Showing posts with label salaried person. Show all posts
Showing posts with label salaried person. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 August 2026

Supreme Court Lays Down Law On Using ITRs (Income tax return)To Assess Victim's Income in Motor Accident Claims

 In the considered view of this Court, there can be no hard and fast formula for computing the annual income of a deceased person/claimant. ITRs being a statutory document are an important reference point when it comes to assessing one’s income, for the purposes of compensation under the Motor Vehicle Act. {Para 17}

18. We find force in the submission put forth by Mr. J.R Midha, learned senior counsel. There must be a bifurcation made between salaried individuals and self-employed individuals when it comes to assessment of annual income. In our view, for salaried individuals, only the ITR of the previous year will be sufficient for showcasing the annual income from salary. The reason for considering only the preceding year is that the financial impact of promotions is significant and may be reflected in the ITR for only that year. A situation may also arise whereby the deceased/claimant might not have completed a year in the promoted position before the accident or might not have filed ITR for such period. In such cases the Court concerned shall take reference to the promotion letter and other corroboratory financial statements.


19. When it comes to self-employed / individuals carrying out their own business, in our view, the average of the income specified in the ITRs of up to the previous three years is to be taken as a reference point for assessment of annual income from their business. There may also be a scenario where only one or two ITRs have been filed. Given such scenarios and the fluctuation of income in these professions, surrounding circumstances are also to be taken into consideration. These would include:

a) The nature of the business (including geographic location,

category etc.);

b) Growth pattern of the business and impact of death on the

business;

c) Potential growth of business (for instance certain

businesses are capital intensive at the outset and are

profitable at scale/in the future);

d) Negative income (certain businesses may require losses in

the initial years, which may not reflect the true financial

standing); and

e) Any other relevant factor relating to the business.

20. The date when the ITRs are filed would also become a relevant consideration, as there may be scenarios where inflated income is showcased after death/injury. In these circumstances, the surrounding factors of the business would become more relevant. However, if sufficiently supported by financial statements, such ITRs may also be taken into consideration.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP(C) No. 27220 of 2024)

RASHMIREKHA TRIPATHY AND ANR. Vs THE BRANCH MANAGER (LEGAL CLAIMS), SRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.

Author: SANJAY KAROL, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 661
Print Page

Sunday, 5 July 2026

Supreme Court Lays Down Law On Using ITRs in Motor Accident Claims To Assess Victim's Income

 In the considered view of this Court, there can be no hard and fast formula for computing the annual income of a deceased person/claimant. ITRs being a statutory document are an important reference point when it comes to assessing one's income, for the purposes of compensation under the Motor Vehicle Act. {Para 17}


18. We find force in the submission put forth by Mr. J.R. Midha, learned Senior Counsel. There must be a bifurcation made between salaried individuals and self-employed individuals when it comes to assessment of annual income. In our view, for salaried individuals, only the ITR of the previous year will be sufficient for showcasing the annual income from salary. The reason for considering only the preceding year is that the financial impact of promotions is significant and may be reflected in the ITR for only that year. A situation may also arise whereby the deceased/claimant might not have completed a year in the promoted position before the accident or might not have filed ITR for such period. In such cases the Court concerned shall take reference to the promotion letter and other corroboratory financial statements.


19. When it comes to self-employed/individuals carrying out their own business, in our view, the average of the income specified in the ITRs of up to the previous three years is to be taken as a reference point for assessment of annual income from their business. There may also be a scenario where only one or two ITRs have been filed. Given such scenarios and the fluctuation of income in these professions, surrounding circumstances are also to be taken into consideration. These would include:


a) The nature of the business (including geographic location, category etc.);


b) Growth pattern of the business and impact of death on the business;


c) Potential growth of business (for instance certain businesses are capital intensive at the outset and are profitable at scale/in the future);


d) Negative income (certain businesses may require losses in the initial years, which may not reflect the true financial standing); and


e) Any other relevant factor relating to the business.


