A short question involved in this petition i.e. whether the suit property” can be treated as an agricultural land or non agricultural land for computation of court fees. {Para 10}
11. Admittedly, in the case at hand, no record is produced to show that the suit property was converted to non agricultural use. However, pleadings of the plaintiffs themselves show that predecessor in title of the plaintiffs and Manjulabai had put the property ad-measuring 2 acres 2 gunthas to non agricultural use. It is pleaded in the plaint that original owner Harnam Singh had constructed a bungalow in the suit property. He had permitted Manjulabai to start brick kiln in the suit property. These pleadings show that land to the extent of 2 acres 2 gunthas was converted to non agricultural use. This view of mine is fortified by the observations made by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State of U.E. v. Nandkumar Aggarwal cited (supra), which are as under:
“6. In the master plan the area in question is no doubt shown as agriculture. If we refer to the Schedule mentioned in the definition of urban agglomeration it could be seen that area in question falls within urban agglomeration as it is situated within the peripheral area of the Municipal Corporation of Lucknow (Lucknow Nagar Mahapatika). The land in question will not be urban land if though situated within the limits of an urban agglomeration, it is mainly used for the purpose of agriculture. Operating of a Bhatta cannot certainly be an agriculture purpose. High Court was not, therefore, correct in holding that the land was being mainly used for the purpose of agriculture merely on the strength of the purpose in master plan which is specified as agriculture (Krishi Bhumi) and that the land is entered in the revenue records. High Court has wrongly applied Explanation B to clause (o) of Section 2 of the Act Simply because land is entered in the revenue record would not mean that it is being used mainly for the purpose of agriculture. Here the land is mainly for the purpose of brick kiln business of the 1st respondent. It is not material if a small portion of the land was being used for the purpose of agriculture as well.”
12. From this authoritative pronouncement of the Hon'ble Apex Court, it is evident that when land is being used mainly for brick kiln it cannot be said that it is agricultural land. It has been put to non agricultural use. In the case at hand, not only brick kiln was constructed but also a bungalow was constructed in the land owned by Harnam Singh the predecessor in title of the plaintiffs and their mother Manjulabai. Therefore, I find much substance in the arguments advanced by learned counsel Shri Kasliwal that the suit property was put to non agricultural use. When the land is put to non agricultural use, court fees will have to be computed treating it as non agricultural land.
In the High Court of Bombay Aurangabad Bench
(Before M.G. Sewlikar, J.)
Sardar Gurpreetsingh Gurnamsingh Pander Vs Sangeeta Bhagchand Bhavle and Others
Writ Petition No. 8225 of 2020
Decided on January 3, 2022,
Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine Bom 36
Print Page