Showing posts with label O 7 R 6 of CPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label O 7 R 6 of CPC. Show all posts

Thursday, 2 April 2020

Whether a party can claim exemption from law of limitation in absence of pleading and proof as per O 7 R 6 of CPC?

The provisions of Sections 4 to 20 of limitation Act are exceptions when suit beyond the period of limitation as prescribed in the Schedule shall not be dismissed as required by Section 3. In this context, we need to refer to Order VII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Order VII deals with plaint. Order VII Rule 6 contains a heading "Grounds of exemption from limitation law". Order VII Rule 6 is as follows:

6. Grounds of exemption from limitation law. - Where the suit is instituted after the expiration of the period prescribed by the law of limitation, the plaint shall show the ground upon which exemption from such law is claimed:

Provided that the Court may permit the Plaintiff to claim exemption from the law of limitation on any ground not set out in the plaint, if such ground is not inconsistent with the grounds set out in the plaint.

12. Order VII Rule 6 uses the words "the plaint shall show the ground upon which exemption from such law is claimed". The exemption provided Under Sections 4 to 20 of the Limitation Act, 1963 are based on certain facts and events. Section 19, with which we are concerned, provide for a fresh period of limitation, which is founded on certain facts, i.e., (i) whether payment on account of debt or of interest on legacy is made before the expiration of the prescribed period by the person liable to pay the debt or legacy, (ii) an acknowledgement of the payment appears in the handwriting of, or in a writing signed by, the person making the payment. We may notice the judgment of this Court dealing with Section 20 of the Limitation Act, 1908, which was akin to present Section 19 of the Limitation Act, 1963. In Sant Lal Mahton v. Kamla Prasad and Ors. MANU/SC/0043/1951 : AIR 1951 SC 477, this Court held that for applicability of Section 20 of the Limitation Act, 1908, two conditions were essential that the payment must be made within the prescribed period of limitation and it must be acknowledged by some form of writing either in the handwriting of the payer himself or signed by him. This Court further held that for claiming benefit of exemption Under Section 20, there has to be pleading and proof. In paragraphs 9 and 10, following has been laid down:

9. It would be clear, we think, from the language of Section 20, Limitation Act, that to attract its operation two conditions are essential: first, the payment must be made within the prescribed period of limitation and secondly, it must be acknowledged by some form of writing either in the handwriting of the payer himself or signed by him. We agree with the Subordinate Judge that it is the payment which really extends the period of limitation Under Section 20, Limitation Act; but the payment has got to be proved in a particular way and for reason of policy the legislature insists on a written or signed acknowledgment as the only proof of payment and excludes oral testimony. Unless, therefore, there is acknowledgment in the required form, the payment by itself is of no avail. The Subordinate Judge, however, is right in holding that while the Section requires that the payment should be made within the period of limitation, it does not require that the acknowledgment should also be made within that period. To interpret the proviso in that way would be to import into it certain words which do not occur there. This is the view taken by almost all the High Courts in India and to us it seems to be a proper view to take (See Md. Moizuddin v. Nalini Bala MANU/WB/0020/1937 : A.I.R. (24) 1937 Cal 284 : I.L.R. (1937) 2 Cal. 137; Lal Singh v. Gulab Rai MANU/UP/0303/1932 : 55 All 280, Venkata Subbhu v. Appu Sundaram 17 Mad. 92, Ram Prasad v. Mohan Lal A.I.R. (10) 1923 Nag 117 and Viswanath v. Mahadeo 57 Bom. 453.

10. ...If the Plaintiff's right of action is apparently barred under the Statute of limitation, Order 7, Rule 6, Code of Civil Procedure makes it his duty to state specifically in the plaint the grounds of exemption allowed by the Limitation Act upon which he relies to exclude its operation; and if the Plaintiff has got to allege in his plaint the facts which entitle him to exemption, obviously these facts must be in existence at or before the time when the plaint is filed; facts which come into existence after the filing of the plaint cannot be called in aid to revive a right of action which was dead at the date of the suit. To claim exemption Under Section 20. Limitation Act the Plaintiff must be in a position to allege and prove not only that there was payment of interest on a debt or part payment of the principal, but that such payment had been acknowledged in writing in the manner contemplated by that section....

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Review Petition (C) Nos. 786-787 of 2019 in Civil Appeal Nos. 8442-8443 of 2016, 

Decided On: 18.12.2019

Shanti Conductors (P) Ltd. Vs.  Assam State Electricity Board 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashok Bhushan, S. Abdul Nazeer and Navin Sinha, JJ.

Citation: (2020) 2 SCC 677.
Print Page

Sunday, 10 January 2016

Whether plaintiff can claim Judgment on admission as matter of right?

9. The words in Order XII Rule 6 CPC “may” and
“make such order…” show that the power under Order XII
Rule 6 CPC is discretionary and cannot be claimed as a
matter of right. Judgment on admission is not a matter of
right and rather is a matter of discretion of the Court. Where
the defendants have raised objections which go to the root of
the case, it would not be appropriate to exercise the
discretion under Order XII Rule 6 CPC. The said rule is an
enabling provision which confers discretion on the Court in
delivering a quick judgment on admission and to the extent
of the claim admitted by one of the parties of his opponent’s
claim. In the suit for eviction filed by the
respondent-landlord, appellant-tenant has admitted the
relationship of tenancy and the period of lease agreement;
but resisted respondent-plaintiff’s claim by setting up a
defence plea of agreement to sale and that he paid an
advance of Rs.82.50 lakhs, which of course is stoutly denied
by the respondent-landlord. The appellant-defendant also
filed the Suit for Specific Performance, which of course is
contested by the respondent-landlord. When such issues

arising between the parties ought to be decided, mere
admission of relationship of landlord and tenant cannot be
said to be an unequivocal admission to decree the suit under
Order XII Rule 6 CPC.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 6106-6108 OF 2015

S.M. ASIF V VIRENDER KUMAR BAJAJ 
Dated: August 12, 2015
 R. BANUMATHI, J.
Citation;(2015) 9 SCC287,2016(2) MHLJ510
Print Page