A person pleading adverse possession has no equities
in his favour since he is trying to defeat the rights of the
true owner. It is for him to clearly plead and establish all
facts necessary to establish adverse possession. Though we
got this law of adverse possession from the British, it is
important to note that these days English Courts are taking
a very negative view towards the law of adverse possession.
The English law was amended and changed substantially to
reflect these changes, particularly in light of the view that
property is a human right adopted by the European
Commission. This Court in Revamma (supra) observed
that to understand the true nature of adverse
possession, Fairweather v. St Marylebone Property
Co [1962] 2 WLR 1020 : [1962] 2 All ER 288 can be 1
considered where House of Lords referring
to Taylor v. Twinberrow [1930] 2 K.B. 16 termed adverse
possession as a negative and consequential right effected
only because somebody else's positive right to access the
court is barred by operation of law. As against the rights of
the paper-owner, in the context of adverse possession, there
evolves a set of competing rights in favour of the adverse
possessor who has, for a long period of time, cared for the
land, developed it, as against the owner of the property who
has ignored the property.
36. The right to property is now considered to be not only
constitutional or statutory right but also a human right.
Human rights have already been considered in realm of
individual rights such as right to health, right to livelihood,
right to shelter and employment etc. But now human rights
are gaining a multi faceted dimension. Right to property is
also considered very much a part of the new dimension.
Therefore, even claim of adverse possession has to be read
in that context.
37. The changing attitude of the English Courts is quite
visible from the judgment of Beaulane Properties Ltd. v. 1
Palmer (2005) 3 WLR 554. The Court here tried to read the
human rights position in the context of adverse possession.
But what is commendable is that the dimension of human
rights have widened so much that now property dispute
issues are also being raised within the contours of human
rights. With the expanding jurisprudence of the European
Courts of Human Rights, the Court has taken an unkind
view to the concept of adverse possession.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
PETITION FOR SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL (CIVIL) NO.
28034/2011
(Arising out of CC 9038/2010)
State of Haryana V Mukesh Kumar & Ors.
Dated;September 30, 2011
Dalveer Bhandari, J.
Citation: AIR2012SC559,(2011)10SCC404,
Print Page
in his favour since he is trying to defeat the rights of the
true owner. It is for him to clearly plead and establish all
facts necessary to establish adverse possession. Though we
got this law of adverse possession from the British, it is
important to note that these days English Courts are taking
a very negative view towards the law of adverse possession.
The English law was amended and changed substantially to
reflect these changes, particularly in light of the view that
property is a human right adopted by the European
Commission. This Court in Revamma (supra) observed
that to understand the true nature of adverse
possession, Fairweather v. St Marylebone Property
Co [1962] 2 WLR 1020 : [1962] 2 All ER 288 can be 1
considered where House of Lords referring
to Taylor v. Twinberrow [1930] 2 K.B. 16 termed adverse
possession as a negative and consequential right effected
only because somebody else's positive right to access the
court is barred by operation of law. As against the rights of
the paper-owner, in the context of adverse possession, there
evolves a set of competing rights in favour of the adverse
possessor who has, for a long period of time, cared for the
land, developed it, as against the owner of the property who
has ignored the property.
36. The right to property is now considered to be not only
constitutional or statutory right but also a human right.
Human rights have already been considered in realm of
individual rights such as right to health, right to livelihood,
right to shelter and employment etc. But now human rights
are gaining a multi faceted dimension. Right to property is
also considered very much a part of the new dimension.
Therefore, even claim of adverse possession has to be read
in that context.
37. The changing attitude of the English Courts is quite
visible from the judgment of Beaulane Properties Ltd. v. 1
Palmer (2005) 3 WLR 554. The Court here tried to read the
human rights position in the context of adverse possession.
But what is commendable is that the dimension of human
rights have widened so much that now property dispute
issues are also being raised within the contours of human
rights. With the expanding jurisprudence of the European
Courts of Human Rights, the Court has taken an unkind
view to the concept of adverse possession.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
PETITION FOR SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL (CIVIL) NO.
28034/2011
(Arising out of CC 9038/2010)
State of Haryana V Mukesh Kumar & Ors.
Dated;September 30, 2011
Dalveer Bhandari, J.
Citation: AIR2012SC559,(2011)10SCC404,
