Showing posts with label Ready Reckoner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ready Reckoner. Show all posts

Sunday, 29 January 2023

Whether the court determine compensation for land acquisition on the basis of ready reckoner rates?

  Thus, there may be various factors, which are required to be

considered for determining the market value of the land. The market value of the land depends upon the location of the land; area of the land; whether the land is in a developed area or not; whether the acquisition is of a small plot of land or a big chunk of land and number of other advantageous and disadvantageous factors are required to be considered. Therefore, there cannot be the same market value for the different lands while determining the compensation for the lands acquired under the Land Acquisition Act. Therefore, the rates mentioned in the Ready Reckoner, which are basically for the purpose of collection of stamp duty and as observed hereinabove, which are the uniform rates for all the lands in the area, cannot be the basis for determination of the compensation for the lands acquired under the Land Acquisition Act. Therefore, the High Court has committed a serious error in enhancing the amount of compensation by 800% from Rs. 21/- per sq. ft. to Rs.174/- per sq. ft. relying upon and/or considering the rates mentioned in the Ready Reckoner. {Para 11}

12. Now, so far as the reliance placed upon the Government

Resolution dated 31.10.1994 by the claimants as well as the High Court is concerned, apart from the fact that the same is contrary to the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid two decisions, what is mentioned in the said Government Resolution is that the Ready Reckoner is scientifically prepared by taking into account the geographical conditions of each area, major roads, railways, etc., as well as by inspecting the information of buying and selling transactions and that the Ready Reckoner rates are based on the talukas in rural areas and the urban areas in different parts of the city. As observed hereinabove, there cannot be a uniform market value of the land for the purpose of determination of the compensation for the lands acquired under the Land Acquisition Act. As observed herein above, the market value of the different lands vary from place to place and it depends upon various factors as observed hereinabove.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3478 OF 2022

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited Vs M/s. Nemichand Damodardas & Anr.

Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Dated: JULY 11, 2022. 

Print Page

Saturday, 28 May 2016

Whether authorities under Stamp Act are bound by rates mentioned in Ready Reckoner?

 It would also be apposite to refer to the Judgments cited by
the learned Government Pleader in support of his contentions that the
rates mentioned in the Ready Reckoner are guidelines to the registering
authority   for   the   imposition   of   stamp   duty.     The   Judgment   of   the
Division   Bench   of   this   Court   in   the   case   of  Solapur   Promoters   and
Builders Association (supra)  was concerning the development charges
which are to be levied under Chapter VI­A of the Maharashtra Regional
Town Planning Act.  The imposition of charges at flat rate regardless of
location of land was challenged on the ground that it was violative of
Article   14   of   the   Constitution   of   India.     In   support   of   the   said
contention, reliance was sought to be placed on the rates mentioned in
the annual statement of rates published by the State Government i.e.

the Ready Reckoner rates.   The Division Bench held that the reliance
placed by the Petitioner in the said Petition on the Ready Reckoner
which   is   device   for   the   purpose   of   imposition   of   stamp   duty   was
misplaced as a Ready Reckoner provides guidelines to the registering
authorities for the imposition of stamp duty which is depending upon
the market value of the property.  Now coming to the Judgment of the
Division Bench of this Court in the case of  Prasadnagar Co­operative
(supra) the quashing and setting aside of the Ready Reckoner rates and
the amendment thereto in respect of the Petitioner's layout situated at
Jaitala, Nagpur was sought.   The Division Bench, whilst allowing the
Petition,   directed   the   Respondents   to   treat   the   Ready   Reckoner   as
guidelines and as a declaration of prima facie market value.
Hence,   by   the   Judgments  (supra),   this   Court   has   treated   the
Ready Reckoner as merely guidelines for the purposes of imposition of
the   stamp   duty,   as   the   same   depends   on   the   market   value   of   the
property.
18) In the instant case, as indicated above, it is an undisputed
fact that the Petitioner's property which is the subject matter of the
Indenture is situated in the “Phoenix Mills Compound” and bears CTS
Nos.1/142, 71 and 109.  The question is whether the said instrument is
to be charged on the basis of Value Zone 12/91 or Value Zone 12/91G

