Showing posts with label letter of administration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label letter of administration. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 June 2025

Beneficiary's Right to Seek Letters of Administration When Executor Refuses to Act: Analyzing Vatsala Srinivasan v. Shyamala Raghunathan

 Introduction

The administration of estates through wills can face significant challenges when the appointed executor refuses to perform their duties. A crucial question arises: Can beneficiaries under a will independently seek letters of administration when the executor fails to act? The Supreme Court of India addressed this vital issue in the landmark case of Vatsala Srinivasan v. Shyamala Raghunathan (2016) 13 SCC 253, establishing clear legal principles that protect beneficiaries' rights.

When a testator appoints an executor in their will, the expectation is that this person will dutifully carry out the administration of the estate. However, situations arise where:

Print Page

Friday, 25 March 2022

Whether the court can revoke letter of administration if all legal heirs are not made parties to the suit?

  As per Section 263, the grant of Letters of Administration may be revoked for “just cause”. Explanation (a) under Section 263 states that just cause shall be deemed to exist where the proceedings were defective in substance. Illustration (ii) under Section 263 deals with a case where “the grant was made without citing parties who ought to have been cited”. {Para 6}

7. It may be of interest to note that some of the colonial statutes contain Illustrations which form part of the statutes themselves. The Indian Succession Act, 1925 is one such enactment.

8. Therefore, the High Court was right in holding that a just cause existed for revoking the grant. Hence, we do not find any error in the order of the High Court warranting our interference. Therefore the appeals are dismissed.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 798-799 OF 2013;

SWAMINATHAN & ORS. Vs ALANKAMONY (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.

Coram: HEMANT GUPTA; V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, JJ.

Dated: 9 March, 2022

Print Page

Tuesday, 22 June 2021

Can the court refuse to issue a letter of administration regarding demonetized currency notes laying in the bank locker?

  Merely because the Government has issued a

demonetization policy, it does not mean that the claim as to

the requisite currency notes is extinguished. If we go by the

report of Assistant Superintendent, we may find that apart

from banned currency notes of Rs.500/- and Rs. 1000/- notes

of Rs. 50/- and Rs. 100/- denomination were also found in

the locker. Trial Court has wrongly rejected the claim in toto.

Even in respect of banned currency notes, the appellants can

approach the concerned authorities and may do the needful.

It is very well true that as the claim is pending for

adjudication before the trial Court, it was not possible for the

appellants to approach the competent authority under the

Specified Bank Notes (Cessation of Liabilities) Act, 2017. This

Court hope that when approached, the competent authority

will consider the claim of the appellants in respect of banned

currency notes. {Para 20}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR

FIRST APPEAL NO. 1602 OF 2019

Sushilkumar  Motilal Sharma Vs Umeshkumar s/o Motilal Sharma,

CORAM : S.M. MODAK, J .

PRONOUNCED ON : 11.06.2021

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 December 2019

Whether a party can obtain letter of administration even after obtaining probate?

Rejecting Mr. Dalpatrai's contention, I summarise my conclusions thus-

(a) Under the Limitation Act no period is advisedly prescribed within which an application for probate, letters of administration or succession certificate must be made;

(b) The assumption that Under Article 137 the right to apply necessarily accrues on the date of the death of the deceased, is unwarranted;

(c) Such an application is for the court's permission to perform a legal duty created by a will or for recognition as a testamentary trustee and is a continuous right which can be exercised any time after the death of the deceased, as long as the right to do so survives and the object of the trust exists or any part of the trust, if created, remains to be executed;

(d) The right to apply would accrue when it becomes necessary to apply which may not necessarily be within 3 years from the date of the deceased's death;

(e) Delay beyond 3 years after the deceased's death would arouse suspicion and greater the delay, greater would be the suspicion;

(f) Such delay must be explained, but cannot be equated with the absolute bar of limitation; and

(g) Once execution and attestation are proved, suspicion of delay no longer operates.

This Court did not agree with/approve conclusion (b). However, approved conclusion (c), reproduced hereinabove.

