Showing posts with label O7 R11. Show all posts
Showing posts with label O7 R11. Show all posts

Friday, 4 May 2018

What is scope of inquiry while deciding application for rejection of plaint?

The High Court dealt with the violations referred to above extensively so as to find out whether a cause of action is made out, but committed a grave error by considering the explanations offered in the replies filed by the Respondents. All the three violations have been discussed meticulously by the High Court with reference to the replies furnished by the Respondents and the court came to the conclusion that the petition did not disclose any cause of action since it lacked material facts. The High Court ventured into such an elaborate enquiry in the light of the pleadings in the replies, to see whether the result of the election has been materially affected, apparently or rather mistakenly, under Order XIV Rule 2.

6. Order XIV deals with settlement of issues and determination of suit on issues of law or on issues agreed upon. Order XIV Rule 2 provides for disposal of a suit on a preliminary issue and under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 2, if the court is of opinion that a case or part thereof can be disposed of on an issue of law only, it may try that issue first, in case it relates to jurisdiction of the court or bar to entertaining the suit. After the 1976 amendment, the scope of a preliminary issue under Order XIV Rule 2(2) is limited only to two areas, one is jurisdiction of the court, and the other, bar to the suit as created by any law for the time being in force. The whole purpose of trial on preliminary issue is to save time and money. Though it is not a mini trial, the court can and has to look into the entire pleadings and the materials available on record, to the extent not in dispute. But that is not the situation as far as the enquiry under Order VII Rule 11 is concerned. That is only on institutional defects. The court can only see whether the plaint, or rather the pleadings of the Plaintiff, constitute a cause of action. Pleadings in the sense where, even after the stage of written statement, if there is a replication filed, in a given situation the same also can be looked into to see whether there is any admission on the part of the Plaintiff. In other words, under Order VII Rule 11, the court has to take a decision looking at the pleadings of the Plaintiff only and not on the rebuttal made by the Defendant or any other materials produced by the Defendant.

7. It appears, the High Court committed a mistake in the present case, since four out of the six issues settled were taken as the preliminary issues. Two such issues actually are relatable only to Order VII Rule 11 of the Code, in the sense those issues pertained to the rejection at the institution stage for lack of material facts and for not disclosing a cause of action. Merely because it is a trial on preliminary issues at the stage of Order XIV, the scope does not change or expand. The stage at which such an enquiry is undertaken by the court makes no difference since an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code can be taken up at any stage.

8. Thus, for an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11 (a), only the pleadings of the Plaintiff-Petitioner can be looked into even if it is at the stage of trial of preliminary issues under Order XIV Rule 2(2). But the entire pleadings on both sides can be looked into under Order XIV Rule 2(2) to see whether the court has jurisdiction and whether there is a bar for entertaining the suit.

9. In the present case, the issue relates to an enquiry under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code, and hence, there is no question of a preliminary issue being tried under Order XIV Rule 2(2) of the Code. The court exercised its jurisdiction only Under Section 83(1) (a) of the Act read with Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code. Since the scope of the enquiry at that stage has to be limited only to the pleadings of the Plaintiff, neither the written statement nor the averments, if any, filed by the opposite party for rejection under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code or any other pleadings of the Respondents can be considered for that purpose.

10. In Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. and Ors. v. Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express and Ors. MANU/SC/8083/2006 : (2006) 3 SCC 100, this Court has dealt with a similar issue. To the extent relevant, paragraph-12 reads as follows:

12.From the aforesaid, it is apparent that the plaint cannot be rejected on the basis of the allegations made by the Defendant in his written statement or in an application for rejection of the plaint. The court has to read the entire plaint as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause of action and if it does, then the plaint cannot be rejected by the court exercising the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code. Essentially, whether the plaint discloses a cause of action, is a question of fact which has to be gathered on the basis of the averments made in the plaint in its entirety taking those averments to be correct. A cause of action is a bundle of facts which are required to be proved for obtaining relief and for the said purpose, the material facts are required to be stated but not the evidence except in certain cases where the pleadings relied on are in regard to misrepresentation, fraud, wilful default, undue influence or of the same nature. So long as the plaint discloses some cause of action which requires determination by the court, the mere fact that in the opinion of the Judge the Plaintiff may not succeed cannot be a ground for rejection of the plaint.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4080 of 2014

Decided On: 24.01.2017

 Kuldeep Singh Pathania Vs. Bikram Singh Jaryal

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Kurian Joseph and A.M. Khanwilkar, JJ.

