, is inadmissible. Rejection of hearsay evidence is for the reason that such statement cannot be made subjected to the test of cross examination. It may suffer from many possible deficiencies, suppressions, error and trustworthiness which lie underneath the bare assertion. Therefore, evidence of a witness that he learnt the fact from another person cannot be admitted, particularly, when the another person does not step in the witness box and says that he had narrated that particular fact to the particular witness. In the light of this position in law, what PW2 Nandkumar Pol, PW3 Sunita Pol and PW4 Duryodhan Kadam are stating to be heard by them from the alleged minor victim of the crime in question, cannot constitute direct evidence which is admissible in law. On the contrary, evidence of all these three witnesses, in respect of the disclosure to them by the alleged minor victim of the crime in question, is totally hearsay, and as such, inadmissible. The same cannot form a basis for convicting the appellant/accused of offences alleged against him. On this backdrop, non-examination of the alleged minor victim of the crime in question and nondisclosure of any reason for his non-examination by the Investigating Officer PW5 Dy.S.P Somanath Gharge, casts a serious shadow of doubt on the prosecution case.

{Para 14}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 820 of 2010

Decided On: 23.08.2017

Dattatraya Ramchandra Sutar Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.M. Badar, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1922/2017,2018 ALLMR (Cri) 663

Print Page