17. Therefore, considering the law laid down by this Court in the case of Kunvarjeet Singh Khandpur (supra), it can be said that in a proceeding, or in other words, in an application filed for grant of probate or letters of administration, no right is asserted or claimed by the applicant. The applicant only seeks recognition of the court to perform a duty. Probate or letters of administration issued by a competent court is conclusive proof of the legal character throughout the world. That the proceedings filed for grant of probate or letters of administration is not an action in law but it is an action in rem. As held by this Court in the case of Kunvarjeet Singh Khandpur (supra), an application for grant of probate or letters of administration is for the court's permission to perform a legal duty created by a will or for recognition as a testamentary trustee and is a continuous right which can be exercised any time after the death of the deceased, as long as the right to do so survives and the object of the trust exists or any part of the trust, if created, remains to be executed.

Therefore, even if the will is probated by any court mentioned in Section 228 of the Act, right to get the letters of administration is a continuous right which can be exercised any time, as long as the right to do so survives and the object of the trust exists or any part of the trust, if created, remains to be executed.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 10482 of 2013

Decided On: 29.04.2019

 Sameer Kapoor  Vs. The State 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
L. Nageswara Rao and M.R. Shah, JJ.


Citation: AIR 2019 SC 3318
Print Page

Wednesday, 20 November 2019

What is difference between probate and letter of administration?

A Grant of Probate is only issued to named Executors of the Will while Letters of Administration are issued to the persons entitled under the rules of intestacy if the deceased died without a Will.
Print Page

Wednesday, 1 May 2019

When court should refuse to issue letter of administration and relegate parties to remedy of partition suit?

 It is settled principle of law that the Court will not allow its time and resources to be taken by a proceeding which is to ultimately abort. (See Liverpool & London S.P. & I Asson. Ltd. Vs. M.V. Sea Success I MANU/SC/0951/2003 : (2004) 9 SCC 512 and ITC Ltd. Vs. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal MANU/SC/0968/1998 : (1998) 2 SCC 76). I do not see any reason as to why the petitioner is not interested in filing a suit for partition instead of flogging this proceeding, which will not serve any purpose for either of the parties. In a partition suit, directions against Banks with whom the deceased may have accounts, regarding release of the amount, can always be issued. The scope of an Administration suit clearly is to collect the assets of the deceased to pay off the debts and other charges and to find out what is the residue of the estate available for distribution amongst the heirs of the deceased. The petitioner in the present case has not explained as to what estate of the deceased has to be collected and from whom and what administration thereof is required. Rather the lis to be adjudicated between the parties is of partition of the estate. A suit for partition is distinct from an administration suit. Though administration of the estate may ultimately after accounts are taken also entail partition but where it is found that there is no need for administration and what is in effect sought is partition only, the Court would be entitled in exercise of discretion under Section 298 supra to refuse the grant of Letters of Administration and to relegate the parties to the remedy of partition.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Test. Cas. 54/2010, I.As. No. 9942/2010 and 6191, 6192,15409 and 19685/2011

Decided On: 22.05.2013

 Shubhra Singhal Vs.  State and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.


Print Page

Friday, 22 July 2016

Whether letter of administration can be revoked on ground of absence of personal citation to daughters of deceased?

 There happens to be no controversy with regard to
grounds so enumerated under Section 263 of the Indian Succession
Act permitting revocation and one of the grounds happens to be
absence of citation. The judgment and order impugned deals with the
aforesaid theme only. In order to scrutinize the finding recorded by
the learned lower Court, the original petition of Civil Misc. (Probate)
Case No.33 of 2010 has been gone through wherefrom it is evident
that in Para-6 of the petition only presence of three daughters have 
been shown without disclosing their names as well as full address (at
present or permanent). In absence thereof, really personal service
would have been effected as contended on behalf of learned counsel
for the appellant is a matter of concern which, ultimately frustrate the
submission made on behalf of learned counsel for the appellant.
Record did not speak with regard to identification of three daughters
of testator Late Basudeo Tiwary by name and further, any requisite for
issuance of notice against them to be available on the record.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Miscellaneous Appeal No.78 of 2012

RAMA SHANKAR TIWARI V SNEH LATA PANDEY 

CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)435 PAT
Date: 05-04-2016
Print Page

Sunday, 12 June 2016

Whether Indian court can issue letter of administration on basis of copy of will issued by foreign court?

