Showing posts with label scientific report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scientific report. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 August 2016

Whether Court can give opinion regarding physical disability of witness without any assistance of scientific report?

 Admittedly, plaintiff No.1, who claims to be the son of
Dubraj through his first wife, has not come to the witness box to
testify his pleadings. As revealed from the impugned judgment, he 
was present in Court and the Court on examination found him to be
hard of hearing and thus incompetent to lead evidence. DWs. 2 and
3 have also deposed that the plaintiff No.1 is little hard of hearing
though not totally deaf. No material is available on record to show
that he was sent for any scientific examination to reach at a
conclusion that he was deaf. The Court is not competent to opine
with regard to the physical disability of a witness without any
assistance of scientific report, more particularly when the witnesses
of the defendants deposed that he was little hard of hearing and not
totally deaf. It further reveals from the impugned judgment that
learned counsel for the defendants raised such an objection and
submitted that the gesture, posture and demeanor of the witness
was only intended to avoid cross-examination by the defendants.
Admittedly, there is no document available on record to show that
the plaintiff No.1 was totally deaf and is not competent to lead
evidence. It is also not the case of the plaintiffs that the plaintiff No.1
was completely deaf and was not able to adduce any evidence nor
any documentary evidence was produced to the effect. The opinion of
the trial Court looking at the demeanor of the plaintiff No.1 was
preliminary one and is not conclusive. The plaintiff No.1 is a vital
witness to testify his relationship with Dubraj as plaintiff No.2 is not
competent enough to lead evidence to that effect. Admittedly, the
plaintiff No.2 has no personal knowledge about the relationship of
plaintiff No.1, if any, with Dubraj. Thus, the learned trial Court
ought not have dealt with such an important issue so lightly in
absence of any scientific report to the effect that the plaintiff No.1
was completely deaf. Thus, this Court draws an adverse inference
against the plaintiffs under Section 114 of the Evidence Act, 1872 for
non-examination of plaintiff No.1.
HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
 F.A. NO. 174 OF 1988

Hema Majhi V Dubraj Majhi 
 Date of Judgment: 20.04.2016

P R E S E N T:
 SHRI JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)477 Orissa
Print Page