Showing posts with label head of branches. Show all posts
Showing posts with label head of branches. Show all posts

Friday, 5 December 2025

Bombay HC: Whether a suit for partition between heads of all the branches of a joint Hindu property is maintainable even though children of those heads are not added as parties to the suit?

As laid down in the Principles of Hindu Law by Mulla in paragraph No. 332, in a suit for partition, the heads of all the branches are the necessary parties. Though not in so many words expressed by the district court, it was clearly observed that both the branches, of Shivram and Totaram, were duly represented in the suit and consequently, in the operative part, the suit property was directed to be divided in two equal parts and possession of one portion each was to be given to both these branches. It was further observed that the intention of the parties to have a particular relief has to be gathered from the pleadings and it was appropriate that the dispute between the two branches was settled once for all. Even if all the sons of Shivram and Totaram were not the parties to the suit, and though strictly speaking the situation was not covered by Order XLI Rule 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure, having found that there was due representation of both the branches and there could not have been any dispute as to equal share of each of these two branches, the interest of justice was met by decreeing the suit partly and by directing the suit property to be divided in two halves only. Pertinently, the district court had not directed a further division amongst the coparceners inter se from each of the branches. {Para 13}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 249 of 1992, X.OBJ/41/2022 in SA/249/1992 and CA/1776/1992 in SA/249/1992

Decided On: 22.04.2022

Gumansing Shivram Patil Vs. Bhika Harsing Patil and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Mangesh S. Patil, J.

Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine Bom 866 : (2022) 6 Mah LJ 177 : (2022) 4 Bom CR 124 : (2023) 1 HLR 528 : (2023) 242 AIC 295,
 MANU/MH/1409/2022

Print Page