Showing posts with label execution sale. Show all posts
Showing posts with label execution sale. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 May 2016

When Auction sale should not be set aside?

Above all, clause 2 of Rule 90, Order XXI CPC requires the J.Dr. to demonstrate the substantial injury sustained by him by reason of any irregularity or fraud either in publishing or conducting the sale of immovable property, for the Court to be satisfied to set aside the sale so conducted. It is thus, clear that it is not every irregularity, which can fetch a satisfaction for the Court to set aside the sale conducted. The irregularity must be of such a grave nature and magnitude that it should result in causing substantial injury to the interest of the J.Dr.
The Supreme Court has spelt out the principle in this regard in Saheb Khan v. Mohd.Yusufuddin and others in the following words of Justice Ruma Pal speaking for a three-Judge bench:
Therefore before the sale can be set aside merely establishing a material irregularity or fraud will not do. The applicant must go further and establish to the satisfaction of the court that the material irregularity or fraud has resulted in substantial injury to the applicant. Conversely even if the applicant has suffered substantial injury by reason of the sale, this would not be sufficient to set the sale aside unless substantial injury has been occasioned by a material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the sale. (See: Dhirendra Nath Gorai and Suibal Chandra Shaw and Ors. v. Sudhir Chandra Ghosh and Ors.(1964) 6 SCC 101; Jaswantlal Natvarlal thakkar v. Sushilaben Manilal Dangarwala and Ors. (1991) Supp.2 SCC 691; Kadiyala Rama Rao v. Gutala Kahna Rao (dead) by L.Rs and others (2000)3 SCC 87).
In the instant case, no such substantial injury suffered by the J.Dr. was either urged or demonstrated.
Hence, I do not find any merit in the appeal preferred by the Judgment Debtor and hence it deserves to be dismissed.
Andhra High Court
Ch.Mahender vs D.Venkat Reddy And 3 Others on 21 August, 2015
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE NOOTY RAMAMOHANA RAO

CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.421 OF 2015 and batch         

Citation;AIR 2016 (NOC)287 HYD
Print Page

Thursday, 24 May 2012

Distinction between execution sale by civil court and by revenue authorities

Sales held by Civil Courts made after enquiry and after the fulfilment of all the required formalities are in a very different position from sales by Revenue authorities. In the former case you have a Court of Justice at. work with its impartiality and its care. In the other you have fiscal authorities at work, and experience and common knowledge tell us that you certainly cannot expect and do not get the same qualities of impartiality and so forth in fiscal authorities as you are entitled to expect and ordinarily do obtain from the Civil Courts So to apply to sales by fiscal authorities precisely the same law which it is proper to apply to sales by Civil Courts would seem to me to be a very gross legal extravagance.
Bombay High Court
Mahadev Narayan Datar vs Sadashiv Keshav Limaye And ... on 9 February, 1920
Equivalent citations: (1920) 22 BOMLR 1082
Author: K Norman Macleod
Bench: N Macleod, Kt., Heaton

Norman Macleod, Kt., C.J.
Print Page