Showing posts with label first suit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label first suit. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 November 2019

Whether second suit will be barred by res judicata if first suit was dismissed as it was premature?

 It is not that every matter decided in a former suit, can be pleaded as res-judicata in a subsequent suit. To consider a matter "res-judicata", one of the conditions is, the matter directly and substantially in issue in the subsequent suit must have been heard and finally decided by the Court in the first suit. To support the plea of res-judicata, it is not enough that the same matter shall be in issue. It is also important that the matter was heard and finally decided. The expression "heard and finally decided" refers to a matter on which the Court, having exercised its judicial mind, has recorded a finding and arrived at a decision on a contested matter.

14. Thus, taking into consideration the facts of the case and the ratio laid down in the case of Shedon Singh (supra), I hold and conclude that since the rejection of the first suit on the ground that the same was premature and not on merits, the findings rendered in the first suit are not binding on the parties, as well as, on the learned trial Judge in the second suit on the ground of res-judicata. The Question is answered accordingly.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Second Appeal No. 795 of 2005

Decided On: 16.04.2019

 Shrikant Waman Pawaskar Vs. Deepali Dinanath Pawaskar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sandeep K. Shinde, J.

Citation: 2019(6) MHLJ 447
Print Page

Tuesday, 31 May 2016

Whether subsequent suit is barred by principle of O2 R 2 of CPC if plaintiff was not aware of his said right at time of first suit?

The plaintiff did not ask for relief for arrears of salary for the obvious reason that the plain- tiff in the 1949 suit asked fox' setting aside of the im- pugned orders and an order that the plaintiff was deemed to be continuing in service. The plaintiff proceeded on the existing law as it stood by reason of the decision in High Commissioner for India v. 1. M. Lall(1). The Judicial Committee in that case held that a civil servant was not entitled to. sue the State for recovering arrears of salary and pay. Counsel for Madhya Pradesh relied on the decision in Province of Punjab v. Pandit Tara Chand(2) which held that a public servant had a right to bring a suit for ar- rears .of pay. The decision of the Judicial Committee in Lall's case (supra) takes a contrary view to the decision of the Federal Court in Pandit (1) 75 I.A. 225.
(2) [1947] F.C.R. 89.
Tara Chand's case (supra). It it true that the decision of the Federal Court in Pandit Tara Chand's case (supra) was not brought to the notice of the Privy Council. Under section 208 of the Government of India Act 1935 the law declared by the Judgment of the Privy Council had to be followed by all the Courts including the Federal Court. Therefore, the earlier decision of the Federal Court though not expressly overruled by the Judicial Committee must be deemed to have overruled by implication by the decision of the Judicial Committee in Lall's case (supra). This Court in State of Bihar v. Abdul Majid(1) stated that a Government servant could ask for arrears of salary. Counsel for Madhya Pradesh said that the decision of this Court in Abdul Majid's case (supra) declared what the exist- ing law has been, and, therefore, the plaintiff could not contend that it was not open to him to ask for arrears of salary in the 1949 suit. It is in that background that Madhya Pradesh contends that the plaintiff not having asked for relief under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Proce- dure would not be entitled to claim salary in the 1956 suit. The contention of Madhya Pradesh cannot be accepted. The plaintiff will be barred under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure only when he omits to sue for or relinquishes the claim in a suit with knowledge that he has a right to. sue for that relief. It will not be correct to say that while the decision of the Judicial Committee in Lall's case (supra) was holding the field the plaintiff could be said to know that he was yet entitled to make a claim for arrears of salary. On the contrary, it will be correct to say that he knew that he was not entitled to make such a claim. If at the date of the former suit the plain- tiff is not aware of the right on which he insists in the latter suit the plaintiff cannot be said to be disentitled to the relief in the latter suit. The reason is that at the date of the former suit the plaintiff is not aware of the right on which he insists in the subsequent suit. A right which a litigant does not know that he possesses or a right which is not in existence at the time of the first suit can hardly be regarded as a "portion of his claim" within the meaning of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. See Amant Bibi v. Imdad Husain(2). The crux of the matter is presence or lack of awareness of the right at the time of first suit.
Supreme Court of India
State Of Madhya Pradesh vs State Of Maharashtra & Ors on 5 January, 1977
Equivalent citations: 1977 AIR 1466, 1977 SCR (2) 555

Bench: Ray, A.N. (Cj)
     
Print Page