Showing posts with label online defamation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label online defamation. Show all posts

Tuesday, 14 October 2025

"From Fiction to Foreseeability: Malaysian High Court Expands Publisher Liability in Online Defamation through Chu Kim Foong & Ors v Lai Zhen Yean"


 Landmark Shifts in Malaysian Online Defamation Law: Analysis of Chu Kim Foong & Ors v Lai Zhen Yean

Introduction: The Growing Complexity of Online Defamation

In the dynamic landscape of digital communication, Malaysian courts are developing new principles to address the challenge of online defamation. The High Court's recent decision in Chu Kim Foong & Ors v Lai Zhen Yean marks a watershed moment in this area, offering vital guidance for legal practitioners, judges, and advocates grappling with the nuances of online republication, intermediary liability, and remedies.

The Chu Kim Foong case stands out for two unprecedented holdings involving the republication of defamatory content via automated mechanisms and the scope of removal orders—issues likely to influence both Malaysian and comparative common law jurisdictions.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Saturday, 4 July 2020

What is single publication rule for filing suit against defamatory material on the internet/facebook page?

In Khawar Butt (supra) this Court dealing with the period of limitation for filing a suit against defamatory material on the internet/facebook page held that the single publication rule was more pragmatic and appropriate. It was held:

"14. I first proceed on to determine the legal issue: Whether, the leaving of the allegedly defamatory material on the internet/facebook page gives rise to a fresh cause of action every moment the said offending material is so left on the webpage-which can be viewed by others at any time, or whether the cause of action arises only when the offending material is first posted on the webpage/internet.

38. I am of the view that the Single Publication Rule is more appropriate and pragmatic to apply, rather the Multiple Publication Rule. I find the reasoning adopted by the American Courts in this regard to be more appealing than the one adopted by the English Courts, prior to the amendment of the law by the introduction of the Defamation Act, 2013. It is the policy of the law of limitation to bar the remedy beyond the prescribed period. That legislative policy would stand defeated if the mere continued residing of the defamatory material or article on the website were to give a continuous cause of action to the plaintiff to sue for defamation/libel. Of course, if there is re-publication resorted to by the defendant-with a view to reach the different or larger section of the public in respect of the defamatory article or material, it would give rise to a fresh cause of action.

39. The alleged libelous posting on Facebook, as averred in the plaint, was posted on around 26.10.2008, 27.10.2008 and even the booklet containing the allegedly defamatory material concerning the plaintiff is said to have been circulated around 25.12.2008. In view of the same, the limitation period for the suit expired on 25.12.2009.



40. Since the suit to claim damages for libel has not been filed within the period of limitation of one year from the date when the cause of action arose, i.e. when the libel was published, the said claim is barred by limitation."
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 21/2017

Decided On: 27.05.2020

 Ajai Agarwal Vs.  IBNI8 Media & Software Limited and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 21 May 2017

Whether person booked for defamatory facebook post can be granted anticipatory bail?

  It is the case of the prosecution that the applicant has posted
one article on the social media, “Facebook” which is defamatory in nature
and has hurt the feelings of a particular class of people from the society.
The police are yet to recover the said mobile phone of the applicant from
which the said post was published.
3. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that, the
applicant being a lady her custodial interrogation may be avoided. He
submitted that the applicant is ready and willing to co-operate with the
investigating agency.
In view thereof, for the time being the applicant can be

directed to attend the Investigating Officer and to join the process of
investigation.
Hence, the following order:
(i) In the event of arrest of the applicant in C. R. No. 134 of 2017
dated 18.04.2017 registered with Oshiwara Police Station,
Mumbai, the applicant shall be released on bail on her
furnishing P.R. Bond of Rs. 25,000/- with one or two solvent
local sureties in the like amount.                                
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO. 837 OF 2017
Nanda Bholanath Singh
Vs.
The State of Maharashtra 
CORAM : A.S. GADKARI, J.
DATE : 5 th MAY, 2017.

Print Page

Sunday, 9 October 2016

Whether court can direct Social Networking Sites To Take Down ‘Morphed’ Photos, Videos?

Thus, while issuing
notice on the applications, ex parte ad interim injunction is granted
restraining defendant nos.1 to 4, their agents, assignees, nominees and
servants from publishing, broadcasting, distributing or disseminating
in any form or manner whatsoever or continuing from doing so in any
manner any defamatory material in the nature of photographs as
mentioned above, relating to or arising from, in connection with any
alleged acts or behaviour relatable to the plaintiff. For removal of
doubts, it is clarified that it is inherent in the direction against
continuation of the publication of the impugned material that
defendant is also obliged to take all steps to remove the impugned
content from the website.
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
 CS(OS) 510/2016
SASIKALA PUSHPA 
v
FACEBOOK INDIA AND ORS 
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.K.GAUBA
Dated:OCTOBER 04, 2016

Print Page

Monday, 16 November 2015

Bombay high court bars ex-Tata general manager from boss bashing on Facebook

The Tata group has gained the primary spherical of a authorized skirmish with a former high-rating worker who took to social media to allegedly defame his employer after his providers have been terminated. The Bombay high court, which dominated within the firm’s favour, has imposed a reasonably complete gag order on the disgruntled employee, asking him to take away all materials deemed libelous and forbidding him from making any disparaging remarks a few broad part of Tata staff.The provocateur, Nityanand Sinha, a former general manager at HL Homes, a joint venture company of one of the Tata Housing firms, has been directed by Justice Gautam Patel to refrain from issuing derogatory statements about the firm in the future.

Print Page

Saturday, 9 November 2013

Accrual of cause of action when defamatory material was posted on Internet/Facebook


Delhi High Court: Deciding a defamation case where the defamatory material was posted on Internet/Facebook, the Court, while relying on various Foreign Court judgments, held that the “Single Publication Rule” will apply where the original publication is in print and the re-publication is on the internet. The Court observed that the rule states that the publication of a book, periodical or newspaper containing defamatory material gives rise to only one cause of action for defamation, which implies, that the limitation period starts to run at the time the first publication is made, even if copies continue to be sold several years later. Hence the cause of action against the person for defamation in respect of the subsequent publication is to be treated as having accrued on the date of the first publication.
Print Page