The further argument that this order also flouts a claim founded on a breach of any law in force in India has no meaning, for, there is no law which is breached here. There is no law even in India that a copy of the Will cannot be accepted by court for issuance of a letter of administration. I have extracted the Section 237 of the Indian Succession Act to show that it is possible for a court to issue a grant which will be limited as to the time when the production of the original is made. Till such time as the original is produced, the copy itself can be acted upon. The Indian Evidence Act does not abhor a secondary evidence at all times. It sets out 7 circumstances (a) to (g) under Section 65 of Evidence Act. Loss of original or the Will being mislaid are circumstances when the secondary evidence is permissible. I have already referred to the decision of the Supreme Court in Ashok Layland Limited (supra) that any order of foreign court of what the grant declares must be taken to be conclusive of what it states. If foreign judgment reads that the party has been served with notice and after the grant, it also says that it was being issued till the original was produced, then it will be begging the question to ask that the original has not been produced and that conflicts with some rule of procedure in India. The circumstances set out for issuing a grant on the basis of a copy itself are sufficient vindication of the fact that the court has found a justification for reception of secondary evidence for issuance of a grant.
The issue of probate or letters of administration is optional for the rest of India by the restrictive operation of Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act referred to above. The effect is twofold: For persons who are mandated to secure the grant under Section 213, a resort to grant under Section 228 of the Act for a foreign grant is mandatory. In Alagammal and others Versus Rakkammal-AIR 1992 Mad 354, the Madras High Court came to such a conclusion by a combined reading of the above two provisions for a person whose properties were situation within the original jurisdiction of Madras High Court. No probate or Letters is necessary in the case of Wills made by Hindus of Punjab and of properties situated in Punjab (Sohan Singh Versus Bhag Singh MANU/LA/0550/1934 : AIR 1934 Lah 599; Ram Chand Versus Sardar Singh MANU/PH/0131/1962 : AIR 1962 Punj 382) and consequently, the grant of probate issued by a foreign court to operate in India will be tested only through Section 13 of CPC and Section 41 of the Evidence Act, the exercise which we have undertaken. Before concluding this issue, I must record a view expressed by the High Court of Lahore, the principle of stare decisis of which court is applicable to the Punjab & Haryana High court as its successor court, in Ramlal Versus Chanan Dass-1938 (40) PLR 1064. The Court has held that the real object of Section 228 is to dispense with the production of the original owing to its having been deposited in some other court. The section is merely an enabling section and if the court considers that there is a question to be decided relating to the validity of the Will, such as the power of the testator to make a Will, etc, the court is bound to try that question before enabling the executor to act under the Will. To our purpose in this case, there is no issue that the father had no power of disposition under the will. Indeed, the issue of title is irrelevant to grants and I will not use the cautious rider that the earlier decision of the Lahore Court alludes to.
IX. Dispensation
14. It will be a travesty to put the party through a necessity of having to prove the Will again under Section 68 of the Evidence Act. If the defendants are aggrieved by the grant, they may resort to such action as it is possible to apply to the foreign court for revoking the grant in the manner similar to the procedure prescribed under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
Civil Revision No. 7513 of 2014
Decided On: 20.01.2016
Appellants: Avtar Singh Bains
Vs.
Respondent: Gurdev Kaur and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:K. Kannan, J.

Print Page

Thursday, 13 August 2015

Whether there is limitation for claiming probate or letter of administration?

 We have now, as per our preceding discussion, settled the question and we hold that Art. 137 of the Limitation Act would not apply to proceedings filed for grant of probate or letters of administration with or without the Will annexed. Before concluding, we must point out that though the proceedings filed for grant of probate or letters of administration may not come within the mischief of Art. 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, yet the delay aspect is relevant to test the genuineness of the Will propounded. Delay in taking steps gives rise to suspicion and the longer the delay the stronger the suspicion. This is an aspect for consideration of the Court while dealing with the request.
Equivalent Citation: AIR1991Mad214, 1990-1-LW337
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS
Applns. Nos. 4946, 4986, 5131, 5175, 5180, 5181, 5208 etc. of 1989 
Decided On: 03.05.1990
Appellants: In the matter of S. Krishnaswami and etc. etc.

And
Appellants: E. Devarajan and others
Vs.
Respondent: E. Ramiah
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S. Nainar Sundaram and K. Swamidurai, JJ.

Print Page