Showing posts with label plaint map. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plaint map. Show all posts

Tuesday, 18 June 2019

Whether appointment of court commissioner to measure suit property is necessary to ascertain encroachment??

Although these two documents are on record, the material thing that needs consideration is whether the plaint map prepared by PW 3 Balwant 'retired Talathi' could be relied upon to hold that there is an encroachment on plaintiffs land and if there is one ,what is the extent. This is the only map (Exh. 76) on record, as far as measurement of the site is concerned. It appears to me that it would not be proper to rely on this measurement map, for the site does not seem to have been measured scientifically and after notice to the defendant. PW 3 Balawant in examination-in-chief says that he measured the site on the basis of 1920 map and it was shown to him by Surendrasing the plaintiff. It is not clear if it was a Survey map drawn by Government agency or department or a private map. Whatever that was, that too should have been placed on record. He admits in cross-examination that he had not seen the title-deed of either party. He also states that the map is drawn as told by Surendrasing. He says that he does not know the number of the map and he did not bring those notes of measurement before the court. It is obvious that the map was drawn as suggested by Surendrasing the plaintiff. It is not a measurement done independently and on basis of authenticated documents. He does not say if he had seen any document before he measured. One, therefore, wonders as to how then he could determine the boundaries of the plots of the plaintiff as well that of the defendant. He does not say if he found any fixed mark of survey department at any spot and that he measured it taking that point as base point. It is, therefore, clear that the measurement map (Exh. 26) cannot be taken as a correct map. The courts below, therefore, should have appointed a Commissioner to measure not only the plot of the plaintiff but that of defendant also with reference to defendant's sale deed (Exh. 65) and also with reference to survey map (Exh. 61). It also appears that plaintiff had filed on record a certified copy of the sanction plan of house of plaintiff and it is at Article 'B'. This sanction plan of plaintiff's house is of the year 1923. Obviously, it is a very old document and material document to determine the exact extent of the land of plaintiff's site. Since sale deed of the plaintiff's site is not available, this document would be of immense help at the time of the measurement. In fact, therefore, the above documents would certainly have helped the measurer to measure the land and for the court to determine the question of encroachment correctly. To my mind, therefore, the courts below erred in not appointing a Commissioner to measure the site of the plaintiff and defendant both with reference to these documents. In order that the suit is finally and effectually decided, it is, therefore, desirable to have measurement of the both the sites which measurement can be undertaken by Surveyor from the City Survey Department.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 67 of 1996

Decided On: 29.01.2008

 Shamlata  Vs. Vishweshwar Tukaram Giripunje and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges: 
C.L. Pangarkar, J.

Citation: AIR 2008 Bom 155

Print Page

Saturday, 9 February 2019

Procedure to be followed by court for deciding suit relating to encroachment on land

 Following  paragraph in Sulemankhan's Judgment is important.

“8. In cases to determine encroachment, it is always desirable to
have disputed suit property measured by competent surveyor to
find out encroachment and its extent. Oral evidence cannot prove
such contentious issue conclusively. In a suit where parties are
disputing boundaries of property and one of the parties alleges
encroachment made by another party to the suit inside suit
property. In such case the plaint map as evidence in respect
thereof is vital document for to decide real controversy between the
parties finally. This Court has time and again expressed opinion
about the necessity of duly drawn measurement plan/map in any
suit in which there is a boundary dispute. The Trial Court as well
as 1st Appellate Court which are Court of Facts, are duty bound to
ascertain that a map is drawn to the appropriate scale by
competent Government official from the office of TILR or DILR, as
the case may be, so that measurement of suit property is carried
out in presence of the parties after due notice to them or even if
they are absent, so as to ensure that the suit property is properly
measured, boundaries are fixed and boundary dispute is finally
settled by producing map in the Court by the plan maker who can
prove its genuineness by deposing in support of such plan/map, if
it is so necessary in the absence of admission for exhibiting the
map. The Trial Court can certainly raise presumption of accuracy
and genuineness of such map in view of Section 83 of the Evidence
Act if map is drawn by competent authority. (See : Ram Kishor

Sen & ors v. Union of India & ors reported in
MANU/SC/0052/1965 : AIR 1966 SC 644) Where such vital
document is duly produced, proved and established, necessary
detailed decree can be follow if there is any encroachment on the
suit property. As held by this Court in Vijay Shende's case (supra),
in such cases, fact of encroachment may be proved partly by oral
evidence although the extent of encroachment cannot be proved in
absence of public records without following due procedure
emerging from Section 36 and Section 60 of the Evidence Act. In
view of this recent judicial precedent referred to above, in the
larger interest of justice, when it appears that the trial Court as
well as 1st Appellate Court failed to follow proper procedure in this
regard to ascertain the boundaries of the suit property.”


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SECOND APPEAL NO.562 OF 2005

Raghunath Kashinath Chavan, Vs  Sakharam Maroti Chavan,

CORAM : SMT. VIBHA KANKANWADI, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 29th JANUARY 2019

Print Page