Showing posts with label O 14 R 2 of CPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label O 14 R 2 of CPC. Show all posts

Thursday, 17 March 2022

When the court should not decide issue of limitation as a preliminary issue?

 In a case, question of limitation can be decided based on admitted facts, it can be decided as a preliminary issue under Order 14 Rule 2(2)(b). Once facts are disputed about limitation, the determination of the question of limitation also cannot be made under Order 14 Rule 2(2) as a preliminary issue or any other such issue of law which requires examination of the disputed facts. In case of dispute as to facts, is necessary to be determined to give a finding on a question of law. Such question cannot be decided as a preliminary issue. In a case, the question of jurisdiction also depends upon the proof of facts which are disputed. It cannot be decided as a preliminary issue if the facts are disputed and the question of law is dependent upon the outcome of the investigation of facts, such question of law cannot be decided as a preliminary issue, is settled proposition of law either before the amendment of CPC and post amendment in the year 1976. {Para 52}

15. Since the determination of the issue of limitation in this case is not a pure question of law, it cannot be decided as preliminary issue under Order XIV Rule 2 of the CPC. 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Civil Appeal No 814 of 2022

M/s Mongia Realty and Buildwell Private Limited Vs Manik Sethi


Coram: Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud; Surya Kant, JJ.

Author: Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, J.

Dated: January 31, 2022

Print Page

Friday, 1 March 2019

Whether court can direct parties to include more properties in suit for partition?

 Party to the suit cannot be forced or compelled to include the properties which are found in Exhibits before the Court as is done in the present case. The Trial Court has misdirected itself while passing the impugned judgment in the present suit. The preliminary issue with regard to whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties and whether the suit of the plaintiffs is for partial partition as such the suit is not maintainable, are the issues which are to be answered along with other issues in the suit. The Trial Court fell into error in not answering all the issues. The Trial Court has committed an error in directing the parties to include the properties mentioned in Ex. D4 to Ex. D7. It is for the parties, either the plaintiffs or defendants to include the properties to the suit schedule for partition. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

Writ Petition No. 44513 of 2014 (GM-CPC)

Decided On: 06.08.2018

C.S. Sundaresha  Vs. C.S. Ananthalakshmi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Shankar Ganapathi Pandit, J.

Citation: AIR 2019 Karnat 5
Print Page

Tuesday, 12 February 2019

Whether it is mandatory for court to frame issue regarding maintainability of suit?

The learned Counsel for the appellant contends that as per Order 14, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the trial Court should have framed an issue on the basis of the plea taken by the defendants in their written statement that the suit is not maintainable on the ground that the deponent Mr. Surender Kumar had no special power of attorney on the date of signing the plaint and verification and the said Special Power of Attorney was executed subsequent to the date of filing of the suit. As such the suit is not maintainable and without framing an issue, the finding given by the trial Court that Surender Kumar as Manager was empowered to sign the plaint and verification is erroneous and therefore, the trial Court committed an error in not framing an issue with regard to the maintainability, which goes to the root of the matter irrespective of the fact that the plaintiff has merit in the case. It is mandatory on the part of the trial Court to frame an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit, but the trial Court has erred in giving a finding in the absence of any issue framed to that effect. Therefore, on these two grounds, the judgment and decree of the trial Court are liable to be set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD

CCCA No. 153 of 1987

Decided On: 30.10.2000

 Unitech Industrial Corporation  Vs. Arvind Engineering Co., Hyd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
E. Dharma Rao, J.

Citation: AIR 2001 AP 177
Print Page

Thursday, 27 December 2018

Whether court can frame issue at the time of final argument?

Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the impugned order of the learned trial Judge is not only illegal, but it is vitiated on account of material irregularity in exercise of jurisdiction. After the evidence had been closed and the parties were proceeding with the argument, the learned trial Judge had no jurisdiction to direct an additional issue to be raised and further evidence to be taken.

Order 14, Rule 1 C. P. C. provides--

"(1) Issues arise when a material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by the one party and denied by the other.

(2) Material propositions are those propositions of law or fact which a plaintiff must allege in order to show a right to sue or a defendant must allege in order to constitute his defence.

(3) x x x

(4) x x x

(5) At the first hearing of the suit the court shall, after reading the plaint and the written statements, if any, and after such examination of the parties as may appear necessary, ascertain upon what material propositions of fact or of law the parties are at variance, and shall thereupon proceed to frame and record the issues on which the right decision of the case appears to depend.