20. The date when the ITRs are filed would also become a relevant consideration, as there may be scenarios where inflated income is showcased after death/injury. In these circumstances, the surrounding factors of the business would become more relevant. However, if sufficiently supported by financial statements, such ITRs may also be taken into consideration.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 8735 of 2026 (Arising out of SLP (C) No. 27220 of 2024)

Decided On: 01.07.2026

Rashmirekha Tripathy and Ors. Vs. The Branch Manager (Legal Claims), Sriram General Insurance Company Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sanjay Karol and N. Kotiswar Singh, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 661,MANU/SC/0663/2026
Print Page

Tuesday, 31 December 2024

Supreme Court : Motor accident claim tribunal should include HRA,PF contribution and other perquisites to salary of deceased before considering his annual income for grant of compensation

The amounts, therefore, which were required to be paid to the deceased by his employer by way of perks, should be included for computation of his monthly income as that would have been added to his monthly income by way of contribution to the family as contradistinguished to the ones which were for his benefit. We may, however, hasten to add that from the said amount of income, the statutory amount of tax payable thereupon must be deducted. {Para 19}

It has also been stated: ' "Income" signifies "what comes in" (per Selborne, C., Jones v. Ogle [(1861-73) All ER Rep 918]). "It is as large a word as can be used" to denote a person's receipts (per Jessel, M.R., Huggins, ex p., Re [51 LJ Ch 935]). Income is not confined to receipts from business only and means periodical receipts from one's work, lands, investments, etc. Secy. to the Board of Revenue, Income Tax v. Al. Ar. Rm. Arunachalam Chettiar & Bros. [  MANU/TN/0126/1920 : AIR 1921 Mad 427] Ref. Vulcan Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Corporation of Madras [AIR 1930 Mad 626 (2)].

21. If the dictionary meaning of the word 'income' is taken to its logical conclusion, it should include those benefits, either in terms of money or otherwise, which are taken into consideration for the purpose of payment of income tax or professional tax although some elements thereof may or may not be taxable or would have been otherwise taxable but for the exemption conferred thereupon under the statute.

To the same effect is the decision of this Court in Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Ram Prasad Varma and Ors. [  MANU/SC/0030/2009 : 2009:INSC:24 : (2009) 2 SCC 712: (2009) 1 SCC (Cri) 853: (2009) 1 Scale 598].

7. We, therefore, are of the opinion that "dearness allowance" and "house rent allowance" payable to the deceased should have been included for determining the income of the deceased and consequently the amount of compensation.

9. Recently in a judgment dated 11th July, 2024 in National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Nalini and Ors. [Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 4230/2019], this Court held that, allowances under the heads of transport allowance, house rent allowance, provident fund loan, provident fund and special allowance ought to be added while considering the basic salary of the victim/deceased to arrive at the dependency factor.

10. Therefore, components of house rent allowance, flexible benefit plan and company contribution to provident fund have to be included in the salary of the deceased while applying the component of rise in income by future prospects to determine the dependency factor. The Accident Claims Tribunal was justified in factoring these components into the salary of the deceased, before applying 50% rise by future prospects due to future prospects, while calculating the total compensation payable to the Appellant.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. ... of 2024 .

Decided On: 23.07.2024

Meenakshi Vs. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Hima Kohli and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.

Citation: MANU/SC/0830/2024,2024 INSC 573.

Print Page

Friday, 13 December 2024

Supreme Court: The deduction towards income tax/surcharge alone should be considered to arrive at the net income of the deceased while computing compensation in case of motor accident

This Court in Shyamwati Sharma and Ors. v. Karam Singh and Ors.   MANU/SC/0468/2010 : (2010) 12 SCC 378, while considering the issues of deduction of taxes, contributions etc., for arriving at the figure of net monthly income, held that "while ascertaining the income of the deceased, any deductions shown in the salary certificate as deductions towards GPF, life insurance premium, repayments of loans etc., should not be excluded from the income. The deduction towards income tax/surcharge alone should be considered to arrive at the net income of the deceased.