as contained in the Ready Reckoner.  In the said context, it is required to
be noted that by the Value Zone 12/91G all the properties of Phoenix
Mills are covered meaning thereby that the Phoenix Mills Compound is
treated as an entity by itself considering the commercial value of the
properties   situated   therein   and   is   therefore   placed   in   Value   Zone
12/91G which is to be considered whilst adjudicating the stamp duty
that is payable in respect of the instrument which is in respect of a
property   situated   therein.     Hence,   though   the   CTS   numbers   of   the
Petitioner's property are placed in Value Zone 12/91, which attracts a
lesser stamp duty, the Petitioner would be liable to pay stamp duty as
per Value Zone 12/91G as the Phoenix Mills Compound is treated as an
entity by itself and therefore, though a part of the property in the said
Phoenix Mills Compound is placed in Value Zone 12/91, the same is
obviously a mistake which has been corrected by issuance of the letter
dated 10th  January, 2012 of the Deputy Director of Town Planning,
Mumbai.
19) Insofar   as  the   adjudication   by   the   Respondent   No.  1   is
concerned, the fact is that the rates mentioned in the Ready Reckoner
are guidelines to the registering authorities for the adjudication of the
stamp duty, the Respondent No. 1 or for that matter even the Collector
of Stamps would therefore not be bound by the rates mentioned in the

Ready Reckoner and even if there were not to be any correction as in
the instant case, by which correction, the CTS numbers of the Petitioner
are now included in Value Zone 12/91G, the Respondent No. 1 would
still   be   entitled   to   rely   upon   the   said   Value   Zone   12/91G   for   the
purposes of calculating the stamp duty payable on the said Indenture as
the Petitioner's property is undisputedly situated in the Phoenix Mills
Compound.   Hence, there is no question of the amendment to Value
Zone 12/91G being applied retrospectively.  It is required to be noted
that the powers of the authorities under the Stamp Act are wide enough
and cannot be fettered by the rates mentioned in the Ready Reckoner.

IN  THE  HIGH  COURT  OF  JUDICATURE  AT  BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 4036 OF 2013
CR Retail Malls (India) Limited
versus
Chief Controlling Revenue 
CORAM :­ R. M. SAVANT, J.

PRONOUNCED ON :­ JULY 9 , 2014
Citation: 2016(2) ALLMR 289
Print Page

Wednesday, 15 January 2014

Whether ready reckoner should be used for determining compensation under land acquisition Act?


 It was submitted by Mr. Jamdar as well as Mr. Patil, AGP, that the Reference Court was in error in relying upon the GR dated 31/10/1994. We do 20
not find any force in these submissions. If the Government of Maharashtra in its wisdom has laid down a policy for offering compensation to the owners of the land which has been acquired for public purposes, it would be proper for the Reference Court to rely upon such a policy as well. The said GR clearly states that the compensation for the acquired land is to be granted on the basis of the valuation of the land by way of sale-purchase transaction method and the valuation as per ready reckoner, whichever is higher. On the date of the publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, the rate prescribed in the ready reckoner by the Government is found to be higher than the market rate as reflected in the sale transactions, it would be necessary that the Reference Court grants market rate on the basis of the valuation as appearing in the ready reckoner. The Government Resolution clearly speaks of the State's intention to offer a better/higher price of land which is acquired for public purposes. It would be, therefore, appropriate that the market rate in the instant case is fixed by following the GR dated 31/10/1994 and in our opinion the Reference Court did not commit any error in relying upon the same.

Bombay High Court
Shalini Vaman Godbole vs Special Land Acquisition Officer on 22 June, 2009
Bench: B.H. Marlapalle, S.J. Vazifdar
Citation;2009(111)BOMLR2759 ;2009 LAC515 bom
Print Page