(6) x x x "

Rule 5 provides:--

"The court may, at any time before passing a decree, amend the issues or frame additional issues on such terms as it thinks fit, and all such amendments or additional issues as may be necessary for determining the matters in controversy between the parties shall be so made or framed."
5. Thus it is clear that the duty to frame issues is put on the court and power inheres in the court to amend existing issues or frame additional issues on such terms as the court thinks fit. In exercise of this power, the court while the arguments had begun, framed an additional issue and thought it fit to allow parties to lead evidence on the additional issue as it was necessary for determining the matter in controversy. The jurisdiction exercised by the court is in terms of Rule 5 (1) of Order 14 of the Code.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA

Civil Revn. No. 377 of 1969

Decided On: 21.09.1970

Kishorelal Gupta Vs. Devilal Kalwar alias Gowalla

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ranganath Misra, J.

Citation: AIR 1971 Orissa 191
Print Page

When it is mandatory for court to frame additional issue?

 Therefore, in the present case, when the defendant has taken an objection in the written statement that Surender Kumar had no authority to sign the plaint and verification and in the cross-examination the said Surender Kumar has admitted that on the date of signing the plaint and verifying the same, he had no special power of attorney, the trial Court should have framed an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit, which has to be decided in the first instance. Even though the trial Court has failed to frame an issue in the first instance, on the basis of the evidence adduced by DW1 that he had no power of attorney at the time of signing the plaint and verification and subsequent to the filing of the suit, the power of attorney was executed in his favour, in accordance with Rule 5 of Order 14, before passing a final decree, the trial Court has got the power to frame issues. When the defendant took an objection that Surender Kumar has no power of attorney to sign the plaint and on the other hand, though he has got letter of authority and that he is entitled to sign the plaint and verification, the trial Court should have framed an issue where one proposition of fact is affirmed by one party and denied by the other. Therefore, keeping this in mind, the trial Court should have exercised the power contemplated under Rule 5 by framing an issue with regard to authority of Surender Kumar to sign the plaint, inasmuch as this issue goes to the root of the matter. Without framing issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit and the authority of the deponent to sign the plaint and verification, trial Court should have not given a finding that deponent has got letter of authority to sign the plaint.

20. Viewed from any angle, the trial Court has committed an error in not framing an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit under Order 14, Rules 1 and 5 CPC and also giving a finding without there being any issue to that effect. Therefore, the trial Court has committed an error of law in delivering the judgment.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD

CCCA No. 153 of 1987

Decided On: 30.10.2000

Unitech Industrial Corporation  Vs.  Arvind Engineering Co., Hyd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
E. Dharma Rao, J.

Citation:AIR 2001 AP 177
Print Page

When issue of limitation should not be decided as preliminary issue?

The issue regarding bar of limitation can be disposed of as a preliminary issue under Order XIV, Rule 2(2) of the Civil Procedure Code only in cases where it can be disposed of as an issue of law and not otherwise. In cases where such an issue requires recording of evidence, it has to be disposed of along with the other issues except when the Court, in its opinion, thinks fit to postpone the settlement of the other issues till the disposal of the issue regarding jurisdiction or limitation. Undoubtedly, the Court in that regard has to exercise its discretion judiciously and considering the facts of each case.
Citation; 2003(3)BomCR814, 2003(2)MhLj219;2003 (1) ALL M R 674
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Civil Revision Appln. No. 752 of 2002
Decided On: 05.09.2002
Appellants: Shraddha Associates and Anr.
Vs.
Respondent: St. Patrick's Town Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. and Ors.

Print Page

Saturday, 22 December 2018

Whether plaint can be rejected if it is barred by limitation?

A plea of limitation cannot be decided as an abstract principle of law divorced from facts as in every case the starting point of limitation has to be ascertained which is entirely a question of fact. A plea of limitation is a mixed question of law and fact. The question whether the words "barred by law" occurring in Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC would also include the ground that it is barred by law of limitation has been recently considered by a two Judge Bench of this Court to which one of us was a member (Ashok Bhan J.) in Civil Appeal No. 4539 of 2003 (Balasaria Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Hanuman Seva Trust and Ors.) decided on 8.11.2005 and it was held: -

After hearing counsel for the parties, going through the plaint, application under Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC and the judgments of the trial court and the High Court, we are of the opinion that the present suit could not be dismissed as barred by limitation without proper pleadings, framing of an issue of limitation and taking of evidence. Question of limitation is a mixed question of law and fact. Ex facie in the present case on the reading of the paint it cannot be held that the suit is barred by time.
This principle would be equally applicable to a Company Petition. Therefore, unless it becomes apparent from the reading of the Company Petition that the same is barred by limitation the petition cannot be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4766 of 2001

Decided On: 11.07.2006

Ramesh B. Desai Vs.   Bipin Vadilal Mehta and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashok Bhan and G.P. Mathur, JJ.