Citation: 2017(6) MHLJ 33
Print Page

Wednesday, 30 August 2017

Whether application for rejection of plaint can be decided along with suit?



First Respondent filed an Election Petition challenging election of Appellant. On receipt of notice in Election Petition, Appellant filed Annexure-P/4-application for rejection of Petition, under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC, by way of a counter affidavit. Court declined to consider same on ground that there was no formal application and hence proceeded with trial. At that stage, Appellant filed Annexure-P/5-formal application for rejection of Election Petition on ground that Election Petition did not disclose any cause of action. That application as per impugned order was posted along with main petition. 



Held, while disposing of the Appeals: 



1. Stand taken by High Court in impugned order cannot be appreciated. An application under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC, can be filed at any stage, as held by this Court in Sopan Sukhdeo Sable and Ors. v. Assistant Charity Commissioner and Ors. MANU/SC/0071/2004. Only restriction is that the consideration of application for rejection should not be on basis of allegations made by Defendant in his written statement or on basis of allegations in application for rejection of plaint. Court has to consider only plaint as a whole, and in case, entire plaint comes under situations covered by Order VII Rule 11(a) to (f) of CPC, the same has to be rejected.[5] 2. Once an application is filed under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC, Court has to dispose of same before proceeding with trial. There is no point or sense in proceeding with trial of the case, in case the plaint (Election Petition in present case) is only to be rejected at threshold.[6] 3. Procedure adopted by Court is not warranted under law. Without disposing of an application under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC, the court could not proceed with trial. In that view of matter, impugned order was set aside. [9] 


The procedure adopted by the court is not warranted under law. Without disposing of an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court cannot proceed with the trial. In that view of the matter, the impugned order is only to be set aside. Ordered accordingly.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA


Civil Appeal No. 5540 of 2016 



Decided On: 04.07.2016




R.K. Roja Vs. U.S. Rayudu and Ors.



Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Kurian Joseph and Rohinton Fali Nariman, JJ.



Citation: AIR 2016 SC 3282,(2016)14 SCC 14

Print Page

Saturday, 12 March 2016

Supreme court:Plaint should be rejected in exceptional circumstances

Rejection of the plaint under Order VII rule 11 of the CPC is a drastic power conferred in the court to terminate a civil action at the threshold. The conditions precedent to the exercise of power under Order VII rule 11, therefore, are stringent and have been consistently held to be so by the Court. It is the averments in the plaint that has to be read as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause of action or whether the suit is barred under any law. At the stage of exercise of power under Order VII rule 11, the stand of the defendants in the written statement or in the application for rejection of the plaint is wholly immaterial. It is only if the averments in the plaint ex facie do not disclose a cause of action or on a reading thereof the suit appears to be barred under any law the plaint can be rejected. In all other situations, the claims will have to be adjudicated in the course of the trial.
Supreme Court of India
P.V. Guru Raj Reddy & Anr vs P. Neeradha Reddy & Ors on 13 February, 2015
Bench: Ranjan Gogoi, Prafulla C. Pant
                                                                    REPORTABLE

               IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
               CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
               CIVIL APPEAL NO.5254 OF 2006

Citation;2016(2) MHLJ 15 SC
Print Page

Sunday, 22 February 2015

Basic principles for deciding application for rejection of plaint



Rejection of the plaint under Order VII rule 11 of
the CPC is a drastic power conferred in the court to
terminate a civil action at the threshold.
The conditions
precedent to the exercise of power under Order VII rule 11,
therefore, are stringent and have been consistently held to
be so by the Court. It is the averments in the plaint that has
to be read as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause
of action or whether the suit is barred under any law. At the
stage of exercise of power under Order VII rule 11, the stand
of the defendants in the written statement or in the
application for rejection of the plaint is wholly immaterial. It
is only if the averments in the plaint ex facie do not disclose
a cause of action or on a reading thereof the suit appears to

be barred under any law the plaint can be rejected. In all
other situations, the claims will have to be adjudicated in the
course of the trial.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.5254 OF 2006
P.V. GURU RAJ REDDY REP. BY
GPA LAXMI NARAYAN REDDY & ANR.

VERSUS
P. NEERADHA REDDY & ORS. ETC.
Dated;FEBRUARY 13, 2015.
RANJAN GOGOI, J.
Print Page