The allegation is that certain messages were received on the official cell phone of Smt. Ashwini Bhide, due to which she felt offended and obstructed in discharge of her official functions and when she blocked the number from which she had received those messages, Smt. Ashwini Bhide received some messages from a different mobile number. This is how, in the opinion of the complainant i.e. respondent no.2, Smt. Ashwini Bhide was obstructed in discharge of her public functions. But, Smt. Ashwini Bhide does not herself come forward and make any such allegations. The complainant, i.e. respondent no.2, has not stated in his FIR that he had received information regarding commission of the said offence directly from Smt. Ashwini Bhide.
There is nothing on record which shows that Smt. Ashwini Bhide had written to the respondent no.2 and informed him about the alleged obstruction being caused to her by the person sending messages to her from certain mobile number, which is alleged to be belonging to the petitioner. No efforts to find out the source of information of respondent no.2 regarding commission of this cognizable offence has been made by the Investigating Officer and, therefore, it is still not known as to whether or not there was any such information available as was sufficient to disclose commission of a cognizable offence so necessary for registration of the FIR in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
7. It would be clear from the above referred messages that the sender of those messages, who is stated to be the present petitioner, had acted in a bona fide manner, on the basis of what he believed to be an act which was necessary for maintaining the health of the city of Mumbai. His intention appears to be to protect the forest, he considers to be acting like a pair of lungs for the city of Mumbai. These messages do not contain any offensive material or any obscenities. Rather, they appear to have been sent in assertion of a democratic right of citizen of this country to put forth his view point, to object, to protest, to persuade, to urge, and so on. It then follows that if anybody is booked for criminal offences such as those as have been registered against the present petitioner, it may amount to an invasion upon the rights of the citizens of this country. Such an effort by any complainant, howsoever high he or she may be in position, cannot be countenanced and must be stopped. Upon such a complaint, as the one involved here, police must never book any ordinary citizen of the country under criminal law and if it does, it would be like suppressing his voice against what he considers to be a wrongful thing. We, therefore, find that no offence under Section 186 IPC is made out against the petitioner.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.4181 OF 2018
Avijit Michael, Vs State of Maharashtra,
CORAM : SUNIL B. SHUKRE & M.M. SATHAYE, JJ
Author: Sunil B. Shukre, J
DATE : 5TH APRIL, 2023.
Print Page