Citation: (2006) 5 SCC 638
Print Page

Friday, 4 May 2018

What is scope of inquiry while deciding application for rejection of plaint?

The High Court dealt with the violations referred to above extensively so as to find out whether a cause of action is made out, but committed a grave error by considering the explanations offered in the replies filed by the Respondents. All the three violations have been discussed meticulously by the High Court with reference to the replies furnished by the Respondents and the court came to the conclusion that the petition did not disclose any cause of action since it lacked material facts. The High Court ventured into such an elaborate enquiry in the light of the pleadings in the replies, to see whether the result of the election has been materially affected, apparently or rather mistakenly, under Order XIV Rule 2.

6. Order XIV deals with settlement of issues and determination of suit on issues of law or on issues agreed upon. Order XIV Rule 2 provides for disposal of a suit on a preliminary issue and under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 2, if the court is of opinion that a case or part thereof can be disposed of on an issue of law only, it may try that issue first, in case it relates to jurisdiction of the court or bar to entertaining the suit. After the 1976 amendment, the scope of a preliminary issue under Order XIV Rule 2(2) is limited only to two areas, one is jurisdiction of the court, and the other, bar to the suit as created by any law for the time being in force. The whole purpose of trial on preliminary issue is to save time and money. Though it is not a mini trial, the court can and has to look into the entire pleadings and the materials available on record, to the extent not in dispute. But that is not the situation as far as the enquiry under Order VII Rule 11 is concerned. That is only on institutional defects. The court can only see whether the plaint, or rather the pleadings of the Plaintiff, constitute a cause of action. Pleadings in the sense where, even after the stage of written statement, if there is a replication filed, in a given situation the same also can be looked into to see whether there is any admission on the part of the Plaintiff. In other words, under Order VII Rule 11, the court has to take a decision looking at the pleadings of the Plaintiff only and not on the rebuttal made by the Defendant or any other materials produced by the Defendant.

7. It appears, the High Court committed a mistake in the present case, since four out of the six issues settled were taken as the preliminary issues. Two such issues actually are relatable only to Order VII Rule 11 of the Code, in the sense those issues pertained to the rejection at the institution stage for lack of material facts and for not disclosing a cause of action. Merely because it is a trial on preliminary issues at the stage of Order XIV, the scope does not change or expand. The stage at which such an enquiry is undertaken by the court makes no difference since an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code can be taken up at any stage.

8. Thus, for an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11 (a), only the pleadings of the Plaintiff-Petitioner can be looked into even if it is at the stage of trial of preliminary issues under Order XIV Rule 2(2). But the entire pleadings on both sides can be looked into under Order XIV Rule 2(2) to see whether the court has jurisdiction and whether there is a bar for entertaining the suit.

9. In the present case, the issue relates to an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code, and hence, there is no question of a preliminary issue being tried under Order XIV Rule 2(2) of the Code. The court exercised its jurisdiction only Under Section 83(1) (a) of the Act read with Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code. Since the scope of the enquiry at that stage has to be limited only to the pleadings of the Plaintiff, neither the written statement nor the averments, if any, filed by the opposite party for rejection under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code or any other pleadings of the Respondents can be considered for that purpose.

10. In Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. and Ors. v. Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express and Ors. MANU/SC/8083/2006 : (2006) 3 SCC 100, this Court has dealt with a similar issue. To the extent relevant, paragraph-12 reads as follows:

12.From the aforesaid, it is apparent that the plaint cannot be rejected on the basis of the allegations made by the Defendant in his written statement or in an application for rejection of the plaint. The court has to read the entire plaint as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause of action and if it does, then the plaint cannot be rejected by the court exercising the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code. Essentially, whether the plaint discloses a cause of action, is a question of fact which has to be gathered on the basis of the averments made in the plaint in its entirety taking those averments to be correct. A cause of action is a bundle of facts which are required to be proved for obtaining relief and for the said purpose, the material facts are required to be stated but not the evidence except in certain cases where the pleadings relied on are in regard to misrepresentation, fraud, wilful default, undue influence or of the same nature. So long as the plaint discloses some cause of action which requires determination by the court, the mere fact that in the opinion of the Judge the Plaintiff may not succeed cannot be a ground for rejection of the plaint.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4080 of 2014

Decided On: 24.01.2017

 Kuldeep Singh Pathania Vs. Bikram Singh Jaryal

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Kurian Joseph and A.M. Khanwilkar, JJ.

