Showing posts with label revocation of probate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label revocation of probate. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 December 2024

Bombay HC: Sub-tenant of deceased is not his legal heir, hence he is not entitled to seek revocation of his probate

There is no dispute about the proposition laid down by this decision but it cannot be ignored that the person applying for revocation must have some right or locus-standi to do so. It may be pointed out that the deceased as well as the respondent are Parsis. Mr. Madon drew my attention to the decision in Perviz Sarosh v. Mrs. Viloo Plumber MANU/MH/0309/2000 : AIR2000Bom189 , wherein a learned single Judge of this Court (Nijjar, J.) held that in order to have locus-standi for challenging the Probate in respect of the Will of a Parsi on the ground sets out in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, right in the inheritance under Section 51 of the Indian Succession Act has to be made out and the same is prerequisite for raising challenge under Section 263. The learned Judge observed that challenge to the probate under Section 263 is not in the nature of a public interest litigation and it can only be at the instance of a person who has a slight interest in the estate for themselves. Admittedly, the petitioner is a non-Parsi and he is not a legal heir of the deceased. Therefore, he has no locus standi or interest to challenge the probate under Section 263 granted in favour of the respondent. All that the petitioner claims is a right of sub-tenancy in respect of the above mentioned house flat which belonged to the deceased. The question whether the petitioner is or is not a tenant or sub-tenant of the said suit house is pending before the Small Causes Court. Even assuming for the sake of argument that the petitioner is a tenant in the said house, still he cannot be said to have a right to apply under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act. In this respect, I am supported by a decision of a learned single Judge of the Delhi High Court in Dr. Jagdish Chandra v. State and Anr., MANU/DE/0276/1988 : 36(1988)DLT272 , wherein it was held that a tenant has no right to apply under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act for cancellation or revocation of the probate granted for the Will executed by the landlord/owner to his adopted son. The ratio of this decision appears to be that a tenant does not have any interest in the estate of the deceased landlord. Even if the landlord dies intestate, the tenant is not likely to get anything unless he is one of the legal heirs of the deceased landlords. In the instant case, the petitioner is admittedly not related to the deceased nor he is her legal heir. He does not have interest in the estate of the deceased in the sense that testacy or intestacy of the deceased landlord does not affect his right as the tenant, if at all he is so. His interest is not such as would be affected by the grant of probate or letters of administration. He continues to be the tenant, if at all he is, irrespective of the fact whether the Will set up by the respondent is true or false and will get protection of the Bombay Rent Act. But he does not have any right or locus standi to challenge the Will of the deceased. {Para 7}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Misc. Petition No. 49 of 2002

Decided On: 24.01.2003

Rajiv Ramprasad Gupta Vs. Rustom Sam Boyce

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.A. Patil, J.

Citation: 2003(2) Bom C. R 460,MANU/MH/0147/2003.

Print Page

Wednesday, 2 October 2019

Whether application for revocation of probate should be tried as civil suit?

 We are of the considered view that an application to revoke probate or letter of administration would be treated as miscellaneous application and may be disposed of on the fact situation in an appropriate case either summarily or after recording evidence. The application to revoke the probate or letter of administration thus may be disposed of by the District Judge either summarily or in a given situation where it requires proof of the facts by adduction of evidence by the parties by recording such evidence as is adduced by the parties. The burden will be on the applicant to prove the facts to revoke the probate or letter of administration and the respondent who obtained probate or letter of administration has to disprove the contentions of the applicant. In that situation, based upon the given facts situation, it will be for the Court to dispose it of either summarily or after giving opportunity to both the parties to adduce evidence and consideration thereof. Under these circumstances, it is not necessary that the application for revocation of the probate or letter of administration would be treated as a suit as a contemplated under Section 295 of the Act. If the contention of Shri Puri merits acceptance, then any proceedings under the application to revoke the probate or letter of administration should be treated as a suit: the applicant cannot prove the will and at the same time cannot contend that the will was not validly executed. Therefore, it would be self contradictory to adopt such a procedure. Accordingly, we are of the view that the procedure required under Section 295 need not be adopted for disposal of the application filed under Section 263 for revocation of the probate or the letter of administration. It would be treated as miscellaneous application and disposed of as indicated earlier according to the given fact situation. In fact, the Bombay High Court came to consider the question, not directly on this issue but in an analogous situation in Narbheram Jivaram Purohit vs. Jevallabh Harijivan, [MANU/MH/0198/1932 : Vol. XXXV (1933) BLR 998]. Therein, the learned single Judge had held that the proper procedure for revocation of probate granted by the High Court is by way of a petition filed in the testamentary and intestate jurisdiction of the Court, and not by way of suit in its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction. In other words, the Court indicated that it need not be treated as a suit on the original side of the Court but it could be disposed of as an application independent of the suit. Thus we hold that the High Court was clearly in error in reaching the conclusion that it should be treated as a suit and disposed of under Section 295."


IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 4807 of 2018

Decided On: 07.03.2019

 Harjit Singh Vs.   Paramjitsingh

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.V. Ghuge, J.

Citation: 2019(5) MHLJ 76
Print Page