Supreme Court in the case of Gurbax Singh Chanda Singh (supra) has held that if the provisions of the statute have not been complied with or the statutory tribunal has not acted in conformity with the fundamental principles of judicial procedure, the civil Courts have jurisdiction to examine those cases. In my view, since the alleged certificate issued under Section 32-M of the BTAL Act is without following the mandatory procedure under the provisions of the BTAL Act, the same being nullity and thus cannot bind the plaintiffs and thus no cognizance thereof can be taken by this Court.
65. In so far as the judgments in the cases of Rajaram Totaram Patel (supra), Tulsiram Adku Marape & Anr. (supra), Saraswatibai Trimbak Gaikwad (supra) and Smt.Savitra Bapu Shinde & Ors. (supra) relied upon by the learned counsel for the defendant nos.1 to 7 are concerned, none of those judgments would assist the case of the defendant nos.1 to 7. The defendant nos.1 to 7 not having raised plea of alleged tenancy before the learned trial Judge, inspite of having rendered opportunities to file written statement twice, the defendant nos.1 to 7 cannot be allowed to raise a plea that the learned trial Judge ought to have referred the issue of tenancy to the competent authority under the provisions of the BTAL Act. The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the defendant nos.1 to 7 are thus clearly distinguishable.
Bombay High Court
1. Shri Chindhu Fakira Satale And ... vs 1. Sau. Vithabai Kashinath Jadhav ... on 5 October, 2016
Bench: R.D. Dhanuka
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR 121 Bom