Having respectfully gone through the cited decisions, in
my opinion, the State/National Forums have trappings of
Courts and are adjudicatory bodies, though not in strict sense
Courts, which decide and settle the consumers disputes and
matter connected therewith by adhering to the provisions of
Civil Procedure Code and these consumer Courts arejudiciary set up by the government to protect the consumer
rights and would fall within the meaning of Section 3 of Indian
Evidence Act.
It is admitted fact that refund vouchers were similar to
Cheques and like Cheque books, refund vouchers printed in
the specialized format were given by the defendant bank to the
plaintiff for issuance thereof as is reflected in the answer to
question No. 21 and 25 given by the sole witness of the
plaintiff. In the particular period of time since there was no
system of payment of Cheque at par in all the branches of the
country, instrument of refund voucher payable at par all the
branches in the country was introduced by the defendant bank
and such facility was given to the plaintiff by the arrangement.
It is well settled that in order to decide whether a
decision in an earlier litigation operates as res judicata, the
Court must look at the nature of the litigation, what were the
issues raised therein and what was actually decided in it.
In the present case having gone through the pleading of
the parties and the evidence-on-record and the judgments
rendered by the said forums, in unequivocal term it is clear
that the issues involved in this suit were substantially the
issues before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission which stood decided by the judgment dated31.3.2008 which attained its finality with the merger of
judgment and order of the National Consumer Dispute
Redressal Commission.
In the context of the foregoing discussions, on critical
examination of the judgments of the said forums and
considering the nature of the litigation and the issues raised
and decided therein being similar to the facts and
circumstances of the instant case, the issues now cannot be
reopened and re-agitated as in my opinion the suit is barred by
the principle of res judicata within the meaning of Section 11 of
Code of Civil Procedure.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
ORIGINAL SIDE
Present: The Hon’ble Justice Shivakant Prasad
CS 175 of 2010
M/s. Kesoram Industries Limited V Allahabad Bank
Judgment on : 03.04.2017
Print Page
my opinion, the State/National Forums have trappings of
Courts and are adjudicatory bodies, though not in strict sense
Courts, which decide and settle the consumers disputes and
matter connected therewith by adhering to the provisions of
Civil Procedure Code and these consumer Courts arejudiciary set up by the government to protect the consumer
rights and would fall within the meaning of Section 3 of Indian
Evidence Act.
It is admitted fact that refund vouchers were similar to
Cheques and like Cheque books, refund vouchers printed in
the specialized format were given by the defendant bank to the
plaintiff for issuance thereof as is reflected in the answer to
question No. 21 and 25 given by the sole witness of the
plaintiff. In the particular period of time since there was no
system of payment of Cheque at par in all the branches of the
country, instrument of refund voucher payable at par all the
branches in the country was introduced by the defendant bank
and such facility was given to the plaintiff by the arrangement.
It is well settled that in order to decide whether a
decision in an earlier litigation operates as res judicata, the
Court must look at the nature of the litigation, what were the
issues raised therein and what was actually decided in it.
In the present case having gone through the pleading of
the parties and the evidence-on-record and the judgments
rendered by the said forums, in unequivocal term it is clear
that the issues involved in this suit were substantially the
issues before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission which stood decided by the judgment dated31.3.2008 which attained its finality with the merger of
judgment and order of the National Consumer Dispute
Redressal Commission.
In the context of the foregoing discussions, on critical
examination of the judgments of the said forums and
considering the nature of the litigation and the issues raised
and decided therein being similar to the facts and
circumstances of the instant case, the issues now cannot be
reopened and re-agitated as in my opinion the suit is barred by
the principle of res judicata within the meaning of Section 11 of
Code of Civil Procedure.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
ORIGINAL SIDE
Present: The Hon’ble Justice Shivakant Prasad
CS 175 of 2010
M/s. Kesoram Industries Limited V Allahabad Bank
Judgment on : 03.04.2017