{Para 12}

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 7642 OF 2009

MANASVI JAIN  Vs DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P. Sathasivam, C.J.I., Ranjan Gogoi and N.V. Ramana, JJ.

Author: N.V. RAMANA, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0355/2014, 2014 INSC 311.
Print Page

Saturday, 14 September 2024

Supreme Court : Motor accident claim tribunal can not allow deductions from the amount of compensation on account of insurance, pensionary benefits, gratuity or grant of employment to a kin of the deceased

 The law is well settled that deductions cannot be allowed from the amount of compensation either on account of insurance, or on account of pensionary benefits or gratuity or grant of employment to a kin of the deceased. The main reason is that all these amounts are earned by the deceased on account of contractual relations entered into by him with others. It cannot be said that these amounts accrued to the dependents or the legal heirs of the deceased on account of his death in a motor vehicle accident. The claimants/dependents are entitled to 'just compensation' under the Motor Vehicles Act as a result of the death of the deceased in a motor vehicle accident. Therefore, the natural corollary is that the advantage which accrues to the estate of the deceased or to his dependents as a result of some contract or act which the deceased performed in his life time cannot be said to be the outcome or result of the death of the deceased even though these amounts may go into the hands of the dependents only after his death. {Para 12}


13. As far as any amount paid under any insurance policy is concerned whatever is added to the estate of the deceased or his dependents is not because of the death of the deceased but because of the contract entered into between the deceased and the insurance company from where he took out the policy. The deceased paid premium on such life insurance and this amount would have accrued to the estate of the deceased either on maturity of the policy or on his death, whatever be the manner of his death. These amounts are paid because the deceased has wisely invested his savings. Similar would be the position in case of other investments like bank deposits, share, debentures etc.. The tort-feasor cannot take advantage of the foresight and wise financial investments made by the deceased.


14. As far as the amounts of pension and gratuity are concerned, these are paid on account of the service rendered by the deceased to his employer. It is now an established principle of service jurisprudence that pension and gratuity are the property of the deceased. They are more in the nature of deferred wages. The deceased employee works throughout his life expecting that on his retirement he will get substantial amount as pension and gratuity. These amounts are also payable on death, whatever be the cause of death. Therefore, applying the same principles, the said amount cannot be deducted.


15. As held by the House of Lords in Perry v. Cleaver MANU/UKHL/0008/1969 : 1969 ACJ 363 the insurance amount is the fruit of premium paid in the past, pension is the fruit of services already rendered and the wrong doer should not be given benefit of the same by deducting it from the damages assessed.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 10588-89 of 2018.

Decided On: 12.10.2018

Sebastiani Lakra and Ors. Vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Madan B. Lokur, S. Abdul Nazeer and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Author: Deepak Gupta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1162/2018,(2019) 17 SCC 465.

Print Page

Supreme Court: What deductions are not permissible in calculation of total income of deceased in case of Motor accident?

 a. Computation of Income


8. In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indira Srivastava and Ors.   MANU/SC/8201/2007 : AIR 2008 SC 845, S.B. Sinha J, has observed that "The term 'income' has different connotations for different purposes. A court of law, having regard to the change in societal conditions must consider the question not only having regard to pay packet the employee carries home at the end of the month but also other perks which are beneficial to the members of the entire family. Loss caused to the family on a death of a near and dear one can hardly be compensated on monitory terms." His Lordship also stated that if some facilities were being provided whereby the entire family stood to benefit, the same must be held to be relevant for the purpose of computation of total income on the basis of which the amount of compensation payable for the death of the kith and kin of the applicants was required to be determined. This Court held that superannuation benefits, contributions towards gratuity, insurance of medical policy for self and family and education scholarship were beneficial to the members of the family. This Court clarified that by opining that 'just compensation' must be determined having regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. The basis for considering the entire pay packet is what the dependents have lost in view of death of the deceased. It is in the nature of compensation for future loss towards the family income" and that "the amounts, therefore, which were required to be paid to the deceased by his employer by way of perks, should be included for computation of his monthly income as that would have been added to his monthly income by way of contribution to the family as contradistinguished to the ones which were for his benefit. We may, however, hasten to add that from the said amount of income, the statutory amount of tax payable thereupon must be deducted."


