Showing posts with label fees of arbitrator. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fees of arbitrator. Show all posts

Thursday, 16 August 2018

Whether Arbitrators can be removed if they refuse to accept the Arbitrator Fees agreed by parties in Arbitration Agreement?

In Mr. K.K. Sarin and Ors. (Supra), this Court had considered the issue whether the Arbitral Tribunal is bound by the agreement between the parties regarding the fees payable to the Arbitral Tribunal and held as under:-

"22. Therefore, even though I agree with the senior counsel for the petitioner that the arbitrators are bound by the agreement between the parties as to the payment of fee and if the said fee is not acceptable to them, are free not to accept the office as an arbitrator and/or to recuse themselves and cannot demand fee in supersession of the said agreement but in the facts of the present case I find the petitioner to have agreed to the fee schedule. The agreement between the petitioner and the respondent as to the fee schedule could always be novated and in this case is found to have been novated. Even otherwise there is no justification whatsoever for the petitioner to have agreed to pay and paid fee higher than agreed and/or as per its circular in arbitration-I and to make a grievance with respect thereto at the fag end of the proceedings in arbitration-II. The ASG had handed over a compilation of judgments on waiver but in view of above, it is not felt necessary to cite the same. The first challenge of the petitioner thus fails."

(emphasis supplied)

In Madras Fertilizers Limited (Supra), the High Court of Madras had held that a party cannot be forced to pay fees higher than what they are capable of paying to the Arbitrator. It was held as under:-

"22. The words used in Section 14(1)(a) is that the mandate of an Arbitrator shall terminate if he has become de jure unable to perform his functions. (emphasis supplied). It is true that the second respondent is ready to go ahead with the proceedings, but somehow, the proceedings got bogged down in the light of the controversy with regard to fixation of fees by the second respondent. The word 'Perform his functions used in Section 14(1)(a) will simply performing his functions effectively without any bias and with full confidence of both the parties. Performing this functions does not simply going through the motion without instilling confidence in the minds of the parties.

23. Now, if the mandate is not terminated and the second respondent is permitted to continue with Arbitration proceedings, it will amount to forcing a higher fee on the petitioner which they are not capable of paying. Further, after these controversies, disputes, exchange of correspondences, etc. with regard to fixation of fee, if the second respondent continues the Arbitration proceedings, the petitioner may not be in a proper frame of mind to proceed with the arbitration before the second respondent. They will definitely have some doubt as to the conduct of the Arbitrator and this doubt would certainly lead to loss of confidence. Therefore, such an unpleasant situation is to be avoided in the best interest of the parties including the Arbitrator.

 In my view, the Arbitral Tribunal is bound by the Arbitration Agreement between the parties, which is the source of its power. The Arbitral Tribunal cannot accept the appointment in part and rewrite the Arbitration Agreement between the parties.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

O.M.P. (T) (COMM.) 39/2018, IA Nos. 6559 and 9228/2018

Decided On: 20.07.2018

 National Highways Authority of India Vs. Gammon Engineers and Contractor Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Navin Chawla, J.


Print Page

Thursday, 31 May 2018

On what basis fees of arbitrator is to be calculated?

A reading of the above would show that the concept prevailing around the world is that the fee of the Arbitral Tribunal is fixed on the cumulative value of the claim and counter claim.
12. As noted in Union of India v. Singh Builders Syndicate (2009) 4 SCC 523 and reiterated in Sanjeev Kumar Jain v. Raghubir Saran Charitable Trust and Ors., (2012) 1 SCC 455, high costs are seriously hampering the growth of arbitration as an effective dispute resolution process. Sometimes arbitration becomes disproportionately expensive. Reasonableness and certainty about total costs are the key to the development of arbitration.
13. If India is to emerge as a preferred place of arbitration and the arbitration culture is to grow in India, it is imperative that such fee structure be rationalised so as to make it cost effective. This, as noted, was the intent of the legislature for bringing about the amendment to the Act. Therefore,

there is no reason for the Fourth Schedule to the Act to be given a meaning which is different from usage by various institutions conducting arbitration proceedings in India and abroad.
14. Even in the general parlance, “Sum in dispute” shall include both claim and counter claim amounts. If the legislature intended to have the Arbitral Tribunal exceed the ceiling limit by charging separate fee for claim and counter claim amounts, it would have provided so in the Fourth Schedule.
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 15th May, 2018
 O.M.P.(MISC) 5/2018
DELHI STATE INDUSTRIAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD. (DSIIDC)
versus
BAWANA INFRA DEVELOPMENT (P) LTD. 
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
Print Page

Thursday, 28 September 2017

Whether parties have right to determine fees of arbitrator?

11. The amended Section 31(8) has done away with the expression “Unless otherwise agreed by the parties…….” and reads as under:—
“(8) The costs of an arbitration shall be fixed by the arbitral tribunal in accordance with section 31A.”
12. Section 31(8) of the Act does not stipulate that the agreement of the parties shall have an overriding effect. The effect of the amendment and specific deletion of the expression “Unless otherwise agreed by the parties…..” shows that the legislative intent that the power of the parties to enter into an agreement with regard to fixing of the fees has been specifically taken away.
13. The regime as contemplated by Section 31(8) read with Section 31(A) of the Act now holds the field.
14. Section 11(14) of the Act empowers the High Court to frame rules for determination of fee of the arbitral tribunal and refers to as a guidance to the rates specified in Schedule IV of the Act. The explanation to Section 11(14) carves out an exception with regard to international commercial arbitration and arbitrations (other than international commercial arbitrations) where parties have agreed for determination of fees as per the rules of an arbitration institution.
15. The above clearly shows that the right of the parties to enter into an agreement with regard to determination of fee for the arbitral tribunal has been restricted to international commercial arbitrations and arbitrations (other than international commercial arbitrations) where parties have agreed for determination of fees as per the rules of an arbitration institution.
16. Thus the contention of learned senior counsel for the petitioner, that the petitioner's nominee arbitrator has consented to the fee schedule stipulated by the Policy Circular is also of no consequence.
In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
(Before Sanjeev Sachdeva, J.)
National Highways Authority of India v. Gayatri Jhansi Roadways Limited .
ARB.A. 1/2017 and I.A. Nos. 8086/2017 (stay) & 9441/2017 (for waiver of cost)
Decided on September 11, 2017
Citation:2017 SCC OnLine Del 10285
Print Page