Showing posts with label noise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label noise. Show all posts

Wednesday, 1 February 2017

Whether court should grant injunction in case of nuisance of noise and vibrations?

 The nuisance of noise and vibrations detracts
from enjoyment of right of property. Nuisance is such a
tort that the injury caused by it cannot be specifically
repaired and the extent of injury cannot be ascertained or
estimated with accuracy. Such nuisance may be of many
degrees and in many cases like the present the nuisance
may not endanger the life or health and it may only cause
annoyance, discomfort. It is settled law that in view of the
rights of the owner of the property whenever there is
discomfort such nuisance can become actionable.
However, the plaintiff is required to show that discomfort

is of such degree that it would affect not only the plaintiff
but any person irrespective of age, health or position in
life. Thus, if the plaintiff is able to prove that his premises
cannot be comfortably occupied due to nuisance created
by the defendant, the plaintiff can get relief of injunction.
The law discussed in the cases cited supra
shows that the defence that the defendant is doing his
business in proper manner, in accordance with the
conditions of licence, cannot prevent the Court from
granting relief of injunction if the plaintiff is able to prove
that the act of the defendant amounts to actionable
wrong, nuisance. Circumstance that the defendant is not
complying with the conditions laid down in the licence
can be used as additional circumstance against the
defendant. When there is non-compliance of the
conditions of licence and there is also actionable nuisance
it is up to the Court to ascertain whether the nuisance

can be stopped by giving some directions to the defendant
like to take corrective measures, to comply with the
conditions of licence.
15) Whether a private nuisance of aforesaid nature
is actionable or not can be judged by ordinary standards
of persons residing in the neighbourhood. It is up to the
Court to decide as to what type of nuisance can be
tolerated in a particular case. If the noise or vibration of
the machinery affects physical comfort of the plaintiff and
his family members, the Court can grant relief provided
that ordinary standards of person’s life in such locality
are satisfied.
16) In view of the aforesaid position of law the
points for considering the matter like the present one can
be as follows :-
(i) whether use of machinery for saw mill of the horse power
(10 HP) used by the defendant is creating nuisance of noise
and vibrations ?
(ii) whether the nuisance is actionable ?
(iii) whether use is in contravention of conditions of licence
and whether by taking some corrective measures nuisance
can be stopped and the defendant can be allowed to run the
business ?

17) When there is contravention of conditions of
licence it is also upto the authority to take steps.
Surprisingly with regard to the aforesaid admission of the
suggestion that there is no pacca construction, no action
is taken by the authority. In such case also Court can step
in and take action.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
Second Appeal No. 223 of 2014

Ismail Musabhai Memon

V
Abdul Aziz Anvar Inamdar,

 CORAM: T.V. NALAWADE, J.

 Dated : 30th September 2015.
Citation: 2016(6)ALLMR 104
Print Page