9. In Raghuvir Singh Matolya and Ors. v. Hari Singh Malviya and Ors.   MANU/SC/0853/2009 : (2009) 15 SCC 363, this Court has observed that dearness allowance and house rent allowance should be included for computation of income of the deceased.

11. Based on the aforementioned judgments, we are of the view that deductions made by the Tribunal on account of HRA, CCA and medical allowance are done on an incorrect basis and should have been taken into consideration in calculation of the income of the deceased. Further, deduction towards EPF and GIS should also not have been made in calculating the income of the deceased.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1440 of 2011.

Decided On: 07.02.2011

Sunil Sharma and Ors. Vs. Bachitar Singh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Singhvi and A.K. Ganguly, JJ.

Author: A.K. Ganguly, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0413/2011,(2011) 11 SCC 425.

Print Page

Sunday, 25 December 2016

How to calculate compensation for accidental death of salaried person in motor accident claim petition?

 Keeping the above principles in mind, coming to the earnings
of the deceased and what amount out of it to be deducted and what
amount to be taken into consideration towards loss of contribution to
the claimants from the sudden accidental death, where the annual
income is in the taxable range, the words "actual salary" should be read
as "actual salary less tax; from  the deceased was aged 32 years as per
Ex.A.4 P.M. Report and as per Ex.A.11 driving licence, the deceased was
born on 30.07.1982 and the Ex.A.10 SSC certificate of the deceased also
proves the same to say as on date of accident 19.11.2003, he completed
31 years.  The deceased was a post-graduate in Applied Science as per
Ex.A.13 and 15 from Periyar University and passed in distinction in the
year 2004 and those are the copies of provisional and regular P.G.Degree
certificates to that effect. As the claim is under Section 166 of the Act,
as per Sarla Verma, Reshmakumari and Rajesh the multiplier that is
applicable is 16 for persons in the age group of 31 to 35 years. The
tribunal rightly has taken the multiplier 16. Coming to earnings for
consideration and personal expenses deduction out of it, the evidence of
P.W.3 who is the Manager(Legal)of Fullerton Indian Private Limited,
Hyderabad branch where the deceased was working as H.R. Assistant   
Manager, since 23.08.2013 (even by the date of accidental death on
19/20.11.2013) as per Ex.A.7 as probationer to say undergoing probation
still. Merely because he is in probation, does not mean he was not in
employment with monthly salary to be computed for assessing 
compensation as on the date and time of death.  As per Section 2(22) of
the Income Tax Act, 1961(for short, 'the IT Act') income is an inclusive
definition which includes any special allowance and benefit granted to
the assessee (employee) other than perks to meet expenses for 
performance of duties or as employment of profit or to compensate for
increase in the cost of living or value of any benefit or perquisite.

      16. As per Section 17(2) in Chapter 4 of the I.T.Act, in
computation of the income under the Head Salaries perquisite includes
value of rent free accommodation provided by the employer or value of
any rent concession in respect of the accommodation provided by the
employer. Salary includes the pay, allowances, bonus or commission 
payable monthly or otherwise or any monetary payments, by whatever 
name called, but does not include D.A. or D.P. unless it enters into the
computation of superannuation or retirement benefits, employer's
contribution to P.F., allowances exempted from payment of tax, value
of perks specified and any payment or expenditure specially excluded.