Citation: 2017(6) MHLJ 33
Print Page

Saturday, 25 July 2015

When court should not decide issue of limitation as preliminary issue?

 Be it stated, the aforesaid pronouncement was made
before the amendment of the Code of Civil Procedure in 1976.
18. In Ramesh D. Desai and others v. Bipin Vadilal
Mehta and others3
, while dealing with the issue of limitation,
the Court opined that a plea of limitation cannot be decided as
an abstract principle of law divorced from facts as in every
case the starting point of limitation has to be ascertained
which is entirely a question of fact. The Court further
proceeded to state that a plea of limitation is a mixed question
of fact and law. On a plain consideration of the language
employed in sub-rule (2) of Order 14 it can be stated with
3 (2006) 5 SCC 638
certitude that when an issue requires an inquiry into facts it
cannot be tried as a preliminary issue. In the said judgment
the Court opined as follows: -
“13. Sub-rule (2) of Order 14 Rule 2 CPC lays down
that where issues both of law and of fact arise in the
same suit, and the court is of the opinion that the
case or any part thereof may be disposed of on an
issue of law only, it may try that issue first if that
issue relates to (a) the jurisdiction of the court, or (b)
a bar to the suit created by any law for the time
being in force. The provisions of this Rule came up
for consideration before this Court in Major S.S.
Khanna v. Brig. F.J. Dillon and it was held as under:
(SCR p. 421)
“Under Order 14 Rule 2, Code of Civil Procedure
where issues both of law and of fact arise in the
same suit, and the court is of opinion that the
case or any part thereof may be disposed of on
the issues of law only, it shall try those issues
first, and for that purpose may, if it thinks fit,
postpone the settlement of the issues of fact
until after the issues of law have been
determined. The jurisdiction to try issues of law
apart from the issues of fact may be exercised
only where in the opinion of the court the whole
suit may be disposed of on the issues of law
alone, but the Code confers no jurisdiction upon
the court to try a suit on mixed issues of law
and fact as preliminary issues. Normally all the
issues in a suit should be tried by the court; not
to do so, especially when the decision on issues
even of law depend upon the decision of issues
of fact, would result in a lopsided trial of the
suit.”
Though there has been a slight amendment in the
language of Order 14 Rule 2 CPC by the amending
Act, 1976 but the principle enunciated in the
abovequoted decision still holds good and there can
be no departure from the principle that the Code
confers no jurisdiction upon the court to try a suit on
mixed issues of law and fact as a preliminary issue
and where the decision on issue of law depends
upon decision of fact, it cannot be tried as a
preliminary issue.”
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CIVIL APPEAL NO. 5954 2014
(Arising out of S.L.P. (Civil) No. 33200 of 2014)

Satti Paradesi Samadhi & Philliar Temple  V M. Sankuntala (D) Tr. Lrs.

Citation;(2015) 5 SCC674
Dipak Misra

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 December 2013

Whether court should frame preliminary issue on ground of non-disclosure of cause of action?

In this respect Mr. Usgaonkar has also rightly contended that preliminary issues can be framed by the Court only in two cases, namely on the ground of lack of jurisdiction and secondly on the quest ion of a bar of the suit created by any law in terms of Order 14, Rule 2(2) of C.P.C. No preliminary issue can thus be framed on the ground of non-disclosure of cause of action and the preliminary issue can be framed only on a pure question of law and not on a mixed question of law and facts. It is discretionary on the part of the Court to try any preliminary issue when an occasion arises either at a preliminary stage or at the time of the final decision on merits. I am entirely inclined to agree with this contention of the learned counsel which seems to find full support in the law.

Bombay High Court
P.R. Sukeshwala And Another vs Dr. Devadatta V.S. Kerkar And ... on 10 August, 1994
Equivalent citations: AIR 1995 Bom 227, 1995 (4) BomCR 89, (1994) 96 BOMLR 15
Bench: . E Silva
Print Page