        17. When such is the case, as per Ex.A.8 the salary statement, his
gross salary was Rs.37,125/-p.m. comprising of basic of Rs.13,125/-, HRA
of Rs.4,800/-, Personal Allowance of Rs.18,400/- and Conveyance
Allowance of Rs.800/- and out of it, the deductions are IT deduction of
Rs.438/-, P.F. of Rs.1575/-, Professional Tax of Rs.200/-and Mediclaim
recovery of Rs.444/-and the net salary thereby is Rs.34,468/-Ex.A.9
Salary sheet also proved through P.W.3 for the total three months period
from 23.08.2013 to 19.11.2013 in this regard. P.W.3 denied the
suggestion of deceased never worked in the entity and Exs.A.7 to A.9 are
created or he was not paid any salary by the entity or he is deposing
false. There is no other much less worth cross-examination to discredit
the evidence of P.W.3 or to doubt the probative value of the Exs.A.7 to
A.9.  From the above, out of the gross salary of the deceased proved of
Rs.37,125/-p.m. comprising of basic of Rs.13,125/-, HRA of Rs.4,800/-,
Personal Allowance of Rs.18,400/- and Conveyance Allowance of  
Rs.800/- and out of it the deductions are IT deduction of Rs.438/-, P.F.
of Rs.1575/-, Professional Tax of Rs.200/-and Mediclaim recovery of
Rs.444/-in showing the net salary as Rs.34,468/-; the Conveyance
Allowance of Rs.800/-, IT deduction of Rs.438/-, P.F. contribution of
Rs.1575/-, Professional Tax of Rs.200/-and Mediclaim recovery of
Rs.444/-even deducted in arriving the net amount thereafter, for the
HRA not liable for deduction as it is not confined to the personal benefit
of deceased but for the whole family of the deceased who are the
claimants. Further, even it is shown in the pay band as Personal
Allowance for a sum of Rs.18,400/-, it is not for any specific personal
meeting of requirement like tour travel etc., to personally benefit the
employee but for part of the earnings of the deceased to contribute to
the family even out of it after meeting the personal expenses deduction
of 1/3rd or 1/4th, as the case may be. Coming to personal expenses
deduction, out of the 4 claimants, the father is a retired employee and
pensioner and contended as not dependent solely on the deceased. 
Even the father is not solely dependent, there could be some
contribution to him by the deceased out of his earnings for what he gets
pension or other retirement benefits is not only to him but also to his
wife and any other family members and that may or may not be 
sufficient for his survival. What is laid down in Sarla Verma in arriving
personal expenses deduction of deceased depending upon number of   
dependents, even father therefrom not taken as a dependent but for the
other three, as per paras 30 to 33 of the expression, which are
reiterated in Reshma Kumari as referred supra, if 1/3rd deducted
towards personal expenses of the deceased, the contribution of the
deceased to the family is the remaining 2/3rds which comes to
(Rs.37,125- Conveyance Allowance of Rs.800 PLUS IT deduction of Rs.438 PLUS P.F.    
contribution of Rs.1575 PLUS Professional Tax of Rs.200 PLUS Mediclaim recovery  
of Rs.444=Rs.34,468/-is the net salary as arrived by the tribunal and
even instead of Rs.438/- if at least 12% deducted towards income tax,
after 50% prospective increase on Rs.34,468 PLUS Rs.438=Rs.52,359/-, of 
which 12% towards income tax deduction taken at Rs.6,283/-, the net
amount comes to Rs.46,076/- and after 1/3rd deduction, the 2/3rds
comes to Rs.30,717/- x 12x16=Rs.58,97,718/-, besides loss of consortium 
to the first claimant-wife Rs.1,00,000/-, loss of estate Rs.10,000/-, care
and guidance to the minor child Rs.25,000/- even as awarded by the
tribunal taken, funeral expenses Rs.25,000/- as laid down in Rajesh
supra, it comes to more than what the tribunal awarded of
Rs.34,50,000/-. Thus, as held in Ranjana Prakash supra, this Court has
since no power to enhance for what is awarded is no way excessive but
low, there is nothing to reduce the quantum of compensation awarded
by the tribunal of Rs.34,50,000/-.
HYDERABAD HIGH COURT
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NOOTY RAMAMOHANA RAO AND HONOURABLE Dr. JUSTICE B.SIVASANKARA RAO                    

M.A.C.M.A.No.471 OF 2016   

Dated 13.04.2016 

Reliance General Insurance Company Limited 
V

Smt. S.Sunitha @ R.Sunitha 
Citation:2016(6) ALLMR (JOURNAL